The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology
Unit 1 social psychology practical: independent investigation guide
Designing, conducting and writing up a questionnaire on obedience or conformity. Work through the seven steps in order: read the guidance, draft your own answer in the boxes, and use the sentence starters if you are stuck. Step 5 has practice data so you can try the calculations and the coding first, with answers to check against.
Independent research brief
In this practical, you are the researcher. Your topic is bounded to a questionnaire or interview on obedience or conformity that looks for a difference, for example between males and females. You formulate your own research aim, select your own sample, write your own questionnaire items, gather your own raw primary data, carry out your own statistical and qualitative analyses, and hand in a full psychological report (its sections are set out in Step 7) to your teacher.
Note: the drafting boxes on this page let you plan your work here. What you type is saved in this browser only, on this device. Copy your drafts into your report document before you switch devices or clear your browser.
Mandatory project requirements
- Topic boundary: a questionnaire or interview on obedience or conformity that looks for a difference, for example between males and females (perceived obedience of others, self-rated obedience, or going along with a group). Choose one of the ideas in Step 1 or your own, and check it with your teacher. If you interview people, use a structured interview: you read the questionnaire aloud and record the answers.
- Sample size: a minimum of 10 to 20 participants. If gender is what you compare, include a deliberate mix of males and females.
- Quantitative tool: closed questions (rating scales from 1 to 5 or 1 to 10), including at least one reverse-scored item to control for acquiescence response bias.
- Qualitative tool: at least one open question or a short story-completion scenario, to capture descriptive narratives.
- Data analysis: full descriptive statistics (mean, median, mode, range, standard deviation), a summary bar chart, and a six-step thematic analysis of the qualitative text.
- Final output: a formal written report that follows psychological conventions (abstract, introduction, method, results, discussion, references and appendices).
Step 1: Selecting an aim and writing hypotheses
An aim is a broad statement of what you intend to investigate. Review the ideas below, or develop your own within obedience or conformity.
- Idea A: Gender and obedience at school (the example used for the practice data on this page). Do male and female students differ in how likely they say they are to follow everyday instructions from a teacher? About eight instructions, such as "put your phone away", "pick up that litter" or "swap seats", each rated from 1 to 10, with one reverse-scored item and the open question "What makes you more likely to follow an instruction?". Links: Milgram (his variation with female participants also found 65% obedience), Burger (2009: no significant difference between men and women), social power theory and agency theory.
- Idea B: Gender and conformity in group chats. Do males and females differ in how likely they say they are to go along with their friends' opinions online? Links: Asch (1951) and normative social influence.
- Idea C: Teacher or older student? Do students say they would obey a teacher more than a prefect giving the same instruction? Everyone rates both versions (repeated measures), with the order counterbalanced: half rate the teacher version first, half the prefect version first. Links: Milgram's Experiment 13 (an ordinary man gives orders: obedience fell to 20%) and legitimate power (social power theory).
- Idea D: Year group and peer conformity. Do younger and older students differ in how much they say they follow their friends? Links: Haun et al. (2014) and Asch.
- Idea E: Your own idea. Any questionnaire or interview on obedience or conformity that compares two groups or two conditions. Check it with your teacher before you start.
Student task 1: draft your aim and hypotheses
Your hypothesis can be directional (one-tailed) or non-directional (two-tailed): base the choice on prior research, and operationalise both variables completely.
Guidance: directional or non-directional?
When to use a directional hypothesis: if your rationale rests on social role theory (which predicts that females will be seen as, or will see themselves as, more compliant, because of the roles they are traditionally expected to take), you can write a one-tailed hypothesis predicting higher obedience for females.
When to use a non-directional hypothesis: Milgram's variation with 40 female participants found the same obedience rate as with men (65%), and Burger (2009) found no significant difference between men and women. If you cite these findings, the earlier research does not point one way, so a two-tailed hypothesis predicting "a difference" without a direction is more scientifically sound.
Self-assessment: is your hypothesis operationalised?
- Does it state both groups being compared (for example, males and females)?
- Does it name the measurement tool clearly (for example, "total score out of 80 on eight instructions rated 1 to 10" or "mean rating on a 1 to 5 agreement scale")?
- Does your null hypothesis state that any difference is "due to chance factors"?
Sentence starters for task 1
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "The aim of this investigation is to find out whether … differ in …"
- "There will be a significant difference in …, measured as the total score out of … on …, between … and …"
- "Participants who are … will have higher …, measured as …, than participants who are …"
- "My hypothesis is directional / non-directional because previous research by … found that …"
- "There will be no significant difference in … between … and …; any difference will be due to chance factors."
Step 2: Defining your target population and sampling technique
To investigate a difference between two groups, such as males and females, your sample must contain a deliberate balance of both. Consider which technique best suits your setting:
- Stratified sampling
- Working out the exact proportion of each sub-group in your school (for example, 52% female and 48% male) and choosing participants at random within each sub-group to mirror that ratio. High representativeness; time-consuming.
- Random sampling
- Every member of the target population has an equal chance of being chosen, for example by numbering a full list and using a random number generator. Avoids researcher bias; needs a complete list.
- Opportunity sampling
- Approaching people who are available in the common room, library or canteen at break. Fast and practical; risk of researcher bias and unrepresentative sub-groups.
- Volunteer (self-selected) sampling
- Putting up a poster or sharing a link that invites people to complete your questionnaire. Willing participants who have opted in; volunteer bias.
Student task 2: plan your sampling strategy
Guidance: describing your sampling technique
Exam questions often ask you to describe the sampling technique you used in your practical. Always include: (1) the technical name, (2) exactly where and how you recruited people, and (3) the make-up of the sample, for example "6 males and 6 females aged 16 to 17, recruited by opportunity sampling in the student canteen".
Sentence starters for task 2
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "My target population is …, and my sample will be … participants (… and …)."
- "I will use … sampling: I will … in / from … by …"
- "I chose … sampling rather than … because …"
- "One strength of this method for my study is that …, which means …"
- "One weakness is that …, so my sample may not represent …, which makes my findings harder to generalise to …"
Step 3: Questionnaire construction: controlling questionnaire biases
- Acquiescence response bias
- The tendency to agree with statements, or tick the same end of the scale, without reading them carefully. Control: question reversal, so some items are framed around obeying and others around refusing.
- Social desirability bias
- The tendency to answer dishonestly to look good or compliant. Control: ask about third-person scenarios, or use anonymous ID numbers instead of names.
- Combining data
- Your questionnaire must gather quantitative data (numbers from rating scales, for descriptive statistics) and qualitative data (open questions or story completions, for thematic analysis).
Student task 3: write your questionnaire items
Complete your own original questions below, following this quota.
This item must measure refusal, so that a high rating means low obedience. Reverse the score before you add it up: on a 1 to 5 scale, 1 becomes 5, 2 becomes 4, 3 stays 3, 4 becomes 2, 5 becomes 1; on a 1 to 10 scale, the reversed score is 11 minus the rating.
Use either an open question (for example, asking participants what makes them follow an instruction) or the opening of a story that participants finish.
Guidance: story completion or open questions?
Story completion (a projective technique): give participants a short scenario, for example a brother and a sister who are both told by a parent to tidy their rooms, and ask them to finish the story. How people finish it can reveal their expectations about gender without alerting them to the true aim.
Open questions: avoid leading wording. Do not ask "Why are women more obedient than men?", which assumes that they are. Ask instead: "Explain whether you think gender influences obedience at school, and give reasons for your answer."
Sentence starters for task 3
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "… tells you to … How likely are you to …? (1 = very unlikely, 10 = very likely)"
- "… tells you to … How likely are you to refuse? (1 = very unlikely to refuse, 10 = very likely to refuse)"
- "Each participant's total is the sum of … items, with item … reversed, giving a score from … to …"
- "Explain what makes you more likely to … Give reasons for your answer."
- "… tells … to … What happens next? Finish the story in a few sentences."
Step 4: Ethical safeguards: the BPS code
All psychological research must protect participants' dignity and safety. The BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct (2009) rests on four principles: respect, competence, responsibility and integrity. In your practical, they mean you must follow these guidelines:
- Informed consent
- Given in writing before the questionnaire begins (a tick box is enough, so no names are needed). Anyone under 16 also needs a parent's consent.
- Right to withdraw
- Emphasised before, during and after data collection: participants can leave out questions, stop, or have their answers removed later.
- Confidentiality and anonymity
- Data are identified by numbers (P01, P02), not names. No real teacher or student is named in your scenarios or your report.
- Deception and debriefing
- You may hold back the exact comparison (for example, gender) at first to prevent demand characteristics, but you MUST reveal the full aim in the debrief.
- Risk management
- Before you start, think about what could upset or embarrass a participant, how likely and how serious it is, and how you will reduce it.
Student task 4: draft your participant brief and debrief
Complete the introductory text that participants will read before they agree to complete your questionnaire.
Complete the text you will give participants after they hand in the questionnaire: the full aim, and their right to withdraw.
Guidance: briefing and debriefing checklist
Briefing and debriefing checklist
- Did your brief explain the nature of the task and the approximate time needed (about 10 minutes)?
- Did you state that participants can leave out any question they prefer not to answer?
- Did your debrief clearly justify why part of the aim (for example, the gender comparison) was held back at first?
- Did you give contact details and a date by which the data will be destroyed?
Sentence starters for task 4
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "You are invited to take part in a psychology study about … It will take about … minutes."
- "Taking part is voluntary. You can leave out any question or stop at any time, and …"
- "Your answers are anonymous: …"
- "Thank you for taking part. The full aim of this study was to …"
- "I did not mention … at the start because …"
- "If you want to withdraw your answers, … by … All questionnaires will be destroyed on … If anything worried you, …"
Step 5: Quantitative and qualitative data analysis
Part A: quantitative calculations and summary table. Once you have collected your questionnaires, calculate each participant's total score (remembering to reverse the scores of reversed items), then these five descriptive statistics for each group or condition:
- Mean
- The total of the scores divided by the number of scores: mean = Σx ÷ N.
- Median
- The middle score in an ordered data set. With an even number of scores, the mean of the two middle scores.
- Mode
- The most frequent score.
- Range
- Highest score minus lowest score.
- Standard deviation (s)
- The spread of scores around the mean: s = √( Σ(x − x̄)² ÷ (N − 1) ).
Practise the method: descriptive statistics
Practice data: these scores are made up for practice. They are not from a real study, and they are not your results.
| Group | Scores |
|---|---|
| Female (P01 to P06) | 58, 62, 58, 66, 57, 59 |
| Male (P07 to P12) | 54, 61, 48, 54, 63, 56 |
- Calculate the mean, median, mode and range of the female scores.
- Calculate the standard deviation of the female scores, using the table below: fill in x − x̄, then (x − x̄)², add up the last column, divide by N − 1 and take the square root.
- Calculate all five statistics for the male scores, then complete a summary table for both groups.
| Participant | Score (x) | x − x̄ | (x − x̄)² |
|---|---|---|---|
| P01 | 58 | ||
| P02 | 62 | ||
| P03 | 58 | ||
| P04 | 66 | ||
| P05 | 57 | ||
| P06 | 59 | ||
| Total | Σx = | Σ(x − x̄)² = |
Answers: practice data
Practice data answers. Check each step of your working, not just the final number.
Working for the females:
- Mean = 360 ÷ 6 = 60
- In order: 57, 58, 58, 59, 62, 66. Median = (58 + 59) ÷ 2 = 58.5
- Mode = 58 (it occurs 2 times)
- Range = 66 − 57 = 9
| Participant | Score (x) | x − x̄ | (x − x̄)² |
|---|---|---|---|
| P01 | 58 | -2 | 4 |
| P02 | 62 | 2 | 4 |
| P03 | 58 | -2 | 4 |
| P04 | 66 | 6 | 36 |
| P05 | 57 | -3 | 9 |
| P06 | 59 | -1 | 1 |
| Total | Σx = 360 | Σ(x − x̄)² = 58 |
- Mean: x̄ = 60.
- Take the mean away from each score (third column), then square each answer (fourth column).
- Add the squares: Σ(x − x̄)² = 4 + 4 + 4 + 36 + 9 + 1 = 58.
- Divide by N − 1: 58 ÷ 5 = 11.6.
- Square root: √11.6 = 3.41, so s = 3.41.
The males: mean = 336 ÷ 6 = 56; in order, 48, 54, 54, 56, 61, 63, so the median is (54 + 56) ÷ 2 = 55; mode = 54; range = 63 − 48 = 15; Σ(x − x̄)² = 146; 146 ÷ 5 = 29.2; √29.2 = 5.40.
| Descriptive statistic | Females | Males |
|---|---|---|
| Mean | 60 | 56 |
| Median | 58.5 | 55 |
| Mode | 58 | 54 |
| Range | 9 | 15 |
| Standard deviation | 3.41 | 5.40 |
Student task 5A: complete your summary table
Complete this summary table with your calculated descriptive statistics, for your results section.
| Descriptive statistic | Group or condition 1 (e.g. males) | Group or condition 2 (e.g. females) |
|---|---|---|
| Mean | [ Enter ] | [ Enter ] |
| Median | [ Enter ] | [ Enter ] |
| Mode | [ Enter ] | [ Enter ] |
| Range | [ Enter ] | [ Enter ] |
| Standard deviation | [ Enter ] | [ Enter ] |
Guidance: the standard deviation and the bar chart
Work out the SD in a table with the columns x, x − x̄ and (x − x̄)². Add up the last column, divide by N − 1, then take the square root. On a calculator, use the sample SD key (often labelled s or σn−1), not σn: with the practice data above, dividing by N instead of N − 1 gives 3.11 instead of 3.41.
The bar chart shows the two means, not raw scores: the groups along the x-axis with a gap between the bars, the mean score up the y-axis starting at 0, both axes labelled (with units) and an informative title.
Sentence starters for your numerical findings
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "Table 1 shows that the mean score for … was …, compared with … for …, a difference of … points."
- "The medians show the same / a different pattern: … for … and … for …"
- "Scores were more spread out for … (SD = …, range = …) than for … (SD = …, range = …), which shows that …"
- "The mean for … is above / below its median, which suggests a slight positive / negative skew, caused by …"
- "Figure 1 shows that …"
Part B: qualitative thematic analysis (the six steps)
- Familiarisation: read and re-read all the written answers or stories carefully.
- Initial coding: highlight key words or phrases that show reasons for obeying or defying, feelings, or a sense of duty, and give each a short code.
- Searching for themes: group related codes together into wider clusters.
- Reviewing themes: re-read the answers to check that each possible theme really represents the raw data.
- Defining and naming themes: give at least two distinct themes a clear, short title and a one-sentence definition.
- Reporting: write up each theme, illustrated with direct quotes from participants.
Practise the method: code six answers
Practice answers: these six answers to "What makes you more likely to follow an instruction?" are made up for practice. They are not from a real study.
| Participant | Answer, word for word |
|---|---|
| P01 (F) | "If a teacher asks politely and explains why, I'll do it straight away." |
| P02 (F) | "I don't want to get a detention or have my parents called." |
| P03 (F) | "Teachers are in charge in school, so I usually just do what they say." |
| P07 (M) | "If it's a teacher I respect, I'll do it. If they shout, I feel like doing the opposite." |
| P08 (M) | "Mostly to avoid trouble. A detention isn't worth it over a phone." |
| P09 (M) | "Teachers are responsible for the class, so if they tell you to do something, it's on them, not me." |
- Give each answer a short descriptive code (one answer can have more than one).
- Identify two or three themes by grouping codes that belong together, and give each theme a title.
- Identify one quote that best supports each theme. Then open the answer and compare.
Answers: practice coding and themes
Practice answers: one good set of codes and themes. Other codes and theme titles can be just as good if each theme fits more than one answer and is supported by a quote.
| Participant | Direct quote | Initial descriptive code | Overarching theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| P01 (F) | "If a teacher asks politely and explains why, I'll do it straight away." | Polite request with a reason | Respect and fairness |
| P02 (F) | "I don't want to get a detention or have my parents called." | Fear of punishment | Avoiding trouble |
| P03 (F) | "Teachers are in charge in school, so I usually just do what they say." | Role gives the right to give orders | The teacher's authority |
| P07 (M) | "If it's a teacher I respect, I'll do it. If they shout, I feel like doing the opposite." | Respect for the teacher; shouting provokes resistance | Respect and fairness |
| P08 (M) | "Mostly to avoid trouble. A detention isn't worth it over a phone." | Fear of punishment | Avoiding trouble |
| P09 (M) | "Teachers are responsible for the class, so if they tell you to do something, it's on them, not me." | Responsibility passed to the teacher | The teacher's authority |
Reviewing: P07 at first looked like a one-off ("if they shout, I feel like doing the opposite"), but on review it shared an idea with P01: both obey when they feel respected and the request is reasonable, so the two became one theme.
Defining, naming and reporting:
- Theme 1: Avoiding trouble (P02, P08): students obey because a teacher can punish them. P08: "Mostly to avoid trouble. A detention isn't worth it over a phone."
- Theme 2: The teacher's authority (P03, P09): students obey because the teacher's role gives them the right to give orders, and responsibility. P09: "If they tell you to do something, it's on them, not me."
- Theme 3: Respect and fairness (P01, P07): students obey when the request is polite and reasonable, and may resist when it is not. P01: "If a teacher asks politely and explains why, I'll do it straight away."
Student task 5B: your thematic analysis matrix
Identify at least three participant quotes from your own study, give each a code, and name its theme.
| Direct quote from participant text | Initial descriptive code | Overarching theme |
|---|---|---|
Sentence starters for reporting your themes
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "A six-step thematic analysis of the answers to … found … themes."
- "The first theme, '…', describes … It appeared in … of the … answers."
- "This theme was coded from phrases such as '…' and '…'."
- "For example, P… wrote: '…'"
- "The second theme, '…', suggests that …"
Step 6: Methodological evaluation and suggestions for improvement
When you evaluate your own practical in the discussion section, consider:
- Reliability: did you check the reliability of your questions? Could you use a test-retest or split-half method?
- Internal validity: did participants guess the aim (demand characteristics)? Did they answer truthfully, or present socially desirable answers?
- Subjectivity in thematic analysis: did your own expectations influence how you coded the answers or stories? Could you use inter-rater reliability?
- Generalisability: is your sample restricted to one school or one age group?
Student task 6: draft your evaluation
State the specific change to the procedure AND justify how it improves validity or reliability.
Sentence starters for task 6
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "One strength of my questionnaire was …, because … This means my results are more valid / reliable because …"
- "One weakness of my study was … For example, in my questionnaire … As a result, …"
- "My sample of … from … may not represent …, because …"
- "To improve my study, I would … This would …, which would increase the validity / reliability of …"
Step 7: Conventions of report writing (final submission scaffold)
Your final write-up must follow standard psychological conventions. Use these guidelines to structure each section.
1. Abstract (a stand-alone paragraph of about 150 words)
A short overview of the whole report, written in the past tense. It must summarise:
- brief theoretical background to obedience or conformity
- the research aim, and both the alternative and null hypotheses
- the method: target population, sample size, sampling method and the questionnaire or interview used
- the key quantitative results (means and SDs) and the main qualitative theme
- a conclusion that answers your aim (for idea A: whether gender affects self-reported obedience).
2. Introduction (theoretical rationale)
An overview of the theories and research that give a clear rationale for your study:
- Review classic and contemporary research. For idea A: Milgram (1963), where 65% of participants obeyed to 450 volts, and his variation with 40 female participants, which also found 65%; and Burger (2009), who found no significant difference between men and women.
- Outline the explanations: for idea A, social role theory against situational explanations (social power theory, agency theory). For other ideas, use the research named in Step 1.
- Justify why you used a questionnaire rather than a high-stress laboratory experiment (it would be unethical to cause participants distress).
- End with your formal aim, alternative hypothesis (H1) and null hypothesis (H0).
3. Method (a step-by-step account that can be replicated)
A detailed account with enough operational detail for another researcher to repeat it exactly:
- Design: questionnaire (or structured interview) design, with closed rating scales and open text or story completion.
- Participants: total number, age range, the make-up of each group (for example, the gender split) and the sampling technique (with justification).
- Apparatus and materials: full description of the questionnaire, rating scales, reverse-scored items, information sheet, consent form and debrief form.
- Procedure: a chronological account of recruitment, briefing, completing the questionnaire on their own, collection and debriefing.
- Controls and ethical issues: how consent, anonymity, the right to withdraw and any deception were handled.
4. Results (quantitative and qualitative findings)
A detailed account of the data (do not list raw score sheets here; put them in the appendices):
- Summary table: mean, median, mode, range and standard deviation for both groups.
- Graph: a fully labelled bar chart of the mean scores of your two groups, for example males and females (clear title, axis labels with units).
- Commentary: clear written paragraphs describing the differences in central tendency and dispersion.
- Qualitative results: the thematic analysis matrix, showing defined themes, descriptions and supporting quotes word for word.
5. Discussion (interpretation and critical review)
- Interpretation: state clearly whether your results support or do not support your alternative hypothesis.
- Link to earlier research: compare your findings with the research in your introduction (for idea A: Milgram, Burger and social role expectations). Did your study find a difference where the laboratory studies did not? Why might that be?
- Methodological critique: evaluate strengths and limitations (how representative the sample was, demand characteristics, the reliability of the questionnaire).
- Improvements: suggest at least two practical, justified changes for future research.
- Concluding statement: a final sentence capturing the main finding of your investigation.
6. References and appendices
- References: full academic references (APA format) for every study and theory you cite, such as Milgram and Burger.
- Appendix 1: a blank copy of your questionnaire.
- Appendix 2: blank copies of your information sheet, consent form and debrief form.
- Appendix 3: the raw data table.
- Appendix 4: fully worked calculations of the mean and standard deviation.
- Appendix 5: the qualitative answers and your coding.
Sentence starters for your abstract and discussion
Use these to start your own sentences; fill each gap (…) with the details of your study.
- "This study investigated whether … A sample of … was … using … sampling."
- "The results support / do not support my alternative hypothesis, because the mean for … (…) was … than for … (…)."
- "This agrees / disagrees with … (year), who found that …"
- "One explanation for this is …, which suggests that …"
- "My findings may differ from … because my study measured … whereas …"
- "In conclusion, …"
Final self-assessment checklist before submitting
Check each of these before you hand in your formal report.