The Chromozone / IAL Biology / Unit 1 / Topic 1
Directed study: exam technique
Exam technique: plan and judge a practical method
Directed study: exam technique. About 40 minutes, independent study, 26 marks. One skill: naming variables, saying how each one is controlled and why, and judging and writing a method, using the DCPIP titration for vitamin C. Type your answers in the boxes, then hand them in at the bottom of the page. Steps 1 and 2 stay open to use; the mark schemes open after you hand in: then mark your work point by point and correct it in a different colour. Teachers: set this after the lesson Core practical 2: the vitamin C content of food and drink.
Teach these first
This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:
How this page works
One exam technique, in three steps: learn how to do it, see it done with the marks shown, then do it yourself on this lesson's content.
Step 1: how to do it 6 min
Use these steps whenever a practical question asks you to plan, describe or explain a method.
- Name the independent variable (IV): the one thing you change. Give the values you will test.
- Name the dependent variable (DV) and say exactly what you measure, with its unit.
- List what else could change the DV in this experiment. Do not use a stock list.
- For each one, say how you keep it the same: a value, a time or a piece of equipment.
- If asked why, say how the variable would change the DV if it was different.
- If asked for a control, set up a test with the IV left out, for comparison.
- Write the method in order, with quantities, equipment, repeats with a mean, and one safety point.
How the mark scheme rewards this. Marks go to a named variable and how it is kept the same: a mass on a balance, a volume with a syringe, a temperature with a water bath. "Keep everything the same" or "make it a fair test" earns nothing. When a question asks why a variable is controlled, Pearson has credited valid with the effect of the variable on the DV, and ignored reliable, accurate, precise and fair test. Use each of these words only for its own meaning, in the table below.
| Word | What it means | How to show or improve it |
|---|---|---|
| Valid | The method measures what you mean it to, because every variable except the IV is controlled. | Control the other variables, with values. Measure the right DV, such as volume of juice added. |
| Repeatable | The same person, with the same method and equipment, gets close results when repeating it. | Do at least three titrations. Leave out any anomaly, then calculate the mean and the spread. |
| Reproducible | Different people, or different equipment or laboratories, get the same results with the same method. | Write the method so that another group can follow it, then compare means. |
| Accurate | Close to the true value. | Standardise with a vitamin C solution of known concentration. Read volumes at the meniscus, at eye level. |
| Precise | Repeat readings are close together, with a small spread. | Use a syringe with finer divisions. Add drops one at a time and judge the end point the same way each time. |
A control is not a controlled variable. A control is a separate test used for comparison, for example distilled water in place of the extract. A controlled variable is something you keep the same in every test, for example the volume of DCPIP.
Common misconceptions and exam errors
These come up again and again in the reports on real exam answers. Each one costs marks.
- Writing "control" when the question asks about controlled variables, or the other way round. A control is a comparison test with the IV left out. Controlled variables are the things you keep the same. Read which one the question wants.
- Writing a stock list: temperature, pH, volume, time. Ask whether each one would change the DV in this experiment. If it is the IV or the DV, it cannot be a controlled variable. Choose only variables that would change the result, and give a value.
- Saying that a variable is controlled "to make the results accurate, reliable or fair". These words earn no mark here. Say the experiment is valid, and explain how the variable would change the DV if it was not controlled.
- Writing "measure the vitamin C" or "measure the size". Say what you read: the volume of juice (cm3) needed to decolourise 1.0 cm3 of DCPIP. Say which quantity and which unit.
- Answering a different question about repeats. If asked how to show that results are repeatable, do not describe how the data are collected. Say: repeat, calculate the mean and the standard deviation, and show them on a graph or in a table.
Step 2: a worked example 5 min
Question: A student compares the vitamin C in kiwi fruit and in tomato. She grinds each fruit with water, filters it, and titrates the extract against DCPIP. Describe how she should control two variables when she makes the extracts, and explain why one of them must be controlled. (4)
Answer 1 1 of 4 marks
She should keep the temperature the same and use 10 g of each fruit (1). This is so the results are fair, accurate and reliable.
Why: The mass of fruit, with a value, earns one mark. Temperature could matter, and Pearson has credited the temperature of extraction, but this answer gives no value and no way of keeping it the same, such as a water bath, so it earns nothing. "Fair, accurate and reliable" explains nothing about how the variable changes the DV, so the explanation earns no mark.
Answer 2 4 of 4 marks
Variable 1 is the mass of fruit. She weighs 10.0 g of kiwi and 10.0 g of tomato on the same balance (1). Variable 2 is the volume of distilled water for grinding. She measures 50 cm3 for each fruit with a measuring cylinder (1). The mass must be the same because a larger mass of fruit would put more vitamin C into the same volume of extract (1). Then less extract would decolourise the DCPIP, so that fruit would seem to have more vitamin C, and the comparison would not be valid (1).
Why: Each variable is named, with a value and a piece of equipment. The explanation follows the chain: variable, effect on the amount of vitamin C in the extract, effect on the DV, so the comparison is not valid.
Step 3: your turn 25 min
Use the steps in Step 1. Parts 1(a) to 1(c) are guided; parts 5 and 6 are on your own. Open the mark scheme only after you hand in.
Context for part 1. A student investigates how the time that fresh guava juice is left in an open beaker affects its vitamin C. She pours guava juice into open beakers and tests one beaker after 0, 2, 4, 6 and 8 hours. She tests each sample with DCPIP.
Name the independent variable and say which values you will test. Name the dependent variable and say exactly what you will measure, with its unit. (2)
Independent variableDependent variableGive three variables that she must control. For each one, say how she should keep it the same, with a value or a piece of equipment. (3)
123Choose one of your variables from (b). Explain how the result would be misleading if it was not controlled. (2)
A student extracts vitamin C from a red pepper with distilled water. She wonders whether the water, or the syringe, could decolourise DCPIP by itself. Describe a control experiment that she should set up, and explain what it shows. (2)
Two students each test the same pepper extract three times. A laboratory method gave a true value of 1.80 cm3. (i) State which student's results are more precise and which are more accurate. Give a reason for each. (ii) Suggest why all of Student A's volumes are too low, and one change to Student B's method that would make the results more precise. (4)
Volume of pepper extract needed to decolourise 1.0 cm3 of DCPIP Titration Student A / cm3 Student B / cm3 1 1.52 1.62 2 1.50 1.95 3 1.51 1.78 Mean 1.51 1.78 Student A's three results are very close. (i) Explain what is meant by "repeatable". (ii) Describe how her class could show that the results are also reproducible. (3)
You are given a red pepper, a knife, a balance, a pestle and mortar, filter paper and a funnel, distilled water, 0.1% DCPIP, a standard vitamin C solution of 1.0 mg cm−3, test tubes and 1 cm3 syringes. Describe a method to find the concentration of vitamin C, in mg cm−3, in an extract of the pepper. (6)
A student's plan. "I want to find out if heating orange juice destroys vitamin C. I will boil some orange juice in a pan and leave some cold. I will add DCPIP to each one and see which turns colourless more quickly. I will test each one once. I will keep everything else the same."
Give two problems with the student's plan. For each problem, say how to improve it. (4)
Mark scheme
1(a) Variables (2)
- IV: the time the juice is left open, with at least two of the values, 0 / 2 / 4 / 6 / 8 hours (1)
- DV: the volume of juice needed to decolourise a fixed volume of DCPIP (for example 1.0 cm3), in cm3 / the vitamin C concentration calculated from it (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "the vitamin C" or "the colour" on its own: the quantity read must be stated
1(b) Controlled variables (3): max 3
- Temperature: keep every beaker at the same temperature, for example 20 °C in a thermostatically controlled water bath / in one room, checked with a thermometer (1)
- The same volume of juice in identical beakers, for example 50 cm3 in 100 cm3 beakers, so the same surface of juice is open to the air (1)
- Juice from the same carton or batch, so every sample starts with the same vitamin C (1)
- The same light, for example all beakers on one bench away from the window (1)
- The same volume and concentration of DCPIP, for example 1.0 cm3 of 0.1% from one batch, measured with a 1 cm3 syringe (1)
- The same person judging the end point, against a white tile (1)
- A variable with no way of keeping it the same earns no mark
- DO NOT ACCEPT time (it is the independent variable)
- IGNORE "the same pH"
- Max 3
1(c) Why control it (2): one variable, max 2
- Temperature: a higher temperature speeds up the oxidation of vitamin C (1)
- So a warmer sample would lose more vitamin C, and the loss would be caused by temperature, not by time: the result would not be valid (1)
- Beaker: a wider beaker leaves more of the juice surface open to the air, so more vitamin C is oxidised (1)
- So samples would differ for a reason other than time, and the result would not be valid (1)
- Volume of DCPIP: a larger volume needs more vitamin C to decolourise it (1)
- So more juice would be added and the juice would seem to have less vitamin C, even if it did not (1)
- Juice batch: a different batch may start with more vitamin C (1)
- So differences between samples might not be caused by the time left open (1)
- Each pair is one variable: the effect on the vitamin C or on the DV (1), then why the result is misleading or not valid (1)
- ACCEPT any other variable from (b) with a matching explanation
- ACCEPT "not valid"
- IGNORE "so the results are fair / reliable / accurate"
- Max 2
2 A control experiment (2)
- Add distilled water (the same solvent) in place of the extract to 1.0 cm3 of DCPIP, using the same syringe (1)
- To show the DCPIP stays blue with water and the syringe, so loss of colour with the extract is caused by vitamin C / a baseline for comparison (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT keeping the volumes or the temperature the same: those are controlled variables, not a control
3 Accurate or precise (4)
- (i) A is more precise: its results are within 0.02 cm3, while B's results spread over 0.33 cm3 (1)
- (i) B is more accurate: its mean, 1.78 cm3, is closer to the true value, 1.80 cm3, than A's mean, 1.51 cm3 (1)
- (ii) A stopped adding extract too early, for example at the first pink or when the colour first faded, so every volume was too low (1)
- (ii) B: add the extract one drop at a time and shake after each drop / use a syringe with finer divisions / judge the end point against a white tile (1)
- ACCEPT less than 1.0 cm3 of DCPIP, or a more dilute DCPIP, in every test for A
- ACCEPT reading at the bottom of the meniscus, at eye level, for B
- IGNORE "A is reliable"
4 Repeatable and reproducible (3)
- (i) The same person, with the same method and equipment, gets very similar results when the test is repeated (1)
- (ii) Other students or another class follow the same method, with their own syringes and DCPIP (1)
- (ii) Their mean volumes are very similar to Student A's means (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "Student A repeats it again" for (ii): that shows repeatability
5 Write the method (6): max 6
- Weigh a known mass of pepper, for example 10.0 g, on a balance, cut it up and grind it with a known volume of distilled water, for example 50 cm3 (1)
- Filter the mixture to make the extract (1)
- Use a syringe to put 1.0 cm3 of DCPIP into a clean test tube, the same volume for every test (1)
- Add the standard vitamin C solution one drop at a time, shaking after each drop, until the blue colour just disappears; record the volume of standard added (1)
- Do the same with the pepper extract and fresh DCPIP, until the blue (and any pink) has gone; record the volume of extract added (1)
- Repeat each titration at least three times with fresh DCPIP, leave out any anomaly and calculate the mean volumes (1)
- Concentration of the extract = (mean volume of standard ÷ mean volume of extract) × 1.0 mg cm−3 (1)
- Judge each end point against a white tile (1)
- Safety: wear eye protection / wash DCPIP splashes off skin / take care with the knife (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT the volume of extract as a quantity kept the same: it is what you measure
- Max 6
6 Improve the plan (4): max 4
- Problem: "see which turns colourless more quickly" gives no measured result, and no volumes are stated (1)
- Improvement: add each juice one drop at a time to 1.0 cm3 of DCPIP and record the volume needed (1)
- Problem: each juice is tested once, so there is no mean and an anomaly cannot be spotted (1)
- Improvement: test each juice at least three times and calculate a mean (1)
- Problem: "everything else the same" names nothing to control (1)
- Improvement: name each variable with a value, for example 1.0 cm3 of the same 0.1% DCPIP for every test (1)
- Problem: boiling evaporates water from the juice, and the boiled juice is still hot when it is tested (1)
- Improvement: boil for a stated time with a lid, make it back up to its starting volume and cool it to room temperature before testing (1)
- Up to 2 marks for each problem: 1 for the problem and 1 for an improvement that fixes it
- IGNORE "not a fair test"
- Max 4
Self-marking checklist 4 min
Before you hand in, check that:
- every control variable has a value, a time or a piece of equipment, not only a name;
- your dependent variable says what you read and the unit;
- every "why" says how the variable would change the DV, and does not use "fair", "accurate" or "reliable" alone;
- a control is a comparison test, not a list of things kept the same.
After you hand in, the mark schemes open. Then:
- tick each mark point you earned: a variable with no way of keeping it the same earns no mark;
- for each point you missed, rewrite it in a different colour, adding the value or the effect on the DV;
- write your total out of 26, and one target, for example: "I will give a number for every variable I control."