The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Self-study: Micro-Asch practical investigation

Spec 1.1.5, 1.2.2, 1.2.9Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 50 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Phase 1 key terms

Primary data
Original data that you collect yourself, for this piece of research. (1.2.2)
Secondary data
Data that someone else collected, often for a different purpose, such as published results. (1.2.2)
Self-report
Participants answer questions about themselves, for example in a questionnaire.
Observation
The researcher watches and records what participants do or say.
Confederate
An actor who is part of the experiment and follows a set script to create social pressure.

Phase 1: planning and method set-up, Part A (4 marks) 8 min

Read the scenario, then answer in your study journal or in the boxes.

  1. Scenario: you are investigating whether peer majority pressure affects line-length judgements in a school. Ethics do not allow you to cause distress, so you run a low-stress micro-study.

    There are two conditions. In one, both confederates give the same wrong answer (a unanimous majority). In the other, one confederate gives the right answer first, so the majority is broken (an ally, also called social support).

    Is the data you collect yourself in this practical primary or secondary data? Explain why, in one sentence. (1.2.2) (2)

  2. Identify your independent variable (IV) and your dependent variable (DV). (Hint: unanimous wrong majority versus a majority broken by an ally; a conforming answer versus a correct answer.) (2)

    IV
    DV
Reveal the answers and mark scheme: Phase 1

1. Data type (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying the type of data and one mark for the reason.

  • Primary data (1)
  • You collect it first-hand, for this investigation (1)

Reject all other answers.

2. Variables (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each variable correctly identified.

  • IV: a unanimous wrong majority versus a majority broken by an ally (1)
  • DV: whether the participant gives the conforming wrong answer or the correct one (1)

Reject all other answers.

Phase 2: preparing the materials and the script, Part B (2 marks) 10 min

Make your testing materials on paper or a mini-whiteboard.

  • Stimulus card 1: draw the standard line X (10 cm). Next to it, draw three comparison lines: A (10 cm), B (7 cm) and C (14 cm). Line A is clearly correct.
  • The script for two confederates and one data recorder, for example:
    • Confederate 1: "The matching line is line B."
    • Confederate 2: "I agree, it's line B."
    • Real participant: says their answer out loud.
    • Data recorder: writes down the participant's answer.
  1. Write out your full script: the exact words for both confederates in each condition (unanimous majority, and ally), and what the data recorder does. (2)

Stretch and challenge: fixed scripts (2 marks) 4 min

  1. Explain why standardised instructions and fixed scripts are essential controls when you measure social influence. (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: Phase 2 and the stretch

3. The script (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate feature of the script.

  • Both conditions scripted word for word: both wrong; or one ally says the right line first (1)
  • The recorder notes each answer and whether it matches the confederates (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

4. Stretch (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for identifying the control and one mark for explaining why it matters.

  • Every participant meets exactly the same social pressure (standardised procedure) (1)
  • So tone or hesitation cannot act as an extraneous variable (investigator effects) (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Phase 3: running the study and collecting data, Part C (1 mark) 13 min

Run a trial: test two or three people, or do a practice run with the example data below.

  • Step 1: show the stimulus card to the participant.
  • Step 2: the confederates give their answers out loud.
  • Step 3: the data recorder writes the participant's answer in a tally table.

Ethics first: test only people aged 16 or over who agree to take part, and only with your teacher's permission. Use participant numbers, never names. Tell each person the real aim straight after their trial, and that going along with a group is normal.

  1. Record your results in the same four columns: participant number, condition, stated answer, conformed (yes or no). If you could not test anyone, copy the example rows. (1)

    Example tally (made-up example data)
    ParticipantConditionStated answerConformed? (yes or no)
    Participant 1Unanimous majorityLine BYes
    Participant 2Unanimous majorityLine ANo
    Participant 3Ally presentLine ANo
Teacher note: before students run the study

Before students test anyone: check each team's design from the Asch (1951) lesson and its directed study. Testers must be with you or have your permission, participants must be 16 or over (or have a parent's consent), and every participant is debriefed straight after the trial.

If testing outside class is not possible, students use the example rows: every part of the page still works.

Reveal the mark scheme: Phase 3

5. Your results (1)

AO2 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for a complete results table.

  • All four columns filled in for every participant, with numbers, not names (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Phase 4: practical evaluation (6 marks) 10 min

  1. Identify two ethical issues in this micro-study, and explain how you can reduce each one. (1.2.9) (4)

    Issue 1
    How to reduce it
    Issue 2
    How to reduce it
  2. Explain how demand characteristics could affect the validity of carrying out this test in a school. (2)

Phase 4: exam-style question (4 marks) 5 min

  1. In Asch's task-difficulty variation, the comparison lines were made closer in length to the standard line, so the right answer was harder to see.

    A student decides to repeat Asch's variation study on task difficulty in a school. Explain how task difficulty affects conformity, and one methodological issue with testing this in a school. (1.1.5) (4)

Reveal the self-assessment mark schemes: Phase 4 and the exam-style question

6. Ethics (4)

AO1 (2 marks), AO3 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying each ethical issue and one mark for how it can be reduced.

  • Deception: participants think the confederates are real (1)
  • Reduce: debrief them fully, straight after (1)
  • Consent or embarrassment: no fully informed consent; they may feel foolish (1)
  • Reduce: remind them they can withdraw their data; reassure them (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

7. Demand characteristics (2)

AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for the effect on behaviour and one mark for the effect on validity.

  • Peers may guess the aim, or spot that the confederates are acting (demand characteristics) (1)
  • So they behave unnaturally, which lowers validity (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Exam-style question (4)

AO1 (2 marks), AO3 (2 marks)

Credit up to two marks for how task difficulty affects conformity (AO1) and up to two marks for a methodological issue linked to the school (AO3).

  • A harder task increases conformity: the right answer is less clear (1)
  • Unsure participants look to others for guidance (ISI) (1)
  • A valid issue, for example low ecological validity or a biased school sample (1)
  • Linked to the school, for example students may not take a line task seriously (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.