The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology
Directed study: exam technique
Exam technique: evaluate a study. Label, Detail, Link
Teach these first
This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
How this page works
One exam skill, in four steps: learn the skill, see it done, practise it with help, then do it on your own.
Step 1: the skill 6 min
When a question asks you to evaluate a study, or to explain a strength or a weakness, every point needs three parts:
- Label: strength or weakness, and the criterion. "Weakness: low ecological validity."
- Detail: a fact that is true only of this study: who, what task, where, how many, what result.
- Link: what it means for the findings. "So ..."
The detail is what makes a point specific. Without it, the same sentence would fit almost any study, and it earns little.
| Criterion | The question to ask | A detail from Asch (1951) |
|---|---|---|
| Generalisability | Who was in the sample, and who is missing? | 50 male American college students. |
| Reliability | Was the procedure standardised, so it could be repeated? | Same line cards; the confederates gave the same wrong answer on the same 12 critical trials. |
| Application | Can the findings help in real life? | They help explain why people go along with a group, for example with prejudiced comments. |
| Validity | Internal: was it controlled? Ecological: is it like real life? Temporal: does it still apply today? | Alone, people made mistakes on fewer than 1% of trials; matching lines had no real consequences. |
| Ethics | Were participants protected, and told the truth? | Told it was a test of vision; many felt stress and embarrassment. |
Use more than one letter. Ethics is one criterion of five. The strongest answers also use reliability, validity and generalisability.
Key words: the evaluation terms
- Generalisability
- How far the findings apply to people beyond the sample that was studied.
- Reliability
- Consistency: a study is reliable if it gives the same results when it is repeated in the same way.
- Internal validity
- How far the study measured what it claimed to, because other variables were controlled.
- Ecological validity
- How far the findings apply to real-life settings and tasks.
- Temporal validity
- How far the findings still apply in other times (eras).
Common misconceptions and exam errors
These come up again and again in the reports on real exam answers. Each one costs marks.
- Points that would fit any lab study. "It lacks ecological validity because it was in a lab" earns little. Say what in this study was unlike real life.
- Naming a criterion without explaining it. "Low generalisability" on its own is not enough: say who was in the sample, who is missing, and so what.
- Wrong study details. Asch (1951) is often mixed up with his variations or with Moscovici, and Milgram's first study with Experiments 7, 10 and 13. Check the numbers before you use them.
- Leaning on ethics. Ethics is one criterion of five. Use reliability, validity and generalisability too.
- Describing the study but never saying strength or weakness. Start every point with its label.
- Evaluating the theory when the question asks about the study. Asch's study is evidence; normative social influence is the explanation. Answer the one the question names.
Step 2: worked example 6 min
Question: Explain one strength and one weakness of Milgram's (1963) study. (4)
Answer 1 1 of 4 marks
A strength is that it was a laboratory experiment, so it was controlled (1). A weakness is that it was unethical.
Why: Both points would fit almost any laboratory study. The strength earns one mark for a point. The weakness names a criterion but has no detail and no link.
Answer 2 4 of 4 marks
Strength: high reliability. The procedure was standardised: every teacher used the same shock generator with 30 switches, and the experimenter used the same four prods in the same order (1). So the study could be repeated, and Burger (2009) found similar obedience, with 70% going on past 150 volts (1). Weakness: low generalisability. The sample was 40 men aged 20 to 50 from New Haven who answered an advert (1), so the 65% may not apply to women, or to people in other places and cultures (1).
Why: Label, Detail, Link, twice. Every detail is true only of Milgram's study, and every link says what it means for the findings.
Step 3: guided practice (13 marks) 14 min
Use the GRAVE checklist in step 1 to find details.
Label each statement about Asch (1951) G (generic) or S (specific). For each generic one, add the detail from Asch's study that would make it specific. (1.1.5) (4)
- "The study was in a laboratory, so it has low ecological validity."
- "On the critical trials, all the confederates gave the same wrong answer, so every participant faced the same pressure."
- "Participants were deceived, which is unethical."
- "People who judged the lines alone made mistakes on fewer than 1% of trials, so the wrong answers in the groups were caused by the majority."
(i)(ii)(iii)(iv)"In Asch's (1951) study, 50 male American college students judged the length of lines. On the 12 critical trials, the confederates all gave the right answer. The participants conformed on about 75% of the critical trials. In a later variation, when one confederate gave the correct answer, conformity rose to about 13%."
This paragraph has three wrong facts. Write each wrong fact and correct it. (1.1.5) (3)
123Each point below is only a Label. Add the Detail and the Link for each one. (1.1.2, 1.1.5, 1.1.4) (6)
- "Milgram's variation studies have high internal validity."
- "Asch's (1951) study raises ethical issues."
- "Zimbardo's prison study raises ethical issues."
(i)(ii)(iii)
Reveal the mark scheme: guided practice
3(a) Generic or specific? (4): one mark each
AO3 (4 marks)
Credit one mark for each correct label, with the detail added for each generic statement.
- (i) G: add that matching lines on cards had no real consequences (1)
- (ii) S (1)
- (iii) G: add that they were told it was a test of vision, and did not know the others were confederates (1)
- (iv) S (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
3(b) Three wrong facts (3)
AO1 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each wrong fact that is corrected.
- "the right answer": the confederates gave the same wrong answer (1)
- "75% of the critical trials": about 32% of critical trials (75% conformed at least once) (1)
- "rose to about 13%": with an ally, conformity fell, to about 5.5% (1)
Reject all other answers.
3(c) Upgrade the point (6): Detail (1) and Link (1) for each
AO1 (3 marks), AO3 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each accurate detail (AO1) and one mark for each link to the evaluation (AO3).
- (i) Detail: each variation kept the same generator, task and learner, and changed one thing, such as orders by phone (1)
- (i) Link: so the fall to 22.5% can be put down to that change (proximity), not other variables (1)
- (ii) Detail: participants were told it was a test of vision, and many felt stress and embarrassment (1)
- (ii) Link: so they could not give informed consent, and some were put under real pressure (1)
- (iii) Detail: the guards became aggressive and some prisoners broke down; it stopped after 6 of 14 planned days (1)
- (iii) Link: so participants were not protected from psychological harm (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
Step 4: exam-style questions on your own (14 marks) 16 min
No help now. Label, Detail, Link for every point.
Explain one strength of Asch's (1951) study in terms of reliability and one weakness in terms of generalisability. (1.1.5) (4) (about 80 words)
Explain one strength and one weakness of Zimbardo's prison study (Haney, Banks and Zimbardo, 1973). Do not use ethics. (1.1.4) (4) (about 80 words)
Explain one strength and one weakness of Sherif's (1935) study as evidence for internalisation. (1.1.4) (4) (about 80 words)
Explain one strength of Asch's research into conformity in terms of its application to real life. (1.1.5) (2)
Reveal the mark scheme: questions 1 to 4
1 Asch (1951) (4): 2 for the strength, 2 for the weakness
AO1 (2 marks), AO3 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for identifying one strength and one mark for justifying it; credit one mark for identifying one weakness and one mark for justifying it.
- Strength: the study was standardised: same line cards, and the confederates gave the same wrong answer on the same 12 critical trials (1)
- So it can be repeated to check the results (reliability), and every participant faced the same pressure (1)
- Weakness: the sample was 50 male American college students (1)
- So the 32% may not apply to women, older people or other cultures (generalisability) (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Look for other reasonable marking points.
2 Zimbardo (4): 2 for the strength, 2 for the weakness; max 2 if ethics is used
AO1 (2 marks), AO3 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for identifying one strength and one mark for justifying it; credit one mark for identifying one weakness and one mark for justifying it.
- Strength: roles were given at random, and volunteers were screened as psychologically healthy (1)
- So the guards' aggression came from the role, not from their personality (1)
- Weakness: some guards may have acted as they thought the researchers wanted (demand characteristics) (1)
- So it may not show conformity to a role alone: lower validity (1)
Also credit: only male student volunteers, so the findings may not generalise to women or to real prison staff.
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Look for other reasonable marking points.
3 Sherif (1935) (4)
AO1 (2 marks), AO3 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for identifying one strength and one mark for justifying it; credit one mark for identifying one weakness and one mark for justifying it.
- Strength: when tested alone again, people kept the group's answer (1)
- So their private view had changed, which is internalisation, not just going along in public (1)
- Weakness: a still light that seems to move in a dark room is an unusual task with no right answer (1)
- So it may not show how people conform on real beliefs or clear tasks: low ecological validity (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Look for other reasonable marking points.
4 Application (2)
AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for identifying a use and one mark for justifying it.
- A use, for example: one ally cut conformity to 5.5%, so schools can teach students to speak up for each other (1)
- So people are better able to resist peer pressure, for example to join in with prejudiced comments (1)
Also credit: helping juries or committees, where people may agree with a majority to avoid standing out.
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Look for other reasonable marking points.
Self-marking checklist 5 min
Before you hand in, check that:
- every point starts with its label: strength or weakness, and the criterion;
- every point has a detail that is true only of that study (a number, the task, the sample or a finding);
- every point ends with a link: "so" and what it means for the findings;
- your numbers match the right study: Asch (1951) 32%, ally 5.5%; Milgram (1963) 65%; Experiment 7 22.5%.
After you hand in, the mark schemes open. Then:
- tick each mark point you earned: a point with no detail from the study earns at most one mark;
- for each point without a detail or a link, add it in a different colour;
- write your total out of 27, and one target, for example: "I will put a number or a fact from the study in every point."