The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology
Directed study: conformity and media prejudice
Teach these first
This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:
Teacher note: ground rules and an opt-out
Popular topics, looked at with a critical psychological eye. Students meet these debates online anyway. The questions ask how people conform in online groups (NSI, ISI, unanimity, social impact, echo chambers), never which side is right.
Ground rules: nobody has to share their own political or religious views; calm, respectful language about every group; look only, never post or comment; no usernames, no copied insults; stop and tell you if anything is upsetting.
Opt-out: Option D (a fan community, no politics) works for every question and every mark point. Any student can choose it without giving a reason, or you can set it for the whole class.
Part 1: theory retrieval (9 marks) 10 min
Before you start your media investigation, answer these three retrieval questions from memory.
Explain the difference between normative social influence (NSI) and informational social influence (ISI). Say which type of conformity each one usually leads to. (1.1.4) (4)
NSILeads toISILeads toState what happened to conformity in Asch's variations when (i) one confederate disagreed with the majority and (ii) the majority grew larger. (1.1.5) (2)
(i)(ii)Name the three factors in Latané's social impact theory, I = f(SIN). Give an online example of each. (1.1.4) (3)
SIN
Reveal the mark scheme: Part 1
1(a) NSI and ISI (4)
AO1 (4 marks)
Credit one mark for each accurate statement. Reject all other answers.
- NSI: conforming to gain approval, fit in or avoid rejection (1)
- NSI leads to compliance: public agreement, private view unchanged (1)
- ISI: conforming because others seem to know better, when unsure (1)
- ISI leads to internalisation: a real change in private belief (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
1(b) Asch's variations (2)
AO1 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for each accurate description. Reject all other answers.
- (i) One dissenting ally cut conformity from about 32% to about 5% (1)
- (ii) Conformity rose up to 3 confederates (about 32%), then levelled off (1)
Accept 36.8% for the starting figure (Asch's 1956 report).
1(c) Social impact theory (3)
AO1 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each factor named with a sensible online example. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- Strength: status or authority, for example a famous influencer (1)
- Immediacy: closeness or frequency, for example constant notifications (1)
- Number: size of the crowd, for example thousands of comments (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
Part 2: media case study investigation
Choose one of these topics. You are not asked who is right: you use psychology to explain how people in the group influence each other.
- Option A: influencer communities about being a man (for example, how recommendation algorithms keep showing more videos of the same kind, and how fans agree with each other in the comments).
- Option B: political echo chambers (for example, the comments under a news story about an election, or an online group that supports one political party).
- Option C: debates about abortion law (for example, the comments under a news report about a change in the law in one country). Look at how people on each side agree with each other.
- Option D: a fan community, no politics (for example, the comments under a music video or a football club's post, where fans pile in to agree). Choose this one if you would rather not look at a political topic.
Stay safe online. Look only: do not post, comment, like, vote or share. Use public pages and news sites, and stay away from anything violent or hateful. Do not copy usernames: write "User 1", "User 2". Do not copy insults or offensive words: describe them instead (for example "User 3 makes fun of the other side"). If anything upsets you, stop, switch to Option D and tell your teacher.
Step 1: choose two media items on your topic.
- Item 1: a public comment section or forum thread (for example YouTube, Reddit or TikTok comments) where most people agree and there is peer pressure.
- Item 2: a video clip, news article or podcast extract with a high-status influencer, presenter or leader.
Step 2: answer the guided questions below about your two items.
Key words: groups and prejudice
- In-group
- The group you belong to and feel part of ("us").
- Out-group
- A group you do not belong to ("them").
- In-group bias
- Favouring members of your own group, while holding negative attitudes towards out-group members.
Two examples of conformity and prejudice
For question 2(d), use one of these two examples. You will study them in the next lesson.
- Sherif et al. (1961), "Robbers Cave": boys at a summer camp were split into two groups, the Eagles and the Rattlers. When the groups competed, boys went along with their own group's growing hostility towards the other group, to be accepted by their own group.
- Elliott (1968), "blue eyes, brown eyes": a primary school teacher in the USA divided her class by eye colour and told them one group was better. Within hours, children in the "better" group treated the other group badly.
Part 2: guided analysis (11 marks) 20 min
Identify your two media items. For each one, name the platform and the date, and say in one sentence what it shows. (2)
Item 1Item 2Are people in your comment section (Item 1) conforming because of NSI (for example using shared slang, repeating the group's view to get likes, avoiding criticism) or ISI (for example believing the leader has expert facts or "inside knowledge")? Explain your answer, with an example from your item (describe it in your own words; do not copy insults). (3)
Asch found that a unanimous majority makes it very hard to resist. Explain how algorithms, moderation rules or voting systems (likes, upvotes, downvotes) can make an online space look 100% unanimous, like an echo chamber. What happens to a person who disagrees there? (3)
Explain how conforming to a group's norms can lead members to take on negative attitudes (prejudice) towards an out-group, such as "the other side" or a rival club. Link your Item 1 to Sherif et al. (1961) or Elliott (1968). (3)
Reveal the mark scheme: Part 2
2(a) Your two items (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for each item named with its platform and date. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- Item 1 named, with platform and date: a crowd that mostly agrees (1)
- Item 2 named, with platform and date: a high-status figure (1)
2(b) NSI or ISI? (3): credit points like these
AO2 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each point. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- A clear label: NSI or ISI (or both) (1)
- A reason: for example copying slang for likes (NSI); trusting the leader's "facts" (ISI) (1)
- A quote or example from the item that shows it (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
2(c) The digital unanimity effect (3): max 3
AO2 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each accurate point. Max 3. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- Likes and upvotes push agreeing comments to the top (1)
- Downvotes, blocking or moderation hide or remove other views (1)
- So the space looks unanimous, as in Asch's baseline study (1)
- A person who disagrees is criticised or ignored, so others stay quiet (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
2(d) From conformity to prejudice (3)
AO2 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each accurate point. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- The group's norms include negative views of an out-group (1)
- Members copy the norm to be accepted by the in-group (NSI) (1)
- As in Sherif's camp or Elliott's class, prejudice grew from group norms (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
Part 3: exam-style scenario question (6 marks) 10 min
Scenario: Alex joins an online discussion group about political news. At first, Alex has no strong view on a debated issue. In the group's channel, hundreds of members post the same memes every day, making fun of people who disagree, and they downvote any different opinion. Alex begins posting similar jokes to fit in. Later, Alex starts searching, alone, for articles that agree with the group's view.
Explain Alex's behaviour using two psychological concepts related to conformity and social influence. (6)
Reveal the mark scheme and model answer: Part 3
Exam question (6): AO1 2, AO2 4
AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (4 marks)
Credit one mark for each concept named and explained (AO1) and one mark for each point applied to Alex (AO2). Generic answers score 0 marks.
AO1 (2 marks)
- NSI: conforming to be accepted or avoid rejection; leads to compliance (1)
- ISI: conforming because you think the group is right; leads to internalisation (1)
Accept "unanimity raises conformity (Asch)" as the second concept.
AO2 (4 marks)
- Alex posts similar jokes to fit in and avoid downvotes (1)
- At first this is compliance: Alex has no strong view in private (1)
- Hundreds of identical posts look unanimous, so Alex thinks the group is right (1)
- Searching for articles alone shows a private change: internalisation (1)
No AO2 marks without a link to Alex.
Look for other reasonable marking points.
Model answer
NSI means conforming to be accepted, and it leads to compliance. Alex first posts similar jokes to fit in and avoid being downvoted, without a strong view of their own (AO1, AO2). ISI means conforming because you believe the group is right. Hundreds of identical posts make the group look unanimous, so Alex starts to believe its view. Searching for articles alone shows a real, private change of belief: internalisation (AO1, AO2).