The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Directed study: review

Spaced repetition: minority influence, Haun, Asch, Milgram and the debates

Spec 1.1.1, 1.1.2, 1.1.5, 1.1.6, 1.3.1, 1.3.4, 2.2.9, 5.4.3Spaced repetitionDirected study: reviewAfter the lessonAbout 21 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This sheet goes back to earlier lessons, so teach them before students start it. They are listed, section by section, under What to revise at the bottom of the page.

How this sheet works

What is spaced repetition? We forget most quickly in the days and weeks after a lesson. Each time you bring something back from memory, just as it starts to fade, it stays with you for longer. So this sheet asks about earlier lessons, not about today's: section 1 goes back about a week, section 2 about a month, and section 3 further back.

Section 1: about a week back, with an exam-style question (12 marks) 13 min

One group in Moscovici et al. (1969)A screen at the top shows the slide, marked 3. Below it, six people sit in a row facing the screen. Two of them are marked 1 and four are marked 2.One group in Moscovici et al. (1969)The slideon a screen3112222Six people in a row, facing the screen(seat order simplified)
One group in the consistent condition. Labels 1 and 2 mark two kinds of people; label 3 marks the slide.Diagram: The Chromozone, simplified

1. The diagram shows one group in Moscovici et al.'s (1969) consistent condition. Name the people at label 1 and at label 2, then state the real colour of every slide (label 3) and what the people at label 1 called it. (1.3.1, Topic A) (3)

Label 1
Label 2
Label 3

Perrin and Spencer (1980) repeated Asch's line study with engineering students in the UK. They gave just 1 conforming answer in 396 trials.

2(a). Calculate the percentage of trials with a conforming answer. Give your answer to 2 decimal places. (1.1.5, Topic A) (1)

2(b). Asch (1951) found conformity on about 32% of critical trials. Explain what the difference suggests about the temporal validity of Asch's findings. (1.1.5, Topic A) (2)

3. Explain why a minority that is consistent but also flexible is more likely to change the views of a majority than a minority that refuses to move. (1.1.6, Topic A) (2)

4. Exam-style question. Explain one strength and one weakness of Haun et al.'s (2014) study in terms of validity. (1.3.4, Topic A) (4)

Strength
Weakness
Reveal the mark scheme: section 1

1. Moscovici's set-up (3)

AO1 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate label or statement.

  • Label 1: confederates (two in each group) (1)
  • Label 2: naive (real) participants (four in each group) (1)
  • Label 3: every slide was blue; the confederates called it green on all 36 trials (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

2(a) Percentage (1)

AO2 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for the correct percentage.

  • 1 ÷ 396 × 100 = 0.25% (1)

Reject all other answers.

2(b) Temporal validity (2)

AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for accurate use of the data (AO2) and one mark for the conclusion (AO3).

  • Conformity was far lower in 1980 (0.25%) than in Asch's study (about 32%) (1)
  • So Asch's findings may belong to 1950s America, a conformist time: low temporal validity (1)

Also accept: engineering students may be more sure about judging lines, so the samples differ.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

3. Consistent and flexible (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for identifying a reason and one mark for justifying it.

  • Consistency shows confidence, so the majority starts to doubt and rethink its view (1)
  • A rigid minority looks dogmatic; a flexible one seems reasonable, so it persuades (1)

Evidence: in Nemeth and Brilmayer (1987), only the flexible juror moved the majority.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

4. Haun et al. (2014) and validity (4)

AO3 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying one strength and one mark for justifying it; credit one mark for identifying one weakness and one mark for justifying it. Answers must be about validity.

  • Strength: the peers' hole gave the same reward as the participant's own hole (1)
  • So switching cannot be put down to more food: high internal validity (1)
  • Weakness: a three-hole box in a lab or sanctuary is an artificial task (1)
  • So it may not show how children and apes copy peers in daily life: low ecological validity (1)

Points about the small samples are about generalisability, not validity: they do not answer this question.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Teacher note: follows the pattern of June 2018 (a strength and a weakness, AO3 4) and October 2017 (a weakness in terms of validity): same AO split, rule line and stock guidance.

Section 2: about a month back (4 marks) 4 min

5. State two things Milgram did in his 1963 study to make the teachers believe the shocks were real. (1.1.2, Topic A) (2)

1
2

A hospital nurse gives a patient a medicine because a senior doctor tells her to, although she is not sure it is right.

6. Explain the nurse's obedience, using two bases of social power. (1.1.1, Topic A) (2)

1
2
Reveal the mark scheme: section 2

5. Making the shocks believable (2)

AO1 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate statement, up to two marks.

  • Each teacher was given a real 45-volt sample shock (1)
  • The learner pounded on the wall at 300 volts, then stopped answering (1)

Also accept: the shock generator looked real (30 switches, labels from "Slight Shock" to "XXX"). Max 2.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

6. The nurse (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each base of power linked to the nurse, up to two marks.

  • Legitimate power: the doctor is above her in the hospital hierarchy (1)
  • Expert power: the doctor has more medical knowledge than she has (1)

Also accept coercive power: she could be disciplined for refusing. Each base must be linked to the nurse.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Section 3: an earlier topic, Topic 0 (4 marks) 4 min

7. State what is meant by predictive validity, and give an example. (2.2.9, Topic 0) (2)

8. Define holism, and give one reason why a holistic explanation is harder to test than a reductionist one. (5.4.3, Topic 0) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: section 3

7. Predictive validity (2)

AO1 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for an accurate definition and one mark for an example.

  • Whether a measure correctly predicts later behaviour (1)
  • Example: a mock exam score that predicts the real exam result (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

8. Holism (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for an accurate definition and one mark for a reason.

  • Explaining behaviour by looking at the whole person and how many factors work together (1)
  • Many factors at once are hard to measure and control, so it is hard to test scientifically (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

What to revise

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.