The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Directed study: why do humans abandon what works?

Spec 1.3.4Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 50 minutes
Back to the lesson

The study: Haun, D. B. M., Rekers, Y. and Tomasello, M. (2014). Children conform to the behavior of peers; other great apes stick with what they know. Psychological Science, 25(12), 2160–2167.

Teach these first

This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:

Key words: the core evolutionary dilemma

Instrumental logic (the ape mindset)
Acting only on reward payoffs. If Strategy A reliably produces food, there is no reason to change it just because conspecifics (members of the same species) are doing something different.
Normative social affiliation (the human child mindset)
The social drive to be "like others" in your peer group. From as young as two, humans often abandon a method that already works just to match a peer majority.
Cumulative culture
The suggested evolutionary advantage of the human tendency to conform. Copying the group lets communities spread traditions, technologies and norms quickly, so each person does not have to reinvent them through risky trial and error.

Reading: the expensive water bottle and the orangutan 5 min

Why humans conform to the herd

An illustrative, magazine-style article written for this course. The orangutan and the students are imagined examples; the study findings are real.

Imagine an adult orangutan sitting in a rainforest canopy. It holds a sturdy, hollow bamboo stick that it has used for months to collect rainwater from tree hollows. The stick works every single day; it has never failed to quench the orangutan's thirst. Nearby, three other orangutans begin drinking rainwater using rolled-up leaves. What does our orangutan do?

The findings of Daniel Haun and colleagues (2014) suggest a clear answer: the orangutan ignores them and keeps using the stick. In their study, chimpanzees and orangutans almost always stuck with the strategy they had learned for themselves, even after watching three peers do something different. To a non-human great ape following instrumental logic, abandoning a functional, rewarding tool simply because three peers are using a different one would be irrational.

Now look at a modern secondary school or university campus

Almost every student already owns a reusable water bottle that works properly: it holds liquid, fits into a bag and does not leak. It represents Strategy A (the known reward). Yet every so often a new "aesthetic" bottle goes viral. In 2023 and 2024, for example, large Stanley tumblers became a social media craze, and news reports showed people queuing outside shops for limited editions. Picture students spending a lot of money, or begging their parents, for a bulky cup that does no better job than the bottle they already have.

Why would an intelligent species abandon a superior or equally functional tool for an expensive alternative? Haun et al. (2014) showed that even two-year-old children do something similar. In more than half of all trials, children dropped their ball into a new hole simply because they had watched three peers do it, abandoning a hole they already knew gave them chocolate (in the test, both holes gave chocolate).

Social affiliation over functional utility

Humans do not buy trending items, adopt viral TikTok slang or copy peer aesthetics because the new method is objectively better. One explanation is normative social affiliation: unlike chimpanzees and orangutans, our ancestors' survival depended on belonging to the in-group. Haun et al. found support for this social motive: in a follow-up study, two-year-olds switched more when their peers stayed to watch them choose than when they chose in private. Dropping the ball into "Hole B" (or carrying the trending tumbler) is a social badge signalling: "I am part of this group; I share your norms."

Mini-research and case study deconstruction (11 marks) 15 min

Choose one modern peer phenomenon from the list below (or choose your own school or digital trend, approved by your teacher):

  • Option 1 (consumer and tech): iPhone versus Android peer dynamics (for example, peer pressure around "green bubbles" in group chats, even though an Android phone has equal or better features).
  • Option 2 (fashion and footwear): viral trainer trends (for example, buying retro trainers such as Adidas Sambas or Nike Dunks when your current trainers are perfectly comfortable and in good condition).
  • Option 3 (study and productivity): abandoning simple paper revision notes to spend hours setting up complex, aesthetic digital templates in Notion or on an iPad because "study influencers" on TikTok use them.

Answer these four questions in your study notebook:

  1. Map Strategy A against Strategy B. In your chosen scenario, identify what represents Strategy A (the individual's already-functional, rewarding method) and what represents Strategy B (the peer majority's choice). (2)
  2. The great ape response. Explain why an orangutan or chimpanzee would refuse to switch in your scenario, referring to instrumental learning and the findings of Haun et al. (2014). (3)
  3. The human child response. Explain why a human teenager or toddler switches to Strategy B, referring to normative social influence (NSI) and social affiliation. (3)
  4. Cumulative culture or maladaptive conformity? Haun et al. suggest that the human tendency to conform may help explain why human culture differs from that of other apes: copying the group helps to pass on cumulative culture (for example language and complex survival tools). Does your chosen modern trend represent beneficial cumulative culture or irrational consumer conformity? Justify your view. (3)
Hint for the deconstruction task

Remember the findings of Haun et al.: two-year-old children switched to the peers' choice in over half of all trials, while chimpanzees and orangutans almost never did. On the first test trial, 12 of 18 children switched, compared with only 2 of 12 chimpanzees and 2 of 12 orangutans. Connect the ape's refusal to switch to the fact that Strategy A already works.

Model answers for the deconstruction task

These model answers use Option 1 (the iPhone example). For another option, credit the same points applied to your trend.

1. Strategy A against Strategy B (2)

Credit one mark for identifying Strategy A and one mark for identifying Strategy B.

  • Strategy A: the Android phone that already works (1)
  • Strategy B: the iPhone the peer group uses (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

2. The great ape response (3): max 3

Credit one mark for each accurate point, up to three marks.

  • Apes repeat rewarded behaviour (instrumental learning) (1)
  • Strategy A already works, so switching gains nothing (1)
  • In Haun et al., apes kept their own rewarded hole (1)
  • So the ape would keep its Android phone (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

3. The human child response (3): max 3

Credit one mark for each accurate point, up to three marks.

  • NSI: wanting to be accepted by the group (1)
  • Switching avoids being left out, for example "green bubbles" (1)
  • Like the 2-year-olds who switched to match three peers (1)
  • Children switched more when peers watched: a social motive (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

4. Cumulative culture or maladaptive conformity? (3)

Credit one mark for each accurate point, up to three marks.

  • Cumulative culture: useful skills passed on, not reinvented (1)
  • The same bias makes people drop working things for status (1)
  • A clear judgement about your trend, with a reason (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Exam practice scenario (6 marks) 8 min

AO1 (2) and AO2 (4)

Scenario: Daniel is a secondary school student who has always revised for exams by writing summary flashcards on paper, a technique that has consistently earned him grade As in his tests. When he joins a new revision study group, he watches the other three students unanimously using an online flashcard app on their phones to study. Despite finding the screen distracting and knowing his paper method works, Daniel puts away his paper flashcards and starts using the phone app during group revision sessions.

1. Explain Daniel's behaviour using findings and concepts from Haun et al. (2014). Refer to the scenario in your answer. (6)

Hint for the 6-mark exam question

Structure your answer into two balanced halves.

  1. AO1 knowledge: state Haun et al.'s key finding (two-year-olds switched to the peers' choice in over half of all trials, despite having a strategy they knew was rewarded, after watching a peer majority). AO2 application: link this to Daniel having a proven method (paper flashcards earning grade As) but abandoning it after watching three peers use the app.
  2. AO1 knowledge: contrast this with instrumental learning (chimpanzees and orangutans almost always stuck with what they knew, because only the outcome mattered to them). AO2 application: Daniel acts like a human child seeking social affiliation and normative belonging in his new study group, rather than like an ape acting on pure instrumental logic.
Reveal the mark scheme and model answer

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (4 marks)

AO1 knowledge (2): max 2

Credit one mark for each accurate statement of a finding, up to two marks.

  • Children switched to the majority's strategy on about half of trials (1)
  • Apes almost never switched; they kept their own strategy (1)
  • Children switched more when peers watched: a social motive (1)

AO2 application to the scenario (4): max 4

Credit one mark for each accurate link to Daniel, up to four marks.

  • Paper flashcards are Daniel's Strategy A: a method that works (1)
  • His three study partners are a unanimous peer majority (1)
  • He switches to the app although his own method works (1)
  • He switches in group sessions, where the others see him (1)
  • An ape would keep the paper cards that bring results (1)

No AO2 marks without a link to Daniel.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Model answer

Haun et al. (2014) found that 2-year-olds switched to a peer majority's strategy on about half of trials, even though their own strategy worked, while apes almost never switched (AO1). Daniel's paper flashcards are his working strategy, but after watching three peers use an app, he switches, like the children (AO2). He does this in group sessions, where the others can see him. This fits the finding that children switched more when peers watched: Daniel wants to fit in with his new group (AO2).

Synoptic stretch: evolutionary asset or flaw? (8 marks) 12 min

Read this claim:

"Conformity to peers was essential for human ancestors to inherit complex survival techniques, but in modern digital consumer society, it has become an irrational vulnerability."

Using your knowledge of Haun et al. (2014), Asch's variations and modern consumer culture, evaluate whether the human tendency to abandon what we know to match a peer majority does more harm than good. Write your answer in your study notes. (8)

Synoptic discussion notes and mark scheme (A/A* extension)

An evolutionary asset: without conformity, cumulative culture would be much harder. In Haun et al., children followed the group while apes did not. Copying lets us pass on language, rules and technology, and build on them.

A modern weakness: today, adverts and influencers use our wish to fit in (NSI) to sell things we do not need, just as Asch's participants gave wrong answers to fit in. Here the ape's rule, "stick with what works", may be wiser.

Mark scheme (8): levels-based. Credit points like these, then check the level

AO1 (4 marks), AO3 (4 marks)

AO1

  • 2-year-olds often switched; apes almost never did
  • In Asch's studies, people gave wrong answers to match a majority
  • Cumulative culture means skills are passed on and built on

AO3

  • Asset: skills spread fast without risky trial and error
  • Weakness: advertisers and influencers exploit NSI
  • Asch shows conformity can override correct judgement
  • Switching cost nothing in Haun, so no proof of harm
  • Small ape samples limit conclusions about apes
  • A supported judgement on harm versus good

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Equal emphasis needed: knowledge and understanding (AO1) and evaluation and conclusion (AO3).

Levels for the 8-mark question
LevelMarkDescriptor
00No rewardable material.
11 to 2Facts about the studies (AO1). Little or no evaluation (AO3).
23 to 4Accurate facts (AO1). Evaluates one side (AO3).
35 to 6Accurate facts (AO1). Evaluates both sides (AO3).
47 to 8Both sides developed (AO3). A supported judgement.

Extra exam practice from the lesson (10 marks) 10 min

Self-marked practice, not part of the hand-in. Answer in your notebook, then mark yourself with the mark schemes.

1. Describe the procedure used by Haun et al. (2014) in their contemporary study of conformity. (AO1) (3)

2. Compare the findings for the human children with the findings for the great apes in Haun et al.'s (2014) study. (AO1, AO2) (3)

3. Evaluate Haun et al. (2014) in terms of generalisability and ethics. (AO3) (4)

Reveal the mark schemes for the extra exam practice

Question 1: describe the procedure (3)

AO1 (3 marks)

Credit up to three marks for an accurate description.

  • Trained alone: only one of three holes gave food (1)
  • Watched three familiar peers use a different hole, rewarded (1)
  • Test: three balls, peers watching; stay or switch recorded (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Question 2: compare the findings (3): max 2 without a similarity

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate comparison, up to three marks. Every point must mention both groups.

  • Children switched to the majority more than both ape species (1)
  • Children switched on about half of choices; apes almost never (1)
  • Similarity: some in every species switched on trial 1 (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Question 3: evaluate generalisability and ethics (4)

AO3 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate point, up to four marks.

  • Small sample: 18 children, 12 chimpanzees, 12 orangutans (1)
  • One German city; sanctuary apes may differ from wild apes (1)
  • Ethics: harmless game, every test choice rewarded, no wrong answer (1)
  • Children and apes cannot consent; parents must consent (BPS) (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.