The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Directed study: Milgram (1963) and obedience today

Spec 1.1.1, 1.1.2Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 40 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Part 1 key-term calibration: agency theory (Milgram, 1974)

Autonomous state
You act by your own free will. You feel responsible for what you do, and your conscience guides you.
Agentic state
You see yourself as the agent of an authority figure. You hand responsibility for your actions to that person.
Agentic shift
The move from the autonomous state to the agentic state when you meet an authority figure.
Moral strain
Anxiety and distress when an order goes against your morals, but you obey anyway.
Displaced responsibility
Passing the responsibility for your actions to the authority figure: "I was only following orders."

Part 1 key-term calibration: social power theory (French and Raven, 1959)

Legitimate power
Power from a position in a hierarchy, for example a police officer or a manager.
Coercive power
Power to punish, for example with a fine, an arrest or the loss of a job.
Reward power
Power to give something good, for example a bonus or a refund.
Expert power
Power from special knowledge or skills, for example a doctor or a security specialist.
Referent power
Power from being liked or admired, so that others want to be like you.
Informational power
Power from the information or clear reasons a person gives, which persuade you (added by Raven, 1965).

Part 1: retrieval and key-term calibration (8 marks) 8 min

Answer from memory first. Use the key words above: they are the words the mark scheme looks for.

  1. Three moments from Milgram's (1963) study:

    1. A teacher sweats, laughs nervously and asks whether the learner is all right, but still presses the next switch.
    2. After the study, a teacher says: "It wasn't my fault. The man in the grey coat was in charge."
    3. A teacher stops at 300 volts and says: "I decide what I do, and I won't hurt him."

    Name the key term from agency theory that each moment (i) to (iii) shows. (1.1.1) (3)

    (i)
    (ii)
    (iii)
  2. Give these three facts about Milgram's (1963) study. (1.1.2) (3)

    What participants were told the study was about
    Percentage who gave shocks of at least 300 volts
    Number who had full, uncontrollable seizures
  3. One weakness of agency theory is that it is reductionist. Explain what this means. (1.1.1, 5.4.3) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: Part 1

1(a) Spot the term (3)

AO1 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each correct key term.

  • (i) Moral strain (1)
  • (ii) Displaced responsibility (accept agentic state) (1)
  • (iii) Autonomous state (1)

Reject all other answers.

1(b) Milgram's study (3)

AO1 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate statement.

  • Memory and learning (accept the effect of punishment on learning) (1)
  • 100% (all 40) (1)
  • 3 (1)

Reject all other answers.

1(c) A weakness (2)

AO3 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for explaining what reductionist means and one mark for relating it to agency theory.

  • Reductionism: explaining behaviour with one simple part or level (1)
  • Agency theory reduces obedience to one switch between two states; it ignores personality and the situation (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Part 2: a real-world case: fake authority

Milgram's participants obeyed a man in a grey coat at a famous university. Today, criminals use the same pressures. They phone or message people while pretending to be a police officer, a bank's fraud team or a tax office. Many of the people they target are careful and intelligent. Read this typical case, based on the warnings that police and banks publish. Then analyse it with the theories you have learned.

A typical courier scam. A woman gets a phone call from a man who says he is a detective in the fraud squad. He gives his name and a badge number. He tells her that criminals have used her bank card, and that someone at her bank may be helping them. She must not tell the bank staff or her family, he says, or she will put the investigation at risk and could be in trouble herself. First he asks her to confirm her name and address. Then he asks her to take out £500 from her bank "as evidence". When she says she is worried, he says: "You are helping the police. You will get every penny back. We are responsible for this, not you." The next day, he tells her to take out £5,000 and hand it to a courier who will come to her door.

Do not write about scams that happened to people you know. If something worries you, talk to your teacher.

Teacher note: further reading and a reminder

Part 2 needs no source of their own: the case on the page is enough. For students who want to read more, these free sources need no sign-in or payment: Report Fraud, the UK's national fraud reporting service (reportfraud.police.uk; it replaced Action Fraud in December 2025), which explains courier fraud and police impersonation; Take Five to Stop Fraud, a UK banking campaign with free advice on bank and police impersonation; the US Federal Trade Commission's consumer advice pages on government and bank impersonator scams (consumer.ftc.gov); BBC News. Many national police forces and central banks also post free warnings in local languages.

Some families may have been targeted by scams like these. Remind the class that answers must not include personal stories, names, numbers or amounts.

Part 2: guided analysis (9 marks) 12 min

  1. Identify two bases of social power that the scammer claims. For each one, describe what the scammer says or does to show it. (1.1.1) (4)

    Base 1
    Shown by
    Base 2
    Shown by
  2. Explain how the scam could push the woman into the agentic state. Use the case. (1.1.1) (3)

  3. In Milgram's study, the shocks rose in small 15-volt steps, and the experimenter used fixed prods such as "You have no other choice, you must go on." Identify one way the scam in the case uses a similar technique, and explain why it works. (1.1.2) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: Part 2

2(a) Social power theory (4): credit points like these

AO2 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying each of two bases of power and one mark for each matching example from the case.

  • A first base of power named correctly (1)
  • A matching example from the case (1)
  • A second base of power named correctly (1)
  • A matching example from the case (1)

Examples: legitimate: says he is a detective, gives a name and badge number; coercive: she "could be in trouble herself"; reward: "You will get every penny back"; informational: gives reasons, such as criminals using her card and someone at the bank helping them.

2(b) Agency theory (3)

AO2 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate point, applied to the case.

  • The scammer claims a high place in a hierarchy, such as the police or a bank (1)
  • So the person sees themselves as an agent carrying out the caller's orders (1)
  • They hand responsibility to the "officer" and act against their own judgement (agentic state) (1)

At least one mark needs a link to the case, for example "We are responsible for this, not you" or being told to keep it secret.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

2(c) Milgram's technique (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying a similar technique and one mark for explaining why it works.

  • A similar technique: small requests first (her address, then £500, then £5,000); or scripted pressure such as "You are helping the police" (1)
  • Why it works: each step seems small, or there is no time to stop and think, so refusing is harder (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Part 3, exam-style question 1: data (2 marks) 3 min

  1. In Milgram's (1963) study, 14 of the 40 participants stopped before 450 volts. Of these 14, 5 stopped at 300 volts, the point where the learner pounded on the wall.

    Calculate the percentage of all 40 participants who stopped at 300 volts. Show your working. (1.1.2) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 1

Question 1 (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for the working and one mark for the answer.

  • 5 ÷ 40 × 100 (the working) (1)
  • 12.5% (the answer) (1)

Correct answer with no working: 2 marks. Allow 12.5 without the % sign.

Reject all other answers.

Part 3, exam-style question 2: pressure at work (3 marks) 5 min

  1. Scenario: Nadia works in a busy call centre. Her team leader tells her to tell customers that they cannot cancel their contracts by phone, although Nadia knows that they can. When Nadia looks worried, her team leader says: "Head office makes the rules, not you. If anyone complains, that's my problem." Nadia feels uncomfortable, but she says it to every caller.

    Explain Nadia's behaviour using agency theory. (1.1.1) (3)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 2

Question 2 (3)

AO2 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate point linked to Nadia.

  • Nadia is in the agentic state: she acts as the agent of her team leader and head office (1)
  • Responsibility is displaced ("that's my problem"), so she obeys against her own judgement (1)
  • Her discomfort is moral strain: the order goes against her morals, but she still obeys (1)

Each mark needs a link to Nadia. Also accept the agentic shift at work, or the hierarchy from team leader to head office.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Part 3, exam-style question 3: obeying an app (8 marks) 10 min

  1. Scenario: A ride-hailing company has no managers who direct its drivers. Instead, an app tells each driver which trips to take and which route to follow. The app sends a warning when a driver turns down too many trips, and it can block drivers whose customer ratings fall. It pays a bonus to drivers who work at busy times. Many drivers follow every instruction from the app, even when they think a route is slow or unsafe. "The app knows best," one says. A few drivers ignore the app and choose their own routes.

    Evaluate social power theory as an explanation of the drivers' obedience. You must refer to the context in your answer. (1.1.1) (8)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 3

Question 3 (8): levels-based. Credit points like these, then check the level

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (3 marks), AO3 (3 marks)

AO1

  • People obey because the source holds bases of power (French and Raven, 1959)

AO2

  • Coercive power: warnings, and blocking drivers with low ratings
  • Reward power: the bonus for working at busy times
  • Informational or expert power: "the app knows best" about traffic and demand
  • Also credit legitimate power: the app speaks for the company the drivers work for

AO3

  • Strength: it explains obedience with no person giving orders; the power is built into the app
  • Strength: one source holds several bases at once, which explains strong obedience
  • Weakness: it does not explain why a few drivers ignore the app (individual differences)
  • Weakness: agency theory may explain more: drivers hand responsibility to the app
  • A supported conclusion on how well the theory explains the drivers

Equal emphasis needed: knowledge and understanding (AO1), application (AO2) and evaluation and conclusion (AO3).

Generic answers score 0 marks.

LevelMarkDescriptor
00No rewardable material.
11-2A few facts about the theory; little link to the drivers.
23-4Accurate facts with some links to the drivers; one side evaluated.
35-6Accurate facts linked to the drivers; strengths and weaknesses.
47-8Detailed and well linked; balanced evaluation; a supported judgement.

Summary and checklist 2 min

  • Agency theory: people obey when they shift into the agentic state and hand responsibility to an authority figure. Obeying against your morals causes moral strain.
  • Social power theory: people obey because the source holds power: legitimate, coercive, reward, expert, referent or informational.
  • Milgram (1963): all 40 men went to at least 300 volts, and 65% went to 450 volts.

Before you hand in, check that you can:

  • name the agency theory term that a behaviour shows;
  • spot the bases of power in a real situation, such as a scam call or an app;
  • use Milgram's figures in a calculation and show your working;
  • write an 8-mark evaluation that links every point to the scenario.

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.