The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology
Directed study: review
Spaced repetition: obedience, social impact and trusting a study
Teach these first
This sheet goes back to earlier lessons, so teach them before students start it. They are listed, section by section, under What to revise at the bottom of the page.
How this sheet works
What is spaced repetition? We forget most quickly in the days and weeks after a lesson. Each time you bring something back from memory, just as it starts to fade, it stays with you for longer. So this sheet asks about earlier lessons, not about today's: section 1 goes back about a week, section 2 about a month, and section 3 further back.
Section 1: about a week back, with an exam-style question (9 marks) 10 min
| Study | Setting and authority figure | Full obedience |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline (1963) | Yale University; the experimenter in a lab coat | 65% |
| Rundown office block (Experiment 10) | A run-down office in Bridgeport, with no link to Yale | 47.5% |
| Ordinary man gives orders (Experiment 13) | Yale; an ordinary man in everyday clothes | 20% |
1(a). Calculate how many of the 40 participants went to 450 volts in the rundown office block study (Experiment 10). (1.1.2, Topic A) (1)
1(b). Exam-style question. Some critics said that Milgram's baseline result was mostly caused by the prestige of Yale University. Explain what the rundown office block study shows about this claim. Use the figures in the table. (1.1.2, Topic A) (3)
2. Explain how Dambrun and Vatine (2010) support the authoritarian personality as an explanation of obedience. (1.1.3, Topic A) (2)
3(a). In social impact theory, name the role of the people at label 1 and of the person at label 2. (1.1.4, Topic A) (2)
3(b). The three people at label 1 move from the back of a hall to stand right next to the person at label 2. Name the social force that increases. (1.1.4, Topic A) (1)
Reveal the mark scheme: section 1
1(a) Experiment 10 (1)
AO2 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for the number of participants.
- 47.5% of 40 = 19 participants (1)
Reject all other answers.
1(b) Exam-style question (3)
AO2 (2 marks), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for each accurate point that uses a figure from the table.
- Prestige played a part: full obedience fell from 65% at Yale to 47.5% in the run-down office (1)
- But 19 of 40, nearly half, still went to 450 volts with no link to Yale (1)
- So the claim is only partly true: the experimenter's authority still produced high obedience; prestige is one factor (1)
Full marks need at least one figure. Do not credit Experiment 13 figures used as evidence about prestige.
Generic answers score 0 marks.
2. Dambrun and Vatine (2)
AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for the finding and one mark for linking it to the theory.
- In a virtual (video) version of Milgram's study, people with higher authoritarian scores were less likely to withdraw (1)
- So people who submit to authority more readily obey more, as the theory predicts (1)
3(a) Source and target (2)
AO1 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for each role.
- Label 1: the sources (1)
- Label 2: the target (1)
3(b) The force (1)
AO1 (1 mark)
- Immediacy (1)
Reject all other answers.
Section 2: further back, the start of Topic A (5 marks) 5 min
4. Explain what is meant by the agentic shift. Use an example from Milgram's (1963) study. (1.1.1, Topic A) (2)
5. Describe what happened at the end of each session of Milgram's (1963) study, and explain why. (1.1.2, Topic A) (2)
6. In Milgram's (1963) study, 26 of the 40 participants went to 450 volts. Give the ratio of participants who went to 450 volts to participants who stopped earlier, in its simplest form. (1.1.2, Topic A) (1)
Reveal the mark scheme: section 2
4. The agentic shift (2)
AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for the explanation and one mark for the example from the study.
- The move from the autonomous state to the agentic state when a person meets an authority figure (1)
- For example: a teacher who wanted to stop carried on once the experimenter took responsibility and said "please continue" (1)
5. The end of each session (2)
AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for describing what happened and one mark for the reason.
- An interview, and a friendly meeting with the learner, who was unharmed (the debrief) (1)
- To protect the participant's wellbeing: to reduce stress and show that no one was hurt (1)
6. Ratio (1)
AO2 (1 mark)
- 26 : 14 = 13 : 7 (1)
14 : 26 or 13 : 20 does not earn the mark.
Reject all other answers.
Section 3: an earlier topic, Topic 0 (5 marks) 5 min
7. A researcher tests how well people drive while texting, using a driving simulator in a laboratory. Explain one reason why the findings may have low ecological validity. (2.2.9, Topic 0) (2)
8. Two observers watch the same 20-minute video of a playground and count acts of aggression. One counts 14 and the other counts 31. Explain what this suggests about the observation, and suggest one way to improve it. (2.2.9, Topic 0) (2)
9. A psychologist leaves out the participants whose results did not fit her hypothesis, so her findings look stronger than they are. Name the BPS principle she has broken. (1.2.9, Topic 0) (1)
Reveal the mark scheme: section 3
7. Ecological validity (2)
AO3 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for identifying one reason and one mark for justifying it.
- A simulator is not a real road: there is no real danger and no real traffic (1)
- So people may drive or text differently from real life, and the findings may not apply to real driving (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
8. Two observers (2)
AO3 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for the suggestion about the observation and one mark for the improvement.
- The counts are very different, so the observation is not reliable (not consistent between observers) (1)
- Improve: operationalise aggression, for example count only hits, kicks and pushes; or train the observers together (1)
Look for other reasonable marking points.
9. BPS principle (1)
AO1 (1 mark)
- Integrity (1)
Reject all other answers.
What to revise
- Dropped marks in Section 1? Revise these lessons: Milgram's variation studies: situational factors and dissent; Factors affecting obedience and dissent: personality, gender, situation and culture; Social roles and social impact theory.
- Dropped marks in Section 2? Revise these lessons: Agency theory: autonomous and agentic states; Milgram (1963): research into obedience.
- Dropped marks in Section 3? Revise these lessons: Can you trust this study? Objectivity, reliability, validity and more; Ethics and practical issues: the BPS code, Milgram and Burger.