The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Directed study: Moscovici (1969) in modern digital media

Spec 1.1.6, 1.3.1Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 50 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:

Teacher note: ground rules and an opt-out

A real person, and a topic students talk about. Students often ask about this influencer, and the page looks at him with a critical psychological eye: how a minority message spreads, not whether he is right or wrong.

Ground rules: talk about the psychology (consistency, conversion, normative and informational influence), not about the person or his viewers; use calm, respectful language; nobody has to say what they watch or what they think of him; no searching for, playing or sharing his videos in class or for homework.

Opt-out: any student can answer questions 1 to 4 about a strict fitness or diet influencer who repeats the same rule every day (for example "no sugar, ever"). The mark points still apply. The exam question (Leo) and the stretch need no change.

Key words: Moscovici's concepts

Diachronic consistency
The minority keeps exactly the same message and stance over a long period of time.
Synchronic consistency
All the members of the minority give the same view at the same time.
Cognitive conflict and conversion
A majority makes people comply in public (normative social influence). A minority that never wavers makes the majority question its own views. This deeper thinking can lead to a real, private change of belief (conversion).
Shifting the "perceptual code"
In Part 2 of Moscovici et al. (1969), participants moved their private boundary between blue and green on the Farnsworth discs. A consistent minority can change the way people see things.
The snowball effect
A minority first persuades a few open-minded members of the majority. As more people switch, the idea spreads faster, until it becomes the majority view.

Reading: disrupting the consensus 10 min

How online minorities shift mainstream ideas

In 1969, Serge Moscovici made a bold claim: social change is driven not by majorities, but by small minorities who refuse to change their message. Majorities use numbers to make people conform. Minorities have a different tool: consistency.

Today we can see this in online influencer communities. One example that many students have heard of is Andrew Tate, a former kickboxer. In 2022, short clips of his videos spread very fast on social media. In them he set out his own ideas about how men should live, about money and status, and about men and women. These were minority views, and many people, including many parents and teachers, strongly criticised them. Teachers in several countries said that pupils were talking about the videos in school.

In this self-study you do not judge him or his viewers. You use Moscovici's findings to explain a psychological question: how can a message from a small group spread so far, so fast?

1. Consistency, used on purpose

Moscovici showed that when the confederates wavered (saying "green" on only 24 of 36 trials), their influence fell from 8.42% to just 1.25%. Many online influencers keep one message and repeat it. Over many podcasts, interviews and videos, Tate's core message stayed the same: diachronic consistency. In 2022, news reports also said that members of his paid online course were encouraged to repost short clips of him. So the same clips appeared again and again, at the same time, on many accounts: synchronic consistency.

2. Cognitive conflict: conversion, not compliance

In Asch's studies, participants faced a majority and conformed out loud so as not to stand out (normative social influence and compliance). But when a minority states a bold opinion with total certainty, it creates cognitive conflict. Viewers who are still forming their own views may start to ask: "Why is he so sure? Could he be right?" This deeper thinking can lead to real, private change: conversion. The same process can also lead people to think the message through and reject it.

3. Shifting the "perceptual code" behind a privacy screen

In Part 2 of Moscovici's study, participants sat behind cardboard screens and judged ambiguous discs in private. Even some who had never agreed with the confederates out loud now called more discs "green": their private boundary between blue and green had moved. Online spaces work in a similar way. A teenager scrolling on a phone is alone behind a digital "privacy screen", away from friends, teachers and parents. Over time, ideas such as success, school or friendship can start to look different to the viewer.

In August 2022, several platforms, including TikTok, Instagram and YouTube, removed Tate's accounts.

Guided research and media deconstruction (10 marks) 15 min

You do not need to search for or watch any of his videos for this task. Use the reading above and what you already know about how influencers work online. Do not post or comment anywhere. If you would rather not write about this example, answer questions 1 to 4 about a strict fitness or diet influencer who posts the same message every day instead: the questions work the same way.

  1. Identifying consistency: describe one way an online influencer shows synchronic consistency (for example many accounts posting the same clips or sounds) and one way they show diachronic consistency (for example repeating the same key phrases and the same message for years). (2)

    Synchronic
    Diachronic
  2. The digital "cardboard screen": in Part 2 of Moscovici's study, private written answers behind cardboard screens revealed private conversion. Explain how using a smartphone alone is like Moscovici's cardboard screen, compared with a public class discussion. (3)

  3. Shifting the perceptual code: in Moscovici's study, the minority moved the boundary between "blue" and "green". Identify one everyday idea that a lifestyle influencer can redefine for viewers (for example what counts as success, or whether school is worth it), and link it to Moscovici. (2)

  4. Rigidity or flexibility: Nemeth and Brilmayer (1987) found that a minority seen as rigid and unwilling to compromise loses influence. Explain how an influencer's refusal to compromise can make a minority less persuasive, and lead to resistance from the wider majority. (3)

Hints for the deconstruction task

Think about watching in private: in public, people often say what the group around them expects (to avoid disapproval, NSI). Alone with a phone, nobody is watching, so any change happens in private (conversion). For question 4, think about how refusing to adapt can make a message look extreme, and lead to pushback from platforms, schools and the public.

Reveal the model answers: deconstruction task

Question 1 (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate example of synchronic and diachronic consistency.

  • Synchronic: many accounts post the same short clips or sounds at the same time (1)
  • Diachronic: the same message and key phrases, repeated for years without changing (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Question 2 (3)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate point.

  • In class, students may say what the group expects, to avoid disapproval: compliance (1)
  • Alone on a phone, there is no audience, so no normative pressure (1)
  • As behind Moscovici's screens, a change can happen in private: conversion (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Question 3 (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying one idea and one mark for linking it to Moscovici.

  • One idea redefined, for example success as money and status, or school as a waste of time (1)
  • Like the blue-green boundary, the viewer's "code" for judging it moves (perceptual code) (1)

Also credit other ideas, for example friendship, health or work, if linked to the boundary shift.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Question 4 (3)

AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate point.

  • Refusing to compromise looks rigid and dogmatic (Nemeth and Brilmayer, 1987) (1)
  • So the wider majority sees the minority as unreasonable, and is less persuaded (1)
  • This leads to resistance, for example platforms removing accounts, or public criticism (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Exam practice scenario: AO1 (2) and AO2 (4) (6 marks) 10 min

  1. Scenario: Leo is a 16-year-old student who recently started following an online lifestyle influencer. The influencer and his inner circle keep posting videos saying that school qualifications are "completely useless" and that real success means joining their paid crypto-trading network. At first, Leo believed school was essential for his future. After watching dozens of near-identical videos every day for two months, he begins planning, in private, to drop out. In his business exam, he writes that a normal job is a "scam".

    Explain Leo's behaviour using findings and concepts from Moscovici et al. (1969). Refer to the scenario in your answer. (6)

Hint for the 6-mark exam question

Build your answer around two concepts: (1) consistency, synchronic (the influencer and his inner circle) and diachronic (two months of the same message); and (2) conversion, a shifted perceptual code (shown by his private plans and his own exam answer). Balance AO1 (the study) with AO2 (Leo).

Reveal the mark scheme and model answer

Exam question (6)

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (4 marks)

AO1: credit one mark for each accurate point from the study. AO2: credit one mark for each accurate point applied to Leo.

AO1 (2)

  • A consistent minority had more influence: 8.42% "green" against 1.25% when inconsistent (1)
  • Minority influence can cause private conversion: in Part 2, private disc judgements shifted (1)

AO2 (4)

  • The influencer and his inner circle all say the same thing: synchronic consistency (1)
  • Dozens of near-identical videos for two months: diachronic consistency (1)
  • Leo has changed his private view: he plans in private to drop out (1)
  • He writes it in his own exam, alone: conversion, not compliance to impress peers (1)

No AO2 marks without a link to Leo.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Model answer

Moscovici et al. (1969) found that a consistent minority had more influence (8.42% "green" answers) than an inconsistent one (1.25%) (AO1). The influencer and his inner circle all repeat the same message, and Leo watches it every day for two months: synchronic and diachronic consistency (AO2). In Part 2, private judgements behind screens also shifted, showing real conversion (AO1). Leo has not just agreed to impress friends: he plans to drop out in private and writes his new view in his own exam, so his private view has changed (AO2).

Synoptic stretch: lab models or digital reality? (8 marks) 15 min

Think about these two points before you write:

  • A trivial task or deep identity? Moscovici's participants judged blue slides, a simple task with no personal stake. Does that limit how far it can explain why young people adopt lifestyle ideas that involve identity, money and moral values?
  • Social impact theory: Moscovici used a fixed group of six (four naive participants, two confederates). Latané's social impact theory says impact depends on Strength, Immediacy and Number. Do modern influencers rely more on Moscovici's consistency, or on Latané's Strength (showing wealth and luxury) and Immediacy (notifications straight to a phone, all day)?
  1. Evaluate whether laboratory experiments such as Moscovici et al. (1969) can fully explain the spread of modern online movements. (8)

Reveal the discussion notes and mark scheme (A/A* extension)

Stretch question (8)

AO1 (4 marks), AO3 (4 marks)

AO1

  • A consistent minority 8.42% "green" against 1.25% inconsistent
  • In Part 2 private judgements shifted: conversion
  • Social impact depends on Strength, Immediacy and Number (Latané)

AO3

  • The lab task had no personal stake: low ecological validity. Taking on an influencer's beliefs can affect friendships, schoolwork and family life, so the lab may underestimate the emotion and doubt involved in real conversion
  • Real movements involve identity, money and morals
  • Consistency still explains the repeated, identical online messages
  • Strength (status, wealth) and Immediacy (notifications, daily livestreams) explain the spread better than a group of six
  • Only female students in 1969, so generalising to young male viewers online is uncertain
  • A supported conclusion on how far the lab explains online movements

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Equal emphasis needed: knowledge and understanding (AO1) and evaluation and conclusion (AO3).

Levels for the 8-mark question
LevelMarkDescriptor
00No rewardable material.
11 to 2A few facts about the study (AO1). Little or no evaluation (AO3).
23 to 4Accurate facts (AO1). Evaluates one side only (AO3).
35 to 6Accurate facts (AO1). Evaluates both sides (AO3).
47 to 8Thorough, accurate facts (AO1). Both sides developed and a supported judgement (AO3).

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.