The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Directed study: dissent, whistleblowers and authority today

Spec 1.1.2, 1.1.3Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 40 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Part 1 key-term calibration: the situation (Milgram's variations)

Situational factors
Features of the physical and social environment that affect how a person behaves.
Proximity
How physically close the authority figure is.
Prestige
How much respect a place or a person has, for example a famous university.
Legitimate authority
Authority that people accept as real and rightful, for example because of a role or a uniform.
Dissent
Refusing to obey an order from an authority figure. It is also called resistance.

Part 1 key-term calibration: personality and culture

Individual differences
Ways in which people differ, such as personality and gender, that change how they behave in the same situation.
Authoritarian personality
A personality that respects and submits to authority, likes clear rules and looks down on people of lower status. It is measured with the F-scale (Adorno et al., 1950).
Internal locus of control
Believing that you are responsible for your own actions and what happens to you.
External locus of control
Believing that outside forces, such as luck or powerful people, control what happens to you.
Individualistic culture
A culture that values independence and personal goals, and accepts dissent.
Collectivistic culture
A culture that values interdependence, group harmony and cooperation.

Part 1: retrieval and key-term calibration (8 marks) 8 min

Answer from memory first. Use the key words above: they are the words the mark scheme looks for.

  1. Four findings from lesson 4:

    1. Obedient participants from Milgram's studies scored higher on the F-scale than those who dissented.
    2. All 13 women, but only 7 of the 13 men, gave the maximum shock to a live puppy.
    3. A review of 10 obedience studies that compared men and women found no difference in 9 of them.
    4. Under similar lockdown rules, people in more collectivistic countries cut their movement more.

    Name the researchers behind each finding (i) to (iv). (1.1.3) (4)

    (i)
    (ii)
    (iii)
    (iv)
  2. Give the percentage of participants who went to 450 volts in (i) the rundown office block (Experiment 10) and (ii) ordinary man gives orders (Experiment 13). (1.1.2) (2)

    (i)
    (ii)
  3. In the rundown office block (Experiment 10), the procedure was the same, but the study had no link to Yale University. Explain which base of social power this weakened. (1.1.1, 1.1.2) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: Part 1

1(a) Name the study (4)

AO1 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for each study named correctly.

  • (i) Elms and Milgram (1966) (1)
  • (ii) Sheridan and King (1972) (1)
  • (iii) Blass (1999) (1)
  • (iv) Frey, Chen and Presidente (2020) (accept Frey et al.) (1)

Reject all other answers.

1(b) Two variations (2)

AO1 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each correct percentage.

  • (i) 47.5% (1)
  • (ii) 20% (1)

Reject all other answers.

1(c) Power and place (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for identifying the base of social power and one mark for applying it to the office block.

  • Legitimate power (accept expert power) (1)
  • With no link to a famous university, the experimenter's role seems less real or rightful, so his orders carry less weight (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Part 2 key word

Whistleblower
A person who reports wrongdoing at their workplace to someone who can act on it, such as a senior manager, a regulator or a journalist.

Part 2: a real-world case: a man who refused to stay silent

Milgram's variations show that dissent rises when the authority figure is far away, less respected or lower in status. Lesson 4 added personality, gender and culture. But some real people refuse to obey even when the authority is close, powerful and respected. In this part you analyse one real case of dissent with the theories you have learned. In lesson 1 you met Lieutenant Calley, who said he was "just following orders" at My Lai in the Vietnam War. This case is about the same day. It is about the killing of civilians, but it gives no details of the killings.

Hugh Thompson at My Lai (1968). Hugh Thompson was a US Army helicopter pilot. On 16 March 1968 he was flying over the village of My Lai with his crew. From the air, he saw US soldiers killing unarmed villagers. The soldiers were following orders from their officers. Thompson was in a different unit from the soldiers on the ground. He landed his helicopter between the soldiers and a group of villagers, and helped the villagers to safety. Then he reported the killings to his senior officers. For many years after this, many people in the US criticised him. In March 1998, 30 years later, the US Army gave him and his crew the Soldier's Medal for bravery.

Teacher note: further reading and a warning

Part 2 needs no source of their own: the case on the page is enough. For students who want to read more (no sign-in or payment): the Wikipedia article "Hugh Thompson Jr."; obituaries from January 2006 by CBS News and Voice of America, which are short. Thompson's crew were Lawrence Colburn and Glenn Andreotta. Avoid sending students to the "My Lai massacre" article: it has distressing detail.

The case is about the killing of civilians. The text on the page gives no details, but warn students before they read more.

Part 2: guided analysis (8 marks) 12 min

  1. Use one of Milgram's variation studies to explain one situational factor that made Thompson's dissent easier or harder. (1.1.2) (3)

  2. Explain how one individual difference (locus of control, the authoritarian personality or gender) could help explain why Thompson dissented when others obeyed. (1.1.3) (3)

  3. People who refuse orders or report wrongdoing, like Thompson, often lose friends or their jobs. Use social power theory to explain why many people in the same situation stay quiet. (1.1.1) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: Part 2

2(a) The situation (3)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each point below, up to three marks.

  • A situational factor and its variation: proximity (Exp 7), prestige (Exp 10) or status (Exp 13) (1)
  • Its result: for example obedience fell to 22.5% when orders came by phone (1)
  • A link to the case: for example the officers giving the orders were not close by, as Thompson was in the air and in a different unit (1)

Also credit the opposite: a close, high-status authority (officers, in a war) made dissent harder.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

2(b) The person (3)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying the factor, one mark for explaining it and one mark for linking it to the case.

  • Names the factor, for example an internal locus of control (1)
  • Explains it: they feel responsible for their own actions, so they resist pressure from authority (1)
  • A link to the case, for example Thompson acted and reported the killings on his own judgement (1)

Also accept a low authoritarian (F-scale) score: less submissive to authority. Gender only with care: Blass (1999) found no sex difference in 9 of 10 studies.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

2(c) The cost of dissent (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for each type of social power linked to staying quiet.

  • Coercive power: people fear punishment, such as being fired, threatened or rejected (1)
  • Reward power: they could lose pay, promotion or approval, so staying quiet seems safer (1)

Also accept legitimate power: the person giving the order holds a rightful place in the hierarchy.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Part 3, exam-style questions 1 and 2: badges online (5 marks) 8 min

  1. A researcher studied an online gaming community (made-up data for practice). On 60 occasions, a moderator with a coloured "MOD" badge next to their name told a player to stop spamming the chat. On 60 other occasions, an ordinary player with no badge gave the same instruction in the same words. Players stopped on 48 of the 60 occasions with the moderator, and on 15 of the 60 occasions with the ordinary player.

    Calculate the percentage of occasions on which players obeyed (i) the moderator and (ii) the ordinary player. (1.1.2) (2)

    (i)
    (ii)
  2. Explain the difference in obedience in the gaming study, using Milgram's ordinary man gives orders variation (Experiment 13). (1.1.2) (3)

Reveal the mark scheme: questions 1 and 2

Question 1 (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each correct percentage.

  • (i) 48 ÷ 60 × 100 = 80% (1)
  • (ii) 15 ÷ 60 × 100 = 25% (1)

Reject all other answers.

Question 2 (3)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each point below, up to three marks.

  • In Experiment 13, obedience fell to 20% when an ordinary man gave the orders (1)
  • The badge works like the experimenter's lab coat: a sign of status and legitimate authority (1)
  • With no badge, the player has no status, so obedience is low: 25%, close to Experiment 13 (1)

The third mark needs a link to the data.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Part 3, exam-style question 3: dissent in a hospital team (8 marks) 10 min

  1. Scenario: At a busy hospital, a senior surgeon tells the operating team to skip the safety checklist before an operation, to save time. Most of the team say nothing and carry on. Two junior nurses refuse to start until the checklist is done. One of them, Ama, has always believed that what happens to her patients is her own responsibility. Later, she reports the surgeon through a new system that lets staff report safety problems without giving their name. The other nurse says she only spoke up because Ama spoke first.

    Assess whether individual differences or situational factors better explain the two nurses' dissent. You must refer to the context in your answer. (1.1.3) (8)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 3

Question 3 (8): levels-based

AO1 (3 marks), AO2 (2 marks), AO3 (3 marks)

AO1

  • Individual differences: an internal locus of control (Rotter, 1966) or a low authoritarian score
  • Situational factors: proximity, prestige and status of the authority (Milgram's variations)

AO2

  • Ama feels responsible for her patients: an internal locus of control, so she resists
  • The surgeon is close and high in status, so the situation pushes the team to obey
  • The second nurse spoke up only after Ama: a change in her situation, not her personality
  • Reporting without a name lowers the cost of dissent: less coercive power

AO3

  • Hofling et al. (1966): 21 of 22 nurses obeyed, so this setting usually brings obedience
  • Elms and Milgram (1966) is a correlation, so personality may not cause dissent
  • Blass (1991): personality and situation work together (interactionist)
  • A judgement: for example Ama's dissent fits individual differences; the second nurse's fits the situation

Gender is unlikely to explain it: both nurses are women, and Blass (1999) found no sex difference in 9 of 10 studies.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Equal emphasis needed: knowledge and understanding (AO1), application (AO2) and evaluation and conclusion (AO3).

Levels for the 8-mark question
LevelMarkDescriptor
00No rewardable material.
11 to 2A few facts about the factors (AO1). Little link to the nurses (AO2).
23 to 4Accurate facts with some links to the nurses (AO1, AO2). One side weighed (AO3).
35 to 6Both kinds of factor, linked to the nurses (AO2). Some weighing (AO3).
47 to 8Both kinds, well linked and weighed (AO2, AO3). A supported judgement (AO3).

Summary and checklist 2 min

  • Situation (Milgram's variations): obedience fell from 65% to 22.5% when orders came by phone (proximity), to 47.5% in a run-down office (prestige) and to 20% when an ordinary man gave the orders (status).
  • Personality: an authoritarian personality and an external locus of control are linked to obedience; an internal locus of control to dissent.
  • Gender: Milgram's 40 women obeyed at the same rate as men (65%); Blass (1999) found no difference in 9 of 10 studies.
  • Culture: collectivistic cultures value harmony and may comply more (Frey et al., 2020); individualistic cultures accept dissent.

Before you hand in, check that you can:

  • give the result of each variation and the situational factor it shows;
  • name the researchers behind the findings on personality, gender and culture;
  • apply situational factors and individual differences to a real case of dissent;
  • write an 8-mark answer that weighs both kinds of factor and reaches a judgement.

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.