The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Self-study: explanations and types of conformity

Spec 1.1.4Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 50 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Section 1 key words: the dual-process model (Deutsch and Gerard, 1955)

Normative social influence (NSI)
The wish to be liked and accepted. It happens in social situations where people fear rejection. It leads to public compliance.
Informational social influence (ISI)
The wish to be right. It happens in unclear or unfamiliar situations, where other people seem to be experts. It leads to private acceptance (internalisation).

Section 1: core differences and concept recap (6 marks) 13 min

  1. Complete the comparison matrix for compliance and internalisation. Fill in cells (a) to (f) from memory first, then check your lesson notes. (1.1.4) (6)

    Comparison matrix: fill in cells (a) to (f)
    ComplianceInternalisation
    Main motive(a)(b)
    Public or private change?(c)(d)
    How long does the change last?(e)(f)
    (a)
    (b)
    (c)
    (d)
    (e)
    (f)
Reveal the completed matrix

Section 1: the matrix (6)

AO1 (6 marks)

Credit one mark for each correct cell. Reject all other answers.

  • (a) To gain approval or avoid disapproval (NSI) (1)
  • (b) To be correct: to hold a valid belief (ISI) (1)
  • (c) Public agreement only; private views stay the same (1)
  • (d) Both public behaviour and private belief change (1)
  • (e) Temporary: it stops when the group pressure goes (1)
  • (f) Lasting: it stays even when the group is not there (1)

Section 2 key words: social impact theory (Latané, 1981)

Strength (S)
The status, authority or age of the source of influence.
Immediacy (I)
How close the source and the target are, in space or in time.
Number (N)
How many sources are trying to influence the target.
Divisional effect
When one source tries to influence many targets, the impact on each target gets smaller.

Section 2: guided scenario task (3 marks) 10 min

  1. Consider these two scenarios:

    • Scenario A: a strict headteacher (high strength, high immediacy) tells 2 students in a quiet corridor to stop talking.
    • Scenario B: a student (low strength) shouts across a crowded stadium of 200 people to stop talking.

    Explain which scenario will produce more compliance. Use strength, immediacy and number, and the divisional effect. (1.1.4) (3)

Reveal the scenario analysis and explanation

Section 2: the scenarios (3)

AO2 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for the judgement and one mark for each reason that is applied to a scenario. Generic answers score 0 marks.

  • Scenario A produces more compliance (1)
  • A: high strength and high immediacy, on only 2 targets (1)
  • B: low strength and low immediacy, divided among 200 targets (divisional effect) (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Model answer: Scenario A will produce far more compliance. The headteacher has high status (strength) and is close by in the corridor (immediacy), and the impact falls on only two students. In Scenario B the source is a peer (low strength), far away (low immediacy), and the impact is spread across 200 people (the divisional effect), so each person feels very little pressure.

Section 3, question 1 (2 marks) 5 min

  1. Describe one difference between compliance and internalisation as types of conformity. (1.1.4) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 1

Question 1 (2)

AO1 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate description. Reject all other answers.

  • Compliance: public behaviour changes, private beliefs do not (1)
  • Internalisation: public behaviour and private beliefs both change, for good (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Example answer: Compliance means going along with a group in public to fit in, while secretly keeping your own opinion. Internalisation is a real, lasting change: your public behaviour and your private belief both match the group.

Section 3, question 2: application (4 marks) 10 min

  1. Scenario: Maya joins a new fitness class. At first, she copies the stretching routines because everyone else is doing them and she does not want to look foolish (Situation A). Later, the instructor explains how one core exercise helps the body. Maya becomes convinced that it improves her posture, and she starts doing it at home every morning (Situation B).

    Explain which explanation of conformity is shown in Situation A and which in Situation B. Use psychological terms. (1.1.4) (4)

    Situation A
    Situation B
Reveal the mark scheme: question 2

Question 2 (4)

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each explanation identified (AO1) and one mark for each link to Maya (AO2). Generic answers score 0 marks.

  • A: normative social influence (accept compliance) (1)
  • A: she copies to avoid looking foolish: for approval (1)
  • B: informational social influence (accept internalisation) (1)
  • B: she accepts the instructor's expert information and does it alone at home (1)

The second mark for each situation must refer to Maya.

Section 3, question 3: evaluation (4 marks) 12 min

  1. Evaluate social impact theory as an explanation of conformity. (1.1.4) (4)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 3

Question 3 (4): max 4

AO3 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate point of evaluation. Max 4. Generic answers score 0 marks.

  • Strength: it predicts impact from S, I and N, so it can be tested (1)
  • Developed: for example, more compliance to a close, high-status source (1)
  • Weakness: it describes when influence happens, but not why (unlike NSI and ISI) (1)
  • Developed: targets are passive in the formula; personality is ignored (1)
  • A brief judgement that weighs the strength against the weakness (1)

Full marks need a strength and a weakness of social impact theory, not of conformity in general.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.