The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Directed study: social power and agency theory in action

Spec 1.1.1Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 40 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Part 1 key-term calibration: social power theory (French and Raven, 1959)

Legitimate power
Power from a position in a hierarchy, for example a police officer or a manager.
Coercive power
Power to punish, for example with a fine, an arrest or the loss of a job.
Reward power
Power to give something good, for example a bonus or a prize.
Expert power
Power from special knowledge or skills, for example a doctor or a mechanic.
Referent power
Power from being liked or admired, so that others want to be like you.

Part 1 key-term calibration: agency theory (Milgram, 1974)

Agentic state
You see yourself as the agent of an authority figure. You hand responsibility for your actions to that person.
Moral strain
Anxiety and distress when an order goes against your morals, but you obey anyway.
Displaced responsibility
Passing the responsibility for your actions to the authority figure: "I was only following orders."

Part 1: retrieval and key-term calibration (8 marks) 8 min

Answer from memory first. Use the key words above: they are the words the mark scheme looks for.

  1. Three short cases:

    1. A mechanic tells a driver: "Do not drive on that tyre. It could burst."
    2. A fan buys the trainers her favourite singer wears, because she wants to be like her.
    3. A teacher says: "Everyone who finishes early gets a house point."

    Name the base of social power that each line (i) to (iii) shows. (1.1.1) (3)

    (i)
    (ii)
    (iii)
  2. Give these three facts about Hofling et al. (1966). (1.1.1) (3)

    Number of nurses phoned
    Number who set off to give the drug
    A rule that the order broke
  3. Gretchen Brandt refused to carry on in one of Milgram's studies. Explain which weakness of agency theory this shows. (1.1.1) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: Part 1

1(a) Spot the base (3)

AO1 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each correct base of power.

  • (i) Expert power (1)
  • (ii) Referent power (1)
  • (iii) Reward power (1)

Reject all other answers.

1(b) Hofling et al. (1966) (3)

AO1 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate statement.

  • 22 (1)
  • 21 (95%) (1)
  • Phone orders were banned (accept: the dose was above the maximum on the label) (1)

Reject all other answers.

1(c) A weakness (2)

AO3 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying the weakness and one mark for justifying it.

  • It ignores individual differences (1)
  • Brandt was in the same situation as people who obeyed, but she kept the responsibility herself, so the theory cannot explain her (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Part 2: a case: three people, three bases

Read this case, then analyse it with the theories you have learned.

The stream. A Year 12 class is on a hiking trip. Their teacher, Mr Osei, is the trip leader. The group also has a mountain guide, Ines, who has led walks in these hills for twenty years. At a stream swollen by rain, Ines says: "We do not cross here. The water is too fast." Mr Osei says: "We are behind. We cross now, and anyone who holds the group up will lose a place on next term's trip." Dev, the captain of the school football team, whom the whole class admires, says: "Let's cross." Most of the class cross, including Priya. She thinks it is unsafe. Later she says: "It wasn't my decision. Mr Osei told us to."

Part 2: guided analysis (9 marks) 12 min

  1. Identify two different bases of social power that Mr Osei uses. For each one, describe what he says or does to show it. (1.1.1) (4)

    Base 1
    Shown by
    Base 2
    Shown by
  2. Ines has expert power, but most of the class obeyed Mr Osei. Explain one reason why. (1.1.1) (2)

  3. Use agency theory to explain Priya's behaviour. Use the case. (1.1.1) (3)

Reveal the mark scheme: Part 2

2(a) Social power theory (4): credit points like these

AO2 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying each base and one mark for the matching detail from the case. Answers must relate to two different bases.

  • A first base named correctly (1)
  • A matching detail from the case (1)
  • A second base named correctly (1)
  • A matching detail from the case (1)

Examples: legitimate: he is the teacher and trip leader ("We cross now"); coercive: "anyone who holds the group up will lose a place on next term's trip". Do not credit reward power: he offers nothing good.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

2(b) The guide (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for a reason and one mark for developing it, in relation to the case.

  • Mr Osei holds legitimate and coercive power, so the class felt they had to obey him (1)
  • Ines can advise but cannot punish or give orders, so her expert power was weaker (1)

Accept other reasons with a link to the case. Referent power is not a reason here: Dev is admired but is not the leader.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

2(c) Agency theory (3)

AO2 (3 marks)

Credit up to three marks for an accurate explanation in relation to the case.

  • Priya is in the agentic state: she acts as the agent of Mr Osei (1)
  • She displaces responsibility: "It wasn't my decision. Mr Osei told us to." (1)
  • She feels moral strain: she thinks it is unsafe, but obeys against her own judgement (1)

Each mark needs a link to Priya. Also accept hierarchy: the teacher is above the pupils.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Part 3, exam-style question 1: data (2 marks) 3 min

  1. In Hofling et al. (1966), 21 of the 22 nurses set off to give the drug. Calculate the percentage of the nurses who set off. Give your answer to the nearest whole number. Show your working. (1.1.1) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 1

Question 1 (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for the working and one mark for the answer.

  • 21 ÷ 22 × 100 (accept 0.9545...) (1)
  • Answer: 95% (1)

Correct answer with no working: 2 marks.

Reject all other answers.

Part 3, exam-style question 2: a museum (3 marks) 4 min

  1. Scenario: Leila visits a museum with her cousin. A guide in the museum's uniform tells her to stop filming, and says that anyone who carries on will be asked to leave. Leila puts her phone away.

    Name one type of social power. (1.1.1) (1)

  2. Describe, using social power theory, why Leila obeyed the guide. (1.1.1) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 2

Question 2(a) (1)

AO1 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for an accurate statement.

  • Any one of: legitimate, coercive, reward, expert, referent (accept informational) (1)

Reject all other answers.

Question 2(b) (2)

AO2 (2 marks)

Credit up to two marks for an accurate description in relation to the scenario.

  • Legitimate power: the guide wears the museum's uniform, so Leila accepts the guide's role (1)
  • Coercive power: Leila would be asked to leave if she carried on (1)

Each mark needs a link to the scenario. A list of the types of power scores 0.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Part 3, exam-style question 3: a senior consultant (8 marks) 11 min

  1. Scenario: Dr Rao is a junior doctor. Dr Hale, the senior consultant, tells her to send a patient home early to free a bed. Dr Rao thinks the patient is not ready, but she signs the form. "It is his decision," she tells a nurse. Dr Hale writes her yearly report. Dr Rao says she respects his skill as a surgeon.

    Discuss, using social power theory and agency theory, why Dr Rao obeyed Dr Hale. You must refer to the context in your answer. (1.1.1) (8)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 3

Question 3 (8): levels-based. Credit points like these, then check the level

AO1 (4 marks), AO2 (4 marks)

AO1

  • Social power theory: obedience depends on the bases of power the authority holds
  • Legitimate, expert and coercive power, each described
  • Agency theory: in the agentic state a person hands responsibility to the authority
  • Obeying against your morals causes moral strain

AO2

  • Legitimate power: Dr Hale is the senior consultant, above Dr Rao in the hospital hierarchy
  • Expert power: she respects his skill as a surgeon
  • Coercive power: he writes her yearly report
  • Agentic state: she displaces responsibility ("It is his decision"); moral strain: she thinks the patient is not ready

Look for other reasonable marking points. Each AO2 point must be linked to Dr Rao.

Equal emphasis needed: knowledge and understanding (AO1) and application (AO2).

Levels
LevelMarkDescriptor
00No rewardable material.
Level 11 to 2A few facts about one theory (AO1). Little or no reference to Dr Rao (AO2).
Level 23 to 4Mostly accurate facts about both theories (AO1). Some links to Dr Rao, partly developed (AO2).
Level 35 to 6Accurate facts (AO1). Both theories used well on the case, with reasoning, but imbalanced (AO2).
Level 47 to 8Accurate, thorough facts (AO1). Both theories applied throughout, with a balanced discussion of why she obeyed (AO2).

Summary and checklist 2 min

  • Social power theory: people obey because the source holds power: legitimate, coercive, reward, expert or referent (and informational, added by Raven in 1965).
  • Agency theory: people obey when they shift into the agentic state and hand responsibility to an authority figure. Obeying against your morals causes moral strain.
  • Hofling et al. (1966): 21 of 22 nurses set off to give a drug on a phone order that broke hospital rules.

Before you hand in, check that you can:

  • name the base of power in a short case, with a detail to show it;
  • use agency theory words (agentic state, displaced responsibility, moral strain) on a case;
  • show your working in a percentage calculation;
  • write an 8-mark discussion that links every point to the scenario.

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.