The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology

Directed study: exam technique

Exam technique: explain it in context. Name it, find it, link it

Spec 1.1.1 to 1.1.4Directed study: exam techniqueExam techniqueAbout 46 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

How this page works

One exam skill, in four steps: learn the skill, see it done, practise it with help, then do it on your own.

Step 1: the skill 5 min

An application question (AO2) gives you a scenario: a short story about people. The marks are for using psychology to explain what those people do. Make three moves for every point:

  1. Name it: the term that fits, for example compliance, ISI or legitimate power.
  2. Find it: the detail in the scenario that shows it. Quote a few words.
  3. Link it: say how the detail shows the term, and what it leads to. Use "so" or "because".
One point, three moves. Scenario: Lahiru tells his cricket team that he loves their new kit colour, but at home he tells his mother it is ugly.
MoveWhat Lahiru's answer says
Name itCompliance, caused by normative social influence (NSI).
Find it"tells his team he loves" it, but "at home ... it is ugly".
Link itHe agrees in public to fit in with the team, but his private view does not change, so it is compliance, not internalisation.

The cover test. Cover the names in your answer. If it would still fit any story, it is not applied yet.

How the marks usually split. In a 3-mark "Explain ... using ..." question, about one mark is for the right psychology and the rest are for linking it to details in the scenario. An answer with no link to the story rarely earns more than one mark.

Key words: the terms you will apply

Compliance
Going along with the group in public while privately disagreeing. It does not last.
Identification
Taking on the views and behaviour of a group you want to belong to, while you are with it.
Internalisation
Really accepting the group's view: public and private views change, and the change lasts.
Normative social influence (NSI)
Conforming because you want to be liked and accepted.
Informational social influence (ISI)
Conforming because you are unsure and believe the group knows what is right.
Agentic state
Seeing yourself as the agent of an authority figure, so the responsibility is theirs.

Common misconceptions and exam errors

These come up again and again in the reports on real exam answers. Each one costs marks.

  1. Knowing the theory but never mentioning the people in the question. A correct definition with no link to the scenario usually earns nothing in an application question.
  2. Dropping the name in. Ending with "this is why Senuri conformed" is not application. Use the details: what the person said, did or felt.
  3. Copying out the story. Repeating the scenario with no psychology earns nothing. Pair every detail with a term.
  4. Choosing the wrong type of conformity. Check two things: did the person's private view change, and does the change last when the group is not there?
  5. Giving two people the same explanation. If two people behave differently, explain each one with their own details.
  6. Stopping at the first mark. Naming the term earns a start. The details and the "so" earn the rest.

Step 2: worked example 6 min

Scenario: Ishara starts work at a busy hospital. On her first day she sees that all the senior nurses wash their hands for a full 30 seconds before they touch a patient. At college she was taught that 20 seconds is enough. She is not sure who is right, so she copies them. Two years later, at another hospital, she still washes her hands for 30 seconds and tells new nurses to do the same.

Question: Explain Ishara's behaviour, using informational social influence. (3)

Answer 1 0 of 3 marks

Informational social influence is when people conform because they want to be right. They look to others who know more, in an unclear situation. It usually leads to internalisation.

Why: The psychology is right, but there is nothing about Ishara. It would fit any question on ISI.

Answer 2 1 of 3 marks

ISI is conforming because you want to be right and think others know more (1). This is why Ishara washed her hands for 30 seconds.

Why: The definition earns a mark, but the last sentence just drops her name in. It does not show which details point to ISI.

Answer 3 3 of 3 marks

Ishara is unsure what is right, because her college said 20 seconds but the senior nurses take 30, so this is ISI: she wants to be right (1). She treats the senior nurses as the experts, so she copies them (1). It led to internalisation: she still does it two years later at a new hospital and teaches others, so her private view has changed (1).

Why: Every mark names the psychology and joins it to a detail from the story with "so" or "because".

Step 3: guided practice (13 marks) 14 min

Use the frames: the words in italics tell you what each gap needs.

  1. Scenario: Mrs Wickramasinghe is the principal of a large school. She tells Dilan, a new teaching assistant, to take a student's phone away for the rest of the week. Dilan thinks the punishment is too harsh. He says to a colleague: "It isn't my decision. She's the principal, so it's on her." He takes the phone, but his hands are shaking.

    Quote the words from the scenario that show (i) legitimate power, (ii) displaced responsibility (the agentic state) and (iii) moral strain. (1.1.1) (3)

    (i)
    (ii)
    (iii)
  2. Explain Dilan's obedience, using agency theory. (1.1.1) (3)

    Frame: Dilan is in the agentic state, because ________ (a detail). So he ________ (how this leads to obedience). He also shows moral strain, because ________ (a detail).

  3. Scenario: at a new school, Tharushi and Nadeesha both start to wear their house T-shirt on Fridays, like the older students. Tharushi admires the older students in her house and wants to be one of them; she wears the shirt only on school days, when she is with them. Nadeesha thinks the shirt looks silly, but she wears it so that the older students will not laugh at her.

    Explain the type of conformity that each girl shows. (1.1.4) (4)

    Frame: Tharushi shows ________, because ________. Nadeesha shows ________, because ________.

  4. Scenario: in a garment factory, a supervisor in the company uniform tells the workers on her line to skip their tea break to finish an urgent order. She says the managers will hear about anyone who refuses. The workers skip the break.

    A student's answer to "Explain why the workers obeyed, using social power theory (3)": "Social power theory says people obey because the person giving the order has power. There are six kinds of power, such as coercive, reward and legitimate. People obey people with more power."

    The student's answer earns 1 mark at most: it never mentions the factory. Rewrite it so that it earns all 3 marks. (1.1.1) (3)

Reveal the mark scheme: guided practice

3(a) Find it (3)

AO2 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate quotation from the scenario that shows the idea.

  • (i) legitimate power: "the principal of a large school" / "She's the principal" (1)
  • (ii) displaced responsibility (the agentic state): "It isn't my decision ... so it's on her" (1)
  • (iii) moral strain: "thinks the punishment is too harsh" / "his hands are shaking" (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

3(b) Agency theory (3)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for the accurate use of agency theory and up to two marks for application to Dilan.

  • He is in the agentic state: he sees himself as the principal's agent, not responsible for the decision (1)
  • Applied: he says it is not his decision, it is on her, so he obeys (1)
  • Applied: moral strain remains, as he thinks it is too harsh and his hands shake (1)

Max 1 if the answer never uses details about Dilan.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

3(c) Two girls (4): 2 for each girl

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for naming the type of conformity and one mark for application to the scenario, for each girl.

  • Tharushi: identification (1)
  • Applied: she admires the group and wants to belong, and wears the shirt only when she is with them (1)
  • Nadeesha: compliance (1)
  • Applied: she thinks it looks silly (private view unchanged) but wears it so that they will not laugh at her (NSI) (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

3(d) The factory (3)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate point that applies social power theory to the factory.

  • Legitimate power: she is the line supervisor, in the company uniform (1)
  • Coercive power: the threat that the managers will hear about anyone who refuses (1)
  • So the workers accept her right to give the order and fear punishment, and skip the break (1)

Credit reward power only with a detail from the scenario (there is none). No marks for listing the six bases.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Step 4: exam-style questions on your own (13 marks) 16 min

No frames now. For every point: name it, find it, link it.

  1. Scenario: Senuri joins an online study group for A level psychology. The other six members all say that flashcards are the best way to revise. Senuri has always reread her notes and has never tried flashcards, so she is not sure. She starts to use flashcards. A year later, after the group has stopped meeting, she still uses them and tells her brother they work better than rereading.

    Explain Senuri's behaviour, using one explanation of conformity and one type of conformity. (1.1.4) (4) (about 80 words)

  2. Scenario: a factory supervisor, Mr Silva, tells Amal and Rohan to stay two hours after their shift to finish an order. Amal grew up in a very strict family where children never questioned adults, and he believes that what happens to him at work is decided by the bosses. He stays, although he is exhausted. Rohan believes he is in charge of his own life. He says no and goes home.

    Explain why Amal obeyed but Rohan did not. Use individual differences in your answer. (1.1.3) (4) (about 80 words)

  3. Scenario: Mr Silva usually gives orders by text message from his office in another building.

    Using Milgram's telephonic instructions study (Experiment 7), explain why the workers would be more likely to obey if Mr Silva gave his orders in person. (1.1.2) (3) (about 60 words)

  4. Scenario: Hiran's friends all post a photo with the same filter for a charity challenge. Hiran thinks the challenge is pointless, but he posts a photo so that his friends will not think he is boring.

    Describe, using compliance, why Hiran posted the photo. (1.1.4) (2)

Reveal the mark scheme: questions 1 to 4

1 Senuri (4)

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each explanation or type of conformity identified and one mark for each application to Senuri.

  • Informational social influence (ISI) (1)
  • Applied: she is unsure and has never tried flashcards; six members seem to know better, so she copies them (1)
  • Internalisation (1)
  • Applied: she still uses them after the group stopped, and tells her brother, so her private view changed (1)

Accept NSI only if linked to a detail (there is little support for it). Max 2 if the answer has no details about Senuri.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

2 Amal and Rohan (4): at least one mark for each man

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (2 marks)

Credit one mark for each accurate individual difference identified and one mark for each application to Amal or Rohan.

  • Amal: an authoritarian personality, from his very strict upbringing, so he submits to authority (1)
  • Amal: an external locus of control: he believes the bosses decide what happens to him, so he obeys (1)
  • Rohan: an internal locus of control: he believes he is in charge of his own life (1)
  • So Rohan takes responsibility for his own choice and dissents; the same order, different personalities (1)

No marks for describing the personality types with no link to the two men.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

3 Mr Silva (3)

AO1 (2 marks), AO2 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for each accurate statement about Milgram's study and one mark for application to Mr Silva.

  • Proximity: an authority figure who is close by is obeyed more (1)
  • Experiment 7: with orders by phone, full obedience fell from 65% to 22.5%; some teachers secretly gave lower shocks (1)
  • Applied: in person, Mr Silva can see whether the workers stay, so they are less likely to leave early and say they stayed (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

4 Hiran (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO2 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for a description of compliance and one mark for application to Hiran.

  • Compliance: he goes along with his friends in public by posting the photo (1)
  • Applied: privately he still thinks it is pointless; he does it to be accepted, not to look boring (NSI) (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Self-marking checklist 5 min

Before you hand in, check that:

  • every point names the psychology and uses a detail from the scenario (a few quoted words are best);
  • each "explain" point has a "so" or "because" that links the detail to the behaviour;
  • in 3(c) and question 2, each person has their own explanation;
  • you used the theory the question names: agency theory in 3(b), social power theory in 3(d), Experiment 7 in question 3.

After you hand in, the mark schemes open. Then:

  • tick each mark point you earned; a point with no scenario detail does not count;
  • do the cover test on one answer: cover the names, and add details where it would still fit any story;
  • write your total out of 26, and one target, for example: "I will quote the scenario in every point."

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.