The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Introduction (Topic 0)

Directed study: check a headline yourself

Spec 9.1.13, 9.1.15Directed study: extendAfter the lessonAbout 40 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:

Your task (12 marks)

Spec: the six evaluation terms; 9.1.15 peer review. Time: about 40 minutes.

Why: afterwards you will be able to tell what a study found from what a headline claims.

What counts as a source: a news website, plus the original study or its abstract if you can find it. A video or a social media post on its own does not count.

  1. Find a news story from the last month that says "a study finds..." about young people. Record the source, the date and the exact claim in the headline. (1)

    Source
    Date
    Exact claim in the headline
  2. Identify two pieces of evidence, two questions and one overclaim, as you did with the social media report in the lesson. (5)

    Evidence 1
    Evidence 2
    Question 1
    Question 2
    Overclaim
  3. Find the original study or its abstract. State the sample size and whether it was an experiment or a correlation. (2)

    Sample size
    Experiment or correlation
  4. Evaluate in two sentences: does the headline match what the study found? (2)

  5. Explain why peer review increases the credibility of a study. (2)

Success checklist: the claim is copied exactly; every box has an answer; you have checked the original study, not just the news story.

Reveal the mark scheme

1. Your news story (1)

Credit one mark for the source, the date and the claim copied exactly from the headline.

  • Source, date and the exact claim, from a news story of the last month about a study of young people (1)

2. Evidence, questions, overclaim (5)

Credit one mark for each point that fits its box and comes from your news story, up to five marks.

  • Evidence 1: something that makes the conclusion more believable, for example a large sample, an objective measure or peer review (1)
  • Evidence 2: a second, different piece of evidence (1)
  • Question 1: something that makes you less sure, for example who was missing from the sample, a self-report measure, or no experiment, so something else could explain a link (1)
  • Question 2: a second, different question (1)
  • Overclaim: words stronger than the evidence, for example "proves", "causes" or "ruins" for a study that found a link (1)

3. The original study (2)

Credit one mark for each, taken from the original study or its abstract.

  • The sample size (1)
  • Experiment or correlation, rightly identified: an experiment changes one variable and measures the effect; a correlation measures two things as they are and looks for a link (1)

4. Does the headline match? (2)

Credit one mark for a judgement and one mark for justifying it with what the study found.

  • A judgement: the headline matches, partly matches or does not match the study (1)
  • A reason from the original study, for example the study found a link but the headline claims a cause, or the sample was smaller or narrower than the headline suggests (1)

5. To finish (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for an accurate statement about peer review and one mark for explaining why it increases credibility.

  • Other experts in the same field check the study's method, results and conclusions before it is published (1)
  • So weak methods, errors or conclusions that go beyond the data are more likely to be caught, and readers can trust the published findings more (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.