The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Introduction (Topic 0)

Directed study: exam technique

Exam technique: describe or explain? Answer the command word

Spec 5.4.3, 5.4.6, 5.4.7Directed study: exam techniqueExam techniqueAbout 48 minutes
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

How this page works

One exam skill, in four steps: learn the skill, see it done, practise it with help, then do it on your own.

Step 1: the skill 5 min

Three command words, three kinds of answer
Command wordWhat you doWords you will often use
State, give, name, identifyRecall one fact, or pick it out of the information you are given. No reason is needed.A word or a short phrase.
DescribeSay what something is, or what happens: its features or its steps. You do not say why."is", "involves", "for example", "first ... then"
ExplainSay why or how. Make a point, then back it up with a reason."because", "so", "this means that"

Read the marks as well as the word. The number in brackets is the mark tariff: about one creditable point for each mark.

  • (1) State or name: one fact.
  • (2) Describe: two features, or one feature and an example.
  • (2) Explain one ...: one point (1) and its reason (1).
  • (4) Explain two ...: two points, each with its own reason.

Describe and explain can be about the same topic. The difference is the reason: an explain answer always says why or how.

Key words: reading a question

Command word
The word at the start of a question that tells you what to do, for example describe or explain.
Mark tariff
The number of marks in brackets. It tells you how many creditable points to make.
Point
One idea that answers the question, for example a feature, a strength or a weakness.
Justification
The reason or evidence that backs up a point. In an explain answer it often starts with "because" or "so".

Common misconceptions and exam errors

These come up again and again in the reports on real exam answers. Each one costs marks.

  1. Writing everything you know about the topic. Only material that does what the command word asks earns marks. Extra facts take time and earn nothing.
  2. Describing when the question says explain. A description says what. An explanation also says why. If your answer has no "because" or "so", it is probably a description.
  3. Stopping after the first mark. In a 2-mark explain question, the point earns one mark and its reason earns the second.
  4. Giving three answers when the question asks for one. Only one is credited. Spend the time developing one point fully.
  5. Ignoring the marks in brackets. A (1) needs a word or a phrase; a (4) needs four creditable points. Match your answer to the tariff.

Step 2: worked example 6 min

Here is one topic, beta bias (lesson 4), asked in two different ways. Read each answer, then the reason for its mark.

Question A: Describe what is meant by beta bias. (2)

Answer 1 0 of 2 marks

Beta bias is a type of gender bias in psychology.

Why: It names the group that beta bias belongs to, but says nothing about what beta bias is.

Answer 2 2 of 2 marks

Beta bias means ignoring or playing down differences between men and women (1). For example, a researcher studies only men and assumes that the findings apply to women too (1).

Why: A clear feature, then an example that shows it. No reason is needed, because the command word is describe.

Question B: Explain one problem caused by beta bias in Milgram's (1963) study. (2)

Answer 3 1 of 2 marks

Milgram's sample was 40 men aged 20 to 50 from New Haven, who answered an advert (1). This is beta bias.

Why: An accurate point about the sample, but it never says what the problem is. There is no "so": it describes instead of explaining.

Answer 4 2 of 2 marks

Milgram's first study used only men (1), so he could not know whether women would obey at the same rate, and treating his 65% as true of everyone ignores possible differences between men and women (1).

Why: The point, then "so" and the problem it causes. (When Milgram later tested 40 women, 65% also went to 450 volts, but nobody could know that until women were tested.)

Spot the pattern: describe answers say what; explain answers add the "so" or the "because".

Step 3: guided practice (11 marks) 12 min

Use the frames: the words in italics tell you what each gap needs.

  1. For each question below, write the command word and what a full answer needs: how many points, and whether each point needs a reason. (4)

    1. Name the kind of twins who share all of their genes. (1)
    2. Describe the twin study method. (3)
    3. Explain one strength of a reductionist explanation of aggression. (2)
    4. Explain two ways a researcher could protect participants from harm. (4)
    (i)
    (ii)
    (iii)
    (iv)
  2. Each sentence below only describes. Finish it with "so ..." to explain the point in italics. (5.4.7, 5.4.3, 1.1.2) (3)

    1. Why this matters for nature and nurture: "In the Minnesota study, the twins had been separated as babies and brought up in different families, ..."
    2. Why this is a problem: "The headline 'Phones are wrecking teenage sleep' explains sleep with one feature of the environment, ..."
    3. Why this is a weakness: "Milgram's participants all chose to answer a newspaper advert, ..."
    (i) so
    (ii) so
    (iii) so
  3. Explain one way a researcher could make an observation of aggression more objective. (2.2.9) (2)

    Frame: The researcher could ________ (one way), so ________ (why this stops opinions changing what is recorded).

  4. Describe what is meant by ethnocentrism. (5.4.6) (2)

    Frame: Ethnocentrism means ________ (what it is). For example, ________ (an example).

Reveal the mark scheme: guided practice

3(a) Decode the question (4): one mark each; both the command word and what it needs

AO1 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for each correct decoding of the question.

  • (i) Name: one fact, a word or a short phrase; no reason (1)
  • (ii) Describe: three features or steps; no reason needed (1)
  • (iii) Explain: one point (a strength) and its reason (1)
  • (iv) Explain: two ways, each with its own reason (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

3(b) From describe to explain (3)

AO3 (3 marks)

Credit one mark for each reason that completes the sentence.

  • (i) so any similarity cannot come from a shared home, which points to genes (nature) (1)
  • (ii) so it leaves out other levels, such as the body clock or stress, and oversimplifies (reductionism) (1)
  • (iii) so they may differ from most men, and the 65% may not apply to everyone (1)

Credit any reason that answers the words in italics. A second description earns nothing.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

3(c) An objective observation (2)

AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for identifying one way and one mark for explaining it.

  • A way: operationalise aggression, for example count hits, kicks and pushes; or use two observers who record separately; or keep observers unaware of the groups (1)
  • So the record does not depend on one person's opinion: two observers would get the same result (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

3(d) Ethnocentrism (2)

AO1 (2 marks)

Credit up to two marks for an accurate description.

  • Judging other cultures by the values and standards of your own (ethnocentrism) (1)
  • An example, for example an intelligence test written for American recruits used to judge recruits from other cultures (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Step 4: exam-style questions on your own (17 marks) 20 min

No frames now. Before you write, underline the command word and the marks. The spec point in brackets tells you where to revise.

  1. State what is meant by monozygotic (MZ) twins. (5.4.7) (1)

  2. Describe how a twin study is used to investigate nature and nurture. (5.4.7) (3) (about 60 words)

  3. Explain one strength of studying twins who were brought up apart. (5.4.7) (2) (about 40 words)

  4. Scenario: a psychologist plans a study of how 14-year-olds react when a teacher gives an unfair order. The students will be told that the study is about classroom noise. Afterwards, they will be told the real aim.

    Identify the ethical guideline that the psychologist breaks by telling the students the study is about classroom noise. (1.2.9) (1)

  5. Describe what is meant by informed consent. (1.2.9) (2)

  6. Explain why the psychologist must ask a parent or guardian for consent. (1.2.9) (2)

  7. Explain one way the psychologist could reduce the risk of harm to the students. (1.2.9) (2)

  8. A news site reports: "Scientists find the risk-taking gene: teenagers who carry it are born to take risks."

    Explain two weaknesses of this explanation of risk-taking in teenagers. (5.4.3, 5.4.7) (4) (about 90 words)

Reveal the mark scheme: question 1

1(a) MZ twins (1)

AO1 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for an accurate statement.

  • Identical twins from one fertilised egg, who share all of their genes (1)

Reject all other answers.

1(b) The twin study method (3): max 3

AO1 (3 marks)

Credit up to three marks for an accurate description.

  • It compares pairs of MZ (identical) twins with pairs of DZ (non-identical) twins (1)
  • MZ twins share all their genes; DZ twins share about half (1)
  • Both kinds usually grow up in the same home, so their environments are alike (1)
  • If MZ pairs are more alike on a behaviour than DZ pairs, genes are likely to play a part (1)

Describe needs no evaluation: a weakness of twin studies earns nothing here.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

1(c) Twins brought up apart (2)

AO1 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for identifying a strength and one mark for justifying it.

  • Strength: they share all their genes but not their home or family (1)
  • So their similarity cannot come from a shared upbringing, which separates nature from nurture better (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Reveal the mark scheme: question 2

2(a) Guideline (1)

AO2 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for the correct guideline, in relation to the scenario.

  • Deception (misleading participants about the aim) (1)

Reject all other answers.

2(b) Informed consent (2)

AO1 (2 marks)

Credit up to two marks for an accurate description.

  • Participants are told what the study involves, including any risks (1)
  • They agree before they start (a parent or guardian agrees for under-16s) (1)

Look for other reasonable marking points.

2(c) Parental consent (2)

AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for a point about the participants and one mark for explaining why it matters.

  • The students are 14, which is under 16 (1)
  • So they may not fully understand the risks, and the BPS code says a parent or guardian must agree for them (1)

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

2(d) Reducing harm (2)

AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)

Credit one mark for identifying one way and one mark for explaining it in relation to the students.

  • A safeguard, for example: screen out students who are anxious; agree a point at which the study stops; debrief straight away; have a qualified person present (1)
  • How it reduces harm, linked to the students, for example: upset students are spotted early, so the unfair order does not cause lasting stress (1)

No marks for "follow the ethical guidelines" with no detail.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Reveal the mark scheme: question 3

3 Two weaknesses (4): 2 per weakness, a point (1) and its justification linked to the headline (1)

AO3 (4 marks)

Credit one mark for identifying each of two weaknesses and one mark for justifying each in relation to the headline.

  • Reductionist: it explains risk-taking at one level, the gene (1)
  • So it leaves out other levels, such as friends, family or culture, and oversimplifies (1)
  • Nature and nurture work together: a gene can make risk-taking more likely, not certain (1)
  • So "born to take risks" overclaims: the environment shapes whether the behaviour shows (1)
  • A link in a group of people does not say what any one teenager will do (1)
  • So the headline cannot tell us that every carrier takes risks (1)

Max 4. Two different weaknesses are needed; a second mark for each must link to the headline.

Generic answers score 0 marks.

Look for other reasonable marking points.

Self-marking checklist 5 min

Before you hand in, check that:

  • each answer does what its command word asks: a fact, a description, or a point with its reason;
  • every explain answer has a "because" or a "so" for each mark after the first;
  • the length of each answer matches its marks: about one creditable point per mark;
  • question 2 is about the 14-year-olds in the study, and question 3 is about the headline.

After you hand in, the mark schemes open. Then:

  • tick each mark point you earned: the idea must match, not just the words;
  • for each explain mark you missed, add the missing "so" or "because" in a different colour;
  • write your total out of 28, and one target, for example: "In explain questions, I give the reason before I move on."

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.