The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)

Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: extend

Is it really an experiment? Apps, start times and phones

Syllabus 7.1.1–7.1.7Homework: extendAbout 18 minutes15 marks
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This homework builds on this lesson, the first of the course. Teach them before students start here:

Task 1: does the app really work? (5 marks) 6 min

A meditation app called CalmMinute says: "Ten minutes a day with our app lowers stress." Two studies looked at this claim.

  • Study A. The company sends a questionnaire to 5000 people who have used the app for a year. They rate how stressed they feel, from 1 (not at all) to 10 (extremely). The average rating is 4.
  • Study B. A psychologist asks 40 students to use the app for 10 minutes every day for two weeks. Another 40 students do not use the app. All 80 students do their usual school day, and at the end of the two weeks they all rate their stress on the same 1 to 10 scale.

1(a). Identify which study is an experiment. Explain your answer, using the features of an experiment. (7.1.1, 7.1.2, Experimental methods: variables) (3)

1(b). Explain why Study A cannot show that the app lowers stress. (7.1.1, 7.1.2, Experimental methods: variables) (2)

Mark scheme: Task 1

1(a) (3)

  • 1 mark for identifying the study
    2 marks for features of an experiment, 1 mark for each
  • Study B is the experiment (1)
  • One variable is manipulated (changed) by the researcher: whether the students use the app or not (1)
  • Its effect on another variable is measured (the stress rating), under controlled conditions (the same 1 to 10 scale, the same two weeks, the same usual school day) (1)
  • Allow "the IV is using the app and the DV is stress" for the second mark; allow "everything else is kept the same" for the controlled-conditions part of the third mark.
  • Do not credit "Study B, because it has fewer people" or "Study A is a questionnaire, so it is not science": these are not features of an experiment. Naming Study B with no reason scores 1 mark only.

1(b) (2)

  • 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
  • Nothing is manipulated: the company does not change anything, it only asks users how stressed they feel / there is no comparison with people who did not use the app (explanation) (1)
  • So something else could explain the low stress ratings, for example people who keep an app for a year may have been less stressed anyway, or the questionnaire came in a calm month such as a holiday (link) (1)
  • Allow "there is no IV", "no control group" or "nothing to compare with" for the first mark.
  • Do not credit "the sample is too small" (5000 is large), or "questionnaires are biased" with no reason.

Task 2: a later school start (6 marks) 6 min

A news report says: "Teenagers concentrate better when school starts later." A school decides to test this with its Year 10 students. For one term, school starts at 8.00 a.m. The next term, it starts at 9.00 a.m.

2(a). "Concentrate better" is a vague phrase. Explain why the dependent variable must be operationalised before the school can test the claim. (7.1.6, Experimental methods: variables) (2)

2(b). Suggest how the school could operationalise the dependent variable. (7.1.6, 7.1.7, Experimental methods: variables) (2)

2(c). Write an operationalised independent variable for this study, with its two levels. (7.1.3, 7.1.6, 7.1.7, Experimental methods: variables) (2)

IV
Level 1
Level 2
Mark scheme: Task 2

2(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for explanation of what operationalising does
    1 mark for explanation of the problem without it
  • Operationalising defines the variable so that it can be accurately measured (or observed) (explanation) (1)
  • Without it, different teachers could measure "concentration" in different ways, so the results could not be compared or checked / the school would not know what to count (explanation) (1)
  • Allow the syllabus wording "defining a variable so it can be accurately measured or observed" for the first mark.
  • Do not credit "so it is fair" or "so it is easier" with no reason.

2(b) (2)

  • 1 mark for suggestion of a specific measure
    1 mark for detail
  • A specific measure of concentration, for example the number of correct answers on the same 20-question attention test, or the number of times a student looks away from the work in a 10-minute task (suggestion) (1)
  • A detail that makes it exact: when or how it is measured, or the score it is out of, for example "in the second lesson of the day", "out of 20", "counted by the teacher with a tally chart" (detail) (1)
  • Allow test marks or grades if a specific test is named, for example "score out of 50 in the end-of-term maths test".
  • Do not credit "how well they concentrate", "their concentration level" or "a concentration test" with nothing that says what is counted.

2(c) (2)

  • 1 mark for the IV
    1 mark for both levels as exact times
  • IV: the time school starts / start time in the morning (1)
  • Both levels given as exact times: 8.00 a.m. and 9.00 a.m. (1)
  • Allow "starting school at 8.00 a.m. or at 9.00 a.m." written as one sentence (2 marks).
  • Do not credit "a later start" or "early and late" with no times: not operationalised (1 mark at most, for the IV).

Task 3: phones on desks (4 marks) 6 min

A teacher reads that having your phone on your desk, even switched off, makes it harder to concentrate. She plans an experiment:

  • Class 1 works in Room 1 with their phones switched off and face down on the desk.
  • Class 2 works in Room 2 with their phones switched off in their bags at the back of the room.
  • Both classes do a 10-minute puzzle sheet. She counts the number of puzzles each student solves.

Room 1 is next to the sports hall, where a noisy lesson is going on. Room 2 is quiet.

3(a). Explain why the noise is a problem for her experiment. (7.1.1, 7.1.2, Experimental methods: variables) (2)

3(b). Suggest two other things the teacher must keep the same for both classes. (7.1.1, 7.1.2, Experimental methods: variables) (2)

1
2
Mark scheme: Task 3

3(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for the reason that noise is another variable
    1 mark for the effect on the results
  • Noise is another variable (not where the phone is) that could change the number of puzzles solved (explanation) (1)
  • So if Class 1 solves fewer puzzles, she cannot tell whether the phone or the noise caused it: the conditions are not controlled (link) (1)
  • Allow "extraneous variable" for the first mark (students meet the term in the next lesson but one).
  • Do not credit "noise is annoying" or "the students will not like it" with no link to the results.

3(b) (2)

  • 1 mark for each different thing kept the same (× 2)
  • One thing kept the same, for example the same puzzle sheet / puzzles of the same difficulty (1)
  • A second, different thing, for example the same 10-minute time limit, the same time of day, the same instructions read out, the same teacher or the same kind of room (1)
  • Do not credit "the phones" (that is the IV, the thing she changes), "the number of puzzles solved" (that is the DV), or "keep everything fair" with nothing named.

TOTAL = 15 MARKS

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.