The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: exam technique
Exam technique: planning an experiment
Teach these first
This homework practises one exam skill, using everything from the first three lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- Experimental methods: variables (lesson 1, syllabus 7.1.1–7.1.7)
- Experimental methods: design (lesson 2, syllabus 7.1.8–7.1.18)
- Experimental methods: extraneous variables and control (lesson 3, syllabus 7.1.19–7.1.21)
The skill: planning an experiment 2 min
Section D of Paper 1 always has one question, worth 4 to 6 marks, that asks you to plan an experiment. The question gives you part of the plan, such as the aim and the design. It then tells you which parts to write about, for example:
| Heading | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Organising experimental conditions | What happens in each condition, and who does which: counterbalancing (repeated measures) or random allocation (independent measures). | Half the participants do the noisy condition first. |
| Controls | One thing kept the same for everyone, and how. | Everyone is tested in the same room at 10 a.m. |
| Choosing materials | What participants see or do, and how the DV is measured. | A list of 20 one-syllable words; count the words recalled. |
Each mark is for one clear, practical step that fits this study. Write in short numbered steps, and write one more step than the number of marks.
Worked example: reading on paper or on a screen 4 min
The question: Jo is planning a repeated measures experiment to test whether students read faster from paper or from a screen. Outline a plan of how Jo will conduct her experiment. In your answer, only refer to: organising experimental conditions; controls; choosing materials. (5)
A full-mark answer, sentence by sentence:
- Every student reads one passage on paper and a different passage on a tablet screen. (1) Organising conditions: what each condition is, and the same students do both.
- Half the students read on paper first; the other half read on the screen first. (1) Organising conditions: counterbalancing deals with the order.
- The two passages are each 300 words long and come from the same book, so they are equally difficult. (1) Materials, and a control on difficulty.
- Both passages use the same font and the same size of text. (1) Control: names what is kept the same.
- Jo times each student with a stopwatch, in seconds, from "Start" until they read the last word. (1) Materials: how the DV is measured.
- Every student reads in the same quiet room, and Jo reads the same instructions from a script. (1) Control: where, and how.
Six creditable steps for 5 marks: one step to spare in case one is not credited.
An answer that scores only 1 mark
"Jo should get some students and test them on paper and on a screen and see which is faster. She must keep everything fair. She should use a big sample and get consent."
- "Test them on paper and on a screen": just about states the two conditions (1).
- "See which is faster" repeats the question: no mark.
- "Keep everything fair" names no control: no mark.
- "A big sample" and "consent" are not under the headings the question asked for: no mark, however true.
Task 1: make it specific (3 marks) 3 min
A student plans a repeated measures experiment to test whether people remember more words when the words are shown as pictures or as written words. Three of their steps are too vague to score.
1. Rewrite each step so it is specific enough to earn a mark: (i) "Use some words." (ii) "Make sure it is fair." (iii) "Test their memory." (7.1.20, 7.1.21, with 7.1.6, Experimental methods: extraneous variables and control) (3)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1 (3)
- 1 mark for each step made specific (× 3)
- (i) Says exactly which words, for example two lists of 15 everyday nouns, all one syllable (one list shown as pictures, one as written words) (1)
- (ii) Names one control and how, for example every list is shown for the same time (2 seconds per item), or everyone is tested in the same quiet room, or the same instructions are read from a script (1)
- (iii) Says how memory is measured, for example after each list participants have 1 minute to write down as many words as they can, and the researcher counts how many are correct (out of 15) (1)
- Allow counterbalancing (half see the pictures first) for (ii), as it controls the order.
- Do not credit (i) "some easy words"; (ii) "keep everything the same"; (iii) "a memory test" or "see how many they remember" with no time or score.
Task 2: guided practice, a walk before a test (5 marks) 5 min
2. Kofi is planning an independent measures experiment to test whether a 10-minute walk outside before a test improves students' test scores. Outline a plan of how Kofi will conduct his experiment. In your answer, only refer to: organising experimental conditions; controls; choosing materials. (7.1.9–7.1.21, Experimental methods: extraneous variables and control) (5)
Planning frame (use these starters)
- Conditions: "In the experimental condition, students ... In the other condition, students ..."
- Allocation: "Kofi puts students into the two conditions by ..."
- Controls: "Kofi keeps ... the same by ..." (write two)
- Materials: "The test is ... It is marked by ..."
Mark scheme: Task 2
2 (5)
- 1 mark for each appropriate step (× 5)
Max 5 - Experimental condition: students walk outside for 10 minutes just before the test (organising conditions) (1)
- The other (control) condition: students spend the same 10 minutes sitting quietly in the classroom / no walk (organising conditions) (1)
- Students are randomly allocated to the two conditions, for example names drawn from a hat (organising conditions) (1)
- Both groups take the same test, for example 20 multiple-choice maths questions (materials) (1)
- Both groups have the same time limit (for example 15 minutes) and take the test in the same room at the same time of day (control) (1)
- The same instructions are read to both groups from a script (control) (1)
- Every test is marked with the same mark scheme / multiple choice makes the marking objective (materials) (1)
- Each control must name what is kept the same.
- Allow a control on the walk itself, for example the same route at the same pace for everyone in the walk condition.
- Do not credit "a walk" with no comparison condition; "keep it fair"; points on sampling, consent or results (not asked for); "see if the walk improves scores" (repeats the question).
Task 3: on your own, typing on a laptop or a phone (6 marks) 6 min
No frame this time. Use the steps you practised. Aim for seven steps.
3. Mia wants to find out whether people make fewer typing mistakes on a laptop keyboard or on a phone screen. She will use a repeated measures design. Outline a plan of how Mia will conduct her experiment. In your answer, only refer to: organising experimental conditions; controls; choosing materials. (7.1.9–7.1.21, Experimental methods: extraneous variables and control) (6)
Self-check: before you hand in
- ☐ I wrote about every heading in the question, and nothing else.
- ☐ Each step is one clear action that another person could follow.
- ☐ I said what happens in each condition, and who does which (counterbalancing for repeated measures).
- ☐ Every control names the thing kept the same, and how.
- ☐ I said exactly what is measured, and how it is scored.
- ☐ I wrote at least one more step than the number of marks.
Mark scheme: Task 3
3 (6)
- 1 mark for each appropriate step (× 6)
Max 6 - Every participant types in both conditions: once on the laptop and once on the phone (organising conditions) (1)
- Counterbalancing: half the participants use the laptop first, the other half the phone first (organising conditions) (1)
- Two different passages of the same length and difficulty (for example two 50-word passages from the same book), one for each condition (materials) (1)
- The same laptop and the same phone for every participant (control) (1)
- Autocorrect (predictive text) is switched off on both devices (control) (1)
- The same time limit in both conditions (for example 2 minutes), or everyone types the whole passage (control) (1)
- Everyone sits at the same desk in the same quiet room, and hears the same instructions read from a script (control) (1)
- The DV: the researcher compares the typed text with the passage and counts the number of words with a mistake (materials) (1)
- Allow "the same passage in both conditions" only if the answer adds a reason it is not a problem (for example a long gap between conditions); otherwise it is a practice effect and scores no mark.
- Do not credit "test people on a laptop and on a phone to see which has fewer mistakes" (repeats the question); "keep everything fair"; "choose people who type a lot" or "get consent" (not under the headings).
Common misconceptions and exam errors
- Writing about parts the question did not ask for. When the question says "only refer to", steps on sampling, ethics or results score nothing, however good.
- "Keep everything the same" or "make it fair". Name the variable and how it is kept the same: "everyone is tested at 10 a.m. in the same room".
- Repeating the question. "She will test whether people type better on a laptop or a phone" is already in the question. The specimen mark scheme gives no marks for words copied from the question.
- Missing the design details. Repeated measures needs counterbalancing and two equally hard versions of the task. Independent measures needs random allocation and a comparison condition.
- A vague DV. "Test their typing" scores nothing. Say what is counted: "the number of words typed with a mistake".
TOTAL = 14 MARKS