The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)

Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: extend

Watching people: a zoo sign and a toddler game

Syllabus 7.2Homework: extendAbout 17 minutes15 marks
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Task 1: does the sign work? (10 marks) 11 min

The reptile house at a zoo puts up a new sign: "Please don't tap the glass. It frightens the animals." The staff want to know whether the sign works.

On a Saturday before the sign goes up, two staff members watch visitors at the snake tank for one hour and record what they do. They do the same on a Saturday after the sign goes up. Both times they wear their own clothes and stand among the visitors, so the visitors do not know they are being watched.

1(a). The staff use a structured observation. Write two operationalised behavioural categories they could record. (7.2.3, 7.2.6, 7.2.7, Non-experimental methods: observation) (2)

1
2

1(b). Describe the tally chart the staff could use: give its column headings and say how it is filled in. (7.2.3, 7.2.5, Non-experimental methods: observation) (2)

1(c). Identify whether this is a covert or an overt observation. Explain why the staff chose to observe in this way. (7.2.8, 7.2.10, Non-experimental methods: observation) (2)

1(d). Identify one extraneous variable that could make the two Saturdays different. Suggest how the staff could control it. (7.1.19–7.1.21, Experimental methods: extraneous variables and control) (2)

1(e). The manager now wants to film the visitors with a hidden camera instead. Explain one ethical problem with this covert observation. (7.2.8, 7.2.10, Non-experimental methods: observation) (2)

Mark scheme: Task 1

1(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for each operationalised behavioural category (× 2)
  • A first category that is a specific, visible action, for example "taps the glass with a finger or knuckle" (1)
  • A second, different specific action, for example "hits the glass with a flat hand", "points at the snake without touching the glass", or "stops to read the sign" (1)
  • Allow categories about the sign as well as the glass, if each one is an action that can be seen and counted.
  • Do not credit "being rude", "annoying the snake", "not respecting animals" or "aggressive": these are not operationalised (two observers could disagree about them).

1(b) (2)

  • 1 mark for headings
    1 mark for how it is filled in
  • Headings: one row or column for each behavioural category, and a column for the tally (and the total) (description) (1)
  • Filled in by making one mark (a tally) in the right row each time a visitor does that behaviour, then adding up the marks at the end of the hour (description) (1)
  • Allow extra columns for time periods (for example every 15 minutes), or for "before the sign" and "after the sign".
  • Do not credit "a table of the results" with no headings, or a checklist that is only ticked once (it would not count how often).

1(c) (2)

  • 1 mark for identification
    1 mark for explanation
  • Covert: the visitors do not know they are being watched / the staff are in their own clothes among the visitors (identification) (1)
  • If visitors knew they were being watched, they might not tap the glass (or would behave better than usual), so the staff would not see their normal behaviour / lower validity (explanation) (1)
  • Do not credit "covert because it is in a zoo", or "so they can watch more people" with no idea of visitors changing their behaviour.

1(d) (2)

  • 1 mark for identification of an extraneous variable
    1 mark for a matching control
  • An extraneous variable, for example the number of visitors, the weather (a rainy day sends more people indoors), school holidays, or how active the snake is (1)
  • A matching control, for example observe at the same time of day (11 a.m. to 12 noon) on both days, choose two Saturdays in term time with similar weather, or record the number of tappers out of all the visitors who pass (1)
  • Allow any sensible extraneous variable linked to the zoo, with a control that deals with that same variable.
  • Do not credit a control that does not match the variable (for example "the weather" with "use the same staff"), or "the sign" (that is what is being tested).

1(e) (2)

  • 1 mark for the ethical problem
    1 mark for explanation
  • The visitors cannot give informed consent, because they do not know they are being studied / filmed (ethical problem) (1)
  • Filming records their faces, so people could be recognised: the film must be kept private, or faces blurred, and visitors could be told afterwards (explanation) (1)
  • Allow "they cannot choose not to take part" for the first mark.
  • Do not credit "it is illegal" or "it is wrong to spy" with no reason linked to the visitors.

Task 2: toddlers and a new tablet game (5 marks) 6 min

A company is making a tablet game for 2-year-olds. The designers watch six toddlers playing it for the first time. They write down everything the children do, with no list of behaviours chosen in advance.

2(a). Identify the type of observation the designers are using. Explain why it suits them at this early stage. (7.2.4, 7.2.5, Non-experimental methods: observation) (3)

2(b). Next month the designers want to run a structured observation of the finished game. Suggest how they could change their method. (7.2.3, 7.2.5, 7.2.6, Non-experimental methods: observation) (2)

Mark scheme: Task 2

2(a) (3)

  • 1 mark for identification
    1 mark for each relevant point of explanation (× 2)
  • Unstructured observation (identification) (1)
  • The designers do not yet know which behaviours will happen, so they record the complete range of what the toddlers do (explanation) (1)
  • So they can spot problems they did not expect, for example toddlers tapping the wrong part of the screen or getting upset (explanation) (1)
  • Allow "they want to see everything the children do with the game" for the second mark.
  • Do not credit "structured", or "unstructured because it is not organised": the observers still record carefully, they just have no list chosen in advance.

2(b) (2)

  • 1 mark for suggestion
    1 mark for detail
  • Choose a fixed set of behaviours in advance (behavioural categories), for example from what they saw in the first observation (suggestion) (1)
  • Operationalise them and record them on a tally chart or checklist, for example "taps the start button", "looks away from the screen", "pushes the tablet away" (detail) (1)
  • Do not credit "watch more children" or "watch for longer": these do not make it structured.

TOTAL = 15 MARKS

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.