The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)

Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: exam technique

Exam technique: strengths and weaknesses in context

Syllabus 7.4Homework: exam techniqueAbout 20 minutes12 marks
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This homework practises one exam skill, using these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Key words: the three things a strength or weakness must be about

Validity
The extent to which the researcher is investigating what they aimed to investigate. In plain words: are the data a true picture?
Reliability
Consistency of the procedure or measures used to collect data. In plain words: would the study give the same results again?
Ethics
Protecting the rights and wellbeing of the participants, for example their consent, privacy and safety.

The skill: a strength or weakness in three steps 2 min

In the exam, "Explain one strength and one weakness of ..." is how a research method is judged. The syllabus only gives marks for strengths and weaknesses about validity, reliability or ethics. Each one needs three steps:

The three steps
StepWhat you write
1. The pointWhat it is about the method, for example "it uses several sources of data".
2. Why it mattersLink it to validity, reliability or ethics.
3. In this studyUse the people, data or setting named in the question.

A point that could be about any study (generic) can score, but at least one point must be linked to the scenario for full marks. When a question says justify, choose one side and support it with a reason from the scenario.

Worked example: Asha's memory 5 min

The question: Dr Perera is carrying out a case study of Asha, a 12-year-old girl who can remember what happened on almost every day of her life. She gives Asha memory tests, interviews her parents and reads Asha's old diaries. Explain one strength and one weakness of using a case study to investigate Asha's memory. (4)

A full-mark answer, sentence by sentence:

  1. Strength: Dr Perera uses triangulation, comparing memory tests, interviews with Asha's parents and Asha's diaries. (1) The point, linked to this study.
  2. If what Asha remembers matches her diaries and what her parents say, Dr Perera can be more sure she is measuring Asha's real memory, so the findings are more valid. (1) Why it matters: validity.
  3. Weakness: Asha's memory is so rare that the study cannot be repeated with other people like her. (1) The point, linked to this study.
  4. So no one can check whether the same results would be found again, which means the reliability of the findings cannot be tested. (1) Why it matters: reliability.
  5. Case studies are also very slow and cost a lot of money. (no mark)

The last sentence earns nothing: time and money are not validity, reliability or ethics. A judgement question can follow: "Suggest whether a case study or an experiment with 50 students is better for this aim. Justify your answer. (2)" A full-mark answer: "A case study, because only one girl is known to have this memory (1), so there are not 50 students like her to test, and Dr Perera wants to understand Asha's memory in depth (1)."

Task 1: from generic to linked (3 marks) 3 min

A psychologist studies how one village recovered after a flood. For a year she interviews 12 families, watches village meetings and looks at school attendance records. A student wrote three generic points about this case study.

1. Rewrite each point so it is linked to the flood study and says why it matters (validity, reliability or ethics): (i) "Case studies give lots of detail." (ii) "Case studies cannot be repeated." (iii) "Participants might get upset." (7.4.1, 7.4.2, Case studies) (3)

(i)
(ii)
(iii)
Mark scheme: Task 1

1 (3)

  • 1 mark for each rewrite linked to the flood study with a reason (× 3)
  • (i) Linked and with a reason, for example: a year of interviews, meetings and attendance records gives a detailed, true picture of how this village recovered, so the findings are more valid (1)
  • (ii) Linked and with a reason, for example: this flood and this village will never happen in the same way again, so another psychologist cannot repeat the study to check the results (reliability) (1)
  • (iii) Linked and with a reason, for example: families may become upset talking about losing their homes in the flood, so the psychologist must protect them from harm and let them stop at any time (ethics) (1)
  • Do not credit a rewrite that still names nothing from the scenario (no flood, village, families, meetings or records), or one with no link to validity, reliability or ethics.

Task 2: guided practice, an esports player (4 marks) 4 min

A sports psychologist studies Leo, a 16-year-old esports player with very fast reactions. For six months she gives him reaction-time tests, interviews his coach and his parents, and watches him train.

2. Explain one strength and one weakness of using a case study to investigate Leo's reactions. (7.4.1, 7.4.2, Case studies) (4)

Answer frame

  • Strength: "The psychologist uses ... in Leo's case. This makes the findings more (valid / reliable / ethical) because ..."
  • Weakness: "Because Leo ..., ... This is a problem for (validity / reliability / ethics) because ..."
Strength
Why it matters
Weakness
Why it matters
Mark scheme: Task 2

2 (4)

  • 1 mark for strength linked to Leo
    1 mark for why it matters
    1 mark for weakness linked to Leo
    1 mark for why it matters
  • Strength, linked: for example she uses triangulation, comparing Leo's test results with what his coach and parents say and what she sees in training (1)
  • Why it matters: if the sources agree she can be more confident the findings are a true picture of Leo (validity); or six months of data gives an in-depth picture (1)
  • Weakness, linked: for example Leo is one unusual player, so the study cannot be repeated with other players like him; or Leo knows he is being watched in training (1)
  • Why it matters: no one can check whether the results would be the same again (reliability); or he may play differently when watched, so the data are not his normal behaviour (validity) (1)
  • Full marks need at least one point linked to Leo. Two strengths or two weaknesses: Max 2.
  • Allow an ethical weakness linked to Leo, for example his test results and interviews must be kept confidential, or he must be free to stop at any time, with a reason.
  • Do not credit "it takes a long time", "it is expensive" (not validity, reliability or ethics); "it gives detail" and "it does not give a wide view" as the strength and the weakness (one is the other turned round).

Task 3: on your own, a boy who will not go to school (5 marks) 6 min

A psychologist wants to understand why one 14-year-old boy refuses to go to school. She plans a case study: interviews with the boy and his teachers, a questionnaire for his parents, and observations at home.

3(a). Explain one weakness of this case study in terms of ethics. (7.4.2, Case studies) (2)

3(b). A colleague suggests sending a questionnaire to 500 students who often miss school instead. Suggest whether the case study or the questionnaire is better for understanding this boy's reasons. Justify your answer. (7.4.2, with 7.3, Case studies) (3)

Self-check: before you hand in

  • ☐ Every strength or weakness is about validity, reliability or ethics, and says which.
  • ☐ At least one point uses the people, data or setting from the question.
  • ☐ I gave one strength AND one weakness when both were asked for.
  • ☐ My weakness is not just my strength turned round.
  • ☐ In the "justify" answer I chose one side and gave a reason from the scenario.
Mark scheme: Task 3

3(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for an ethical issue linked to the boy
    1 mark for why it matters or what to do
  • An ethical issue linked to the boy: for example he may become upset or anxious talking about why he avoids school (harm), or the observations at home intrude on the family's private life (privacy), or he is under 16 (1)
  • Why it matters or what to do: for example he must be able to stop at any time; his name and family details must be kept confidential; his parents (and the boy) must agree before it starts (1)
  • Allow "watching him at home without his agreement" for the first mark.
  • Do not credit "it takes a long time" or "it is only one boy" (these are not about ethics).

3(b) (3)

  • 1 mark for choice
    1 mark for reason linked to the boy
    1 mark for a second reason or comparison
  • Choice: the case study (or the questionnaire, if justified) (1)
  • Reason linked to the boy: for example the aim is to understand this one boy, and interviews, observation and his parents' views give an in-depth picture of his own reasons (1)
  • A second reason or a comparison: for example a questionnaire to 500 other students would show common reasons for missing school, not this boy's; or triangulation lets her check his reasons against his teachers' and parents' views (validity) (1)
  • Allow the questionnaire, if justified for a different aim, for example "it is anonymous, so students may be more honest about why they miss school, but it would not explain this boy" (Max 2, as the aim is this boy).
  • Do not credit a choice with no reason; "the case study, because it is better" or "because it is more detailed" with nothing from the scenario (Max 1, for the choice).

Common misconceptions and exam errors

  1. A generic point with no link. "Case studies give lots of detail" could be about any study. The specimen mark schemes need at least one point linked to the scenario for full marks.
  2. A strength or weakness that is not about validity, reliability or ethics. "It takes a long time" and "it is expensive" earn no marks in 0266.
  3. The same point twice. "It gives detail" and "it does not give a wide view" are one idea turned round, so the second one earns nothing extra.
  4. Only one side. When the question asks for a strength and a weakness, two weaknesses cannot get full marks.
  5. "Justify" with no reason. Choose one side, then support it with evidence from the scenario.
  6. Words you do not need. "Generalisation" and named types of validity are not 0266 terms: explain the idea in plain words instead.

TOTAL = 12 MARKS

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.