The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: extend
Who did they ask? Polls, queues and rare twins
Teach these first
This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- Case studies (lesson 6, syllabus 7.4)
- Sampling (lesson 7, syllabus 7.5)
Task 1: "85% of athletes agree" (6 marks) 7 min
A sports drink company, FuelUp, posts a poll on its own social media page: "Do you train better after drinking FuelUp? Vote now!" 2000 of its followers vote, and 85% vote "Yes". The company then prints on its bottles: "85% of athletes train better with FuelUp."
1(a). Identify the sampling technique used in the poll. (7.5.3, 7.5.4, Sampling) (1)
1(b). Identify the population the company's claim is about, and the sample it actually used. (7.5.1, 7.5.2, 7.5.4, Sampling) (2)
1(c). Explain why the sample may not represent the population. (7.5.4, Sampling) (3)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1(a) (1)
- 1 mark for the sampling technique
- Volunteer sample (sampling) (1)
- Allow "self-selected sample".
- Do not credit "opportunity sample" (the followers chose to answer an invitation), or "random sample".
1(b) (2)
- 1 mark for the population
1 mark for the sample - Population: all athletes / everyone who trains (1)
- Sample: the 2000 followers who voted in the poll (1)
- Do not credit "FuelUp drinkers" for the population (the claim is about athletes); "85%" for the sample.
1(c) (3)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 3)
- The voters follow FuelUp's own page, so they are likely to already like or buy the drink (1)
- People who choose to vote may be the keenest fans (volunteer bias): people with no strong feelings do not bother (1)
- Athletes who do not use social media, or do not follow the page, are missing, so the 85% probably makes the drink look better than it is for all athletes (1)
- Allow "the people who answered are all the same type of person" for one mark if it is linked to the poll.
- Do not credit "the sample is too small" (2000 is large; the problem is who they are), or "it is biased" with no reason.
Task 2: the new canteen menu (4 marks) 5 min
The school council wants to know what all 900 students think of the new canteen menu. On Monday, one council member asks the first 30 students in the lunch queue.
2(a). Explain why these 30 students may not represent all 900 students. (7.5.4, Sampling) (2)
2(b). Suggest two changes to how the council member chooses students, still using an opportunity sample, so the sample better represents the whole school. (7.5.3, 7.5.4, Sampling) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 2
2(a) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- Students at the front of the queue may be of one type, for example the youngest year groups (who eat first), or students who like the canteen food most (1)
- Students who bring a packed lunch, or who eat later, are missing, so their views on the menu are not heard (it may be a busy Monday menu only) (1)
- Allow "they may be friends of the council member" or "one day is not typical" with a reason linked to the menu.
- Do not credit "30 is too small" on its own, or "they were not chosen randomly".
2(b) (2)
- 1 mark for each different change (× 2)
- A change, for example ask students at different points in the queue, on different days of the week, or at different lunch sittings (1)
- A second, different change, for example also ask students in other places (the library, the playing field, the packed-lunch area), or ask some students from every year group who are there (1)
- Do not credit "use a volunteer sample" or "use a random sample" (the question says opportunity), or "ask more people" with no idea of who.
Task 3: finding twins for a case study (5 marks) 6 min
A psychologist wants to study identical twins who were separated as babies and grew up in different countries. She puts an advert on a twins' charity website asking such twins to contact her. One pair, Mina and Sara, aged 30, reply.
3(a). Identify the sampling technique the psychologist used. (7.5.3, 7.5.4, Sampling) (1)
3(b). Explain why a case study is a good method for this research. (7.4.1, 7.4.2, Case studies) (2)
3(c). Describe how the psychologist could use triangulation in her case study of Mina and Sara. (7.4.1, 7.4.2, Case studies) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 3
3(a) (1)
- 1 mark for the sampling technique
- Volunteer sample (sampling) (1)
- Do not credit "opportunity sample": the twins chose to reply to an invitation (the advert).
3(b) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- Twins like this are very rare (only one pair replied), so a large sample for an experiment is not possible (1)
- A case study gives an in-depth picture of Mina and Sara over time, using several methods, which suits a rare, real-life situation that could never be set up on purpose (1)
- Allow "it would be unethical to separate twins on purpose" for the second mark.
- Do not credit "case studies are easy" or "it is cheaper".
3(c) (2)
- 1 mark for description of the methods
1 mark for comparing the results - Collect data about the twins with more than one method, for example interviews with each twin, a personality questionnaire, and talking to their families (description) (1)
- Then compare the results from the different methods to see whether they agree (if they agree, she can be more confident in the findings) (description) (1)
- Allow named methods in the twins' context for the first mark (at least two different methods).
- Do not credit "use three methods" with no methods named and no comparison; "test three pairs of twins" (that is a bigger sample, not triangulation).
TOTAL = 15 MARKS