The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)

Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: exam technique

Exam technique: ethics in a new scenario

Syllabus 7.7Homework: exam techniqueAbout 20 minutes13 marks
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This homework practises one exam skill, using this lesson. Teach them before students start here:

The skill: ethics in a new scenario 2 min

Ethics questions describe a study you have never seen (a novel scenario) and ask what is wrong with it or how to make it ethical. A list of guidelines scores very little. Use three moves:

Name it, point to it, fix it
MoveWhat you writeExample
1. Name itThe ethical guideline.Confidentiality.
2. Point to itWhat happened in this study that breaks it.Their names were printed in the school newsletter.
3. Fix itWhat the researcher should do instead, in this study.Use numbers instead of names.

"Explain how the study breaks a guideline" usually gives one mark for the guideline and one for the evidence from the study. "Suggest ... include a reason" gives one mark for the suggestion and one for the reason.

Worked example: a voice coach that shouts 4 min

The question: A fitness app tests whether users run further with a shouting "drill sergeant" voice coach or a calm voice coach. Each of 2000 users is given one of the voices without being told about the study. Afterwards, the app sends each user's running data and home town to a sports company. Explain two ways this study breaks ethical guidelines. (4)

A full-mark answer, sentence by sentence:

  1. The study breaks the guideline on consent. (1) Name it.
  2. The users were never told they were in a study, so they could not agree to take part. (1) Point to it: evidence from this study.
  3. It also breaks confidentiality. (1) Name it.
  4. Each user's running data and home town were sent to a sports company, so users could be identified. (1) Point to it.
  5. It is also unethical because of privacy and harm. (no mark)

The last sentence names two more guidelines but points to nothing in the study, so it earns no mark. If the question had asked how to make the study ethical, each answer would need move 3: "ask users to agree before they get a voice coach", "send only anonymous data, with no home towns".

Task 1: name it (3 marks) 3 min

Each study breaks one ethical guideline. Name it.

1. (i) Participants are told a study is about how fast they read, when it is really about how they react when someone laughs at them. (ii) Without any warning, participants are shown a real video of a serious car crash. (iii) After a study that tricked them, participants leave without being told what the study was really about. (7.7.1, Ethical guidelines) (3)

(i)
(ii)
(iii)
Mark scheme: Task 1

1 (3)

  • 1 mark for each guideline identified (× 3)
  • (i) Avoiding deception (participants were given wrong information about the aim) (1)
  • (ii) Minimising harm (the video could cause distress: psychological harm) (1)
  • (iii) Debriefing (they were not given full information after the data were collected) (1)
  • allow (i) informed consent (they could not give informed consent to the real study); (ii) protection from harm
  • do not credit (iii) deception (the deception happened during the study; what is missing at the end is the debriefing); privacy for any of the three

Task 2: guided practice, the hidden canteen camera (4 marks) 5 min

To find out how many students choose the healthy meal, researchers hide a camera in a school canteen for a week. No one is told. Later, to encourage healthy eating, the head teacher shows clips of students choosing chips, with their faces clearly visible, at a whole-school assembly.

2. Explain two ways this study breaks ethical guidelines. (7.7.1, 7.7.2, Ethical guidelines) (4)

Answer frame

  • Way 1. Name it: "The study breaks ..." Point to it: "because in this study ..."
  • Way 2. Name it: "It also breaks ..." Point to it: "because ..."
Way 1: name it
Way 1: point to it
Way 2: name it
Way 2: point to it
Mark scheme: Task 2

2 (4)

  • 1 mark for each guideline (× 2)
  • 1 mark for each link to the canteen study (× 2)
  • Guideline 1, for example consent (guideline) (1)
  • The camera was hidden and no one was told, so students could not agree to being filmed (link) (1)
  • Guideline 2, for example confidentiality (guideline) (1)
  • Faces were shown at an assembly, so students could be identified; or students may feel embarrassed in front of the whole school (psychological harm) (link) (1)
  • allow privacy or minimising harm as guideline 2
  • allow right to withdraw: they did not know about the study, so they could not leave it, as one of the two guidelines
  • Two different guidelines, each with its own link. A guideline with no link to the canteen scores 1 mark at most for that guideline.
  • do not credit "it is illegal" or "it is mean"

Task 3: on your own, a sleep questionnaire (6 marks) 6 min

Dr Silva is designing a questionnaire for 15-year-olds about how much sleep they get on school nights. Some questions ask how late they use their phones in bed.

3(a). Suggest one piece of information Dr Silva should tell the students before the study, so that the questionnaire is ethical. Include a reason for your answer. (7.7.1, 7.7.2, Ethical guidelines) (2)

3(b). Some students may be worried about admitting that they use their phones late at night. Explain how Dr Silva could make the study more ethical for these students. (7.7.2, Ethical guidelines) (2)

3(c). Dr Silva thinks students will answer more honestly if she tells them the study is about "school life" rather than sleep. Explain whether this is acceptable, and what she must do at the end of the study. (7.7.1, 7.7.2, Ethical guidelines) (2)

Self-check: before you hand in

  • ☐ Every guideline I named is pointed to with something that happens in this study.
  • ☐ Every fix is for this study, not a general rule.
  • ☐ Where the question asked for a reason, I gave one ("so that ...", "because ...").
  • ☐ I used the syllabus names: consent, debriefing, confidentiality, avoiding deception, right to withdraw, privacy, minimising harm.
Mark scheme: Task 3

3(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for suggestion
  • 1 mark for reason
  • A piece of information, for example: that it is a questionnaire about their sleep and phone use on school nights; that they can stop at any time and skip questions; that their answers will be anonymous (suggestion) (1)
  • A matching reason or guideline, for example: so that they can give informed consent; so that they know they have the right to withdraw; so their privacy and confidentiality are protected (reason) (1)
  • allow "that their parents have agreed" with the reason "students under 16 need consent from a parent"
  • do not credit "tell them the results" (that comes after the study); "tell them it is ethical" with no information named

3(b) (2)

  • 1 mark for suggestion
  • 1 mark for link to these students
  • Make the questionnaire anonymous (no names), keep the answers confidential, or tell students they can leave out any question (suggestion) (1)
  • Then no teacher or parent can find out who uses their phone late, so students are protected and feel safe to answer (link) (1)
  • do not credit "tell them not to worry" or "make the questions shorter" with no ethical reason

3(c) (2)

  • 1 mark for evaluation of the deception
  • 1 mark for what she must do at the end
  • Telling them it is about "school life" is (mild) deception: it is only acceptable if it is really needed for honest answers and causes no harm, and it should be kept to a minimum (explanation) (1)
  • At the end she must debrief the students: tell them the real aim (sleep and phone use) and answer their questions (description) (1)
  • allow "it is not acceptable, because deception should be avoided; she could keep it vague and still debrief them" (2 marks if debriefing is included)
  • do not credit "yes, it is fine" or "no, it is wrong" with no reason; "she should tell them the results"

Common misconceptions and exam errors

  1. Naming a guideline without pointing to the study. "It breaks consent and privacy" scores little. Say what happened in this study that breaks it.
  2. A fix that is not for this study. "Follow the ethical guidelines" earns nothing. Say what this researcher should do: "ask the parents of the 15-year-olds to agree".
  3. Mixing up privacy and confidentiality. Privacy is about personal space and not asking unnecessary personal questions. Confidentiality is about keeping the data anonymous.
  4. Mixing up deception and debriefing. Deception is wrong information during the study. The debriefing comes after the data are collected and puts it right.
  5. A suggestion with no reason. When the question says "include a reason", the second mark is for the reason: "so that they can give informed consent".

TOTAL = 13 MARKS

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.