The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: extend
Running a study: a bus seat and a breathing exercise
Teach these first
This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- Ethical guidelines (lesson 9, syllabus 7.7)
- The role of the researcher: the research process (lesson 10, syllabus 7.8)
Task 1: "Could I sit down, please?" (9 marks) 10 min
A bus company wants to know whether passengers are more likely to give up their seat for an older passenger who asks for one. Researchers use an actor, a woman of 70 with a walking stick, who gets on busy buses where every seat is taken. She stands near the front.
- In the asking condition she says: "Excuse me, could I sit down, please?"
- In the silent condition she says nothing.
A researcher sits on the bus and records whether anyone offers her a seat within one minute. The passengers do not know a study is taking place.
1(a). Write an aim for this study. (7.8.1, 7.8.2, The role of the researcher: the research process) (1)
1(b). Explain why the researchers use an actor (a stooge) instead of watching what happens to real older passengers. (7.8.1, 7.8.2, The role of the researcher: the research process) (2)
1(c). Suggest two things the actor must keep the same on every bus. (7.8.1, 7.8.2, The role of the researcher: the research process) (2)
1(d). Explain one ethical problem with this study, and suggest how the researchers could reduce it. (7.7.1, 7.7.2, Ethical guidelines) (2)
1(e). Describe how the researcher could record the data on each bus. (7.8.1, 7.8.2, The role of the researcher: the research process) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1(a) (1)
- 1 mark for aim
- An aim that starts "To investigate ..." and names both variables, for example "To investigate whether asking for a seat affects whether passengers give up their seat for an older person" (1)
- do not credit a prediction ("Passengers will give up their seat more when asked"), or an aim with only one variable ("To investigate kindness on buses")
1(b) (2)
- 1 mark for explanation of why the actor is used
- 1 mark for link to real older passengers
- The actor is the same person, looks the same age, uses the same stick and says the same words every time (a standardised situation) (explanation) (1)
- Real older passengers would all be different (how old or unwell they look, what they say), so the researchers could not tell whether asking, or something else, made passengers give up their seat (link) (1)
- allow "they cannot wait for real passengers to ask in exactly the same way" for the link
- do not credit "actors are easier to find" or "it is more fun" with no idea of keeping the situation the same
1(c) (2)
- 1 mark for each thing kept the same (× 2)
- For example the same clothes and walking stick, or the same place to stand (1)
- A second, different thing, for example the same words in the same polite voice, getting on at the same kind of stop, or at the same time of day (1)
- do not credit "whether she asks" (that is the independent variable, which changes), or "act normally"
1(d) (2)
- 1 mark for problem
- 1 mark for way to reduce it
- Passengers cannot give consent because they do not know they are in a study; or a passenger may feel embarrassed or guilty for not giving up a seat (harm) (problem) (1)
- Record no names, faces or photos (confidentiality); observe only what happens in a public place; or tell nearby passengers the truth (debrief) before they get off (way to reduce it) (1)
- The way to reduce it must match the problem.
- do not credit "they should ask everyone for consent first" with no thought that this would change what passengers do; "it is wrong to use actors"
1(e) (2)
- 1 mark for method of recording
- 1 mark for detail
- A checklist or table for each bus, for example the bus number, the condition (asking or silent) and whether a seat was offered (yes or no) (method) (1)
- The time in seconds until a seat was offered, using a stopwatch, or a tally of offers out of all the buses in each condition (detail) (1)
- do not credit "write down what happens" with nothing about what is recorded
Task 2: a breathing exercise before a mock exam (6 marks) 8 min
A school counsellor wants to test whether a 5-minute breathing exercise before a mock exam lowers students' stress. Just before the exam, half of the Year 10 groups do the exercise and half do not. Every student then rates their stress from 1 (calm) to 10 (very stressed) on a slip of paper.
2(a). Write the first three sentences of the counsellor's briefing to a group doing the exercise. It must follow the ethical guidelines. (7.8.1, with 7.7.1, The role of the researcher: the research process) (3)
2(b). Explain why the counsellor should read the same briefing, word for word, to every group. (7.8.1, 7.8.2, The role of the researcher: the research process) (2)
2(c). State one thing the debriefing should include, after the stress ratings have been collected. (7.8.1, with 7.7.1, The role of the researcher: the research process) (1)
Mark scheme: Task 2
2(a) (3)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 3)
- Says what they will do: a 5-minute breathing exercise, then rate their stress from 1 to 10 on a slip of paper (1)
- Asks for their agreement (consent), for example "Are you happy to take part?" (1)
- Tells them they can stop at any time, or leave the rating blank (right to withdraw), or that the slips have no names (confidentiality) (1)
- allow any three of these four ideas, in the student's own words, as long as they are written to the students
- do not credit "I will now tell you about the study" with nothing about the study; the full aim with every detail is not needed before the study
2(b) (2)
- 1 mark for reason
- 1 mark for development
- It keeps the procedure the same for everyone (standardised instructions) (reason) (1)
- If groups heard different instructions, the instructions could change their stress ratings (an extraneous variable), so a difference could not be put down to the breathing exercise (development) (1)
- allow "so the study can be repeated in the same way and give consistent results" for the development
- do not credit "so that it is clear" or "so nobody is confused": clear is not the same as identical
2(c) (1)
- 1 mark for one thing the debriefing should include
- For example: the full aim of the study, what the ratings will be used for, a chance to ask questions, or that they can ask for their rating to be removed (1)
- do not credit "thank them" on its own, or "tell them their stress score" (the slips are anonymous)
TOTAL = 15 MARKS