The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0)
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 7 Research methods (Unit 0) · Homework: extend
Tired drivers: what do the data really show?
Teach these first
This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- Dealing with data: the range and bar charts (lesson 12, syllabus 7.9.5–7.9.8)
- Dealing with data: reaching conclusions (lesson 13, syllabus 7.9.9–7.9.10)
Task 1: what do the results show? (6 marks) 7 min
A road-safety charity wants to know whether a short nap helps tired drivers. 24 adult volunteers each sleep only 5 hours one night. The next day, at 2 p.m., 12 of them have a 20-minute nap and the other 12 watch a calm TV programme for 20 minutes. At 3 p.m. everyone drives the same route in a driving simulator. When a child steps into the road, the simulator records how quickly each driver presses the brake: their reaction time, in milliseconds. A lower time means a faster reaction.
Aim: to investigate whether a short nap affects how quickly tired drivers react.
| Group | Mean reaction time (milliseconds) | Range (milliseconds) |
|---|---|---|
| 20-minute nap | 610 | 120 |
| No nap (watched TV) | 780 | 410 |
1(a). Write a conclusion about the effect of the nap. Use the means and refer back to the aim. (7.9.9, 7.9.10, Dealing with data: reaching conclusions) (2)
1(b). Explain what the ranges show about the two groups. (7.9.5, 7.9.6, Dealing with data: the range and bar charts) (2)
1(c). A student writes: "The no-nap group did better, because their number is higher." Explain the mistake. (7.9.10, Dealing with data: reaching conclusions) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1(a) (2)
- 1 mark for conclusion from the means
- 1 mark for link back to the aim
- The nap group reacted faster on average: a mean of 610 ms compared with 780 ms for the no-nap group (conclusion) (1)
- So the results support the aim's idea that a short nap affects (speeds up) how quickly tired drivers react (link) (1)
- allow "the data suggest a nap helps tired drivers brake sooner" for the link, if it refers back to the aim
- do not credit "the nap group was 610 and the TV group was 780" with no pattern (that is data, not a conclusion); "this proves naps work"
1(b) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- The nap group's range (120 ms) is much smaller than the no-nap group's (410 ms) (1)
- So the nap group's reaction times were more consistent (close together), while the no-nap drivers varied a lot: some reacted quickly and some very slowly (1)
- do not credit "the nap group did better because their range is smaller" (the range shows spread, not which group was faster)
1(c) (2)
- 1 mark for explanation of what a higher time means
- 1 mark for the correct comparison
- A higher reaction time means a slower reaction: the drivers took longer to press the brake (explanation) (1)
- So the no-nap group did worse: 780 ms is slower than 610 ms, and the nap group did better (comparison) (1)
- do not credit "the numbers are the wrong way round" with no reason about time
Task 2: check the headline (4 marks) 5 min
A newspaper reports the study with this headline: "Scientists prove that a nap makes ALL drivers TWICE as safe!"
2. Use the study to explain two ways in which the headline goes beyond the data. (7.9.9, 7.9.10, with 7.5, Dealing with data: reaching conclusions) (4)
Mark scheme: Task 2
2 (4)
- 1 mark for each way the headline goes beyond the data (× 2)
- 1 mark for each link to the study (× 2)
- Way 1, for example "prove": one study can only support or suggest a conclusion (way) (1)
- Only 24 people took part, once, in one simulator (link) (1)
- Way 2, for example "all drivers": the sample may not represent all drivers (way) (1)
- The sample was 24 volunteers who had slept only 5 hours, so well-rested drivers, older drivers or professional drivers may react differently (link) (1)
- allow "twice as safe": 610 ms is not half of 780 ms (about 22% faster), and braking in a simulator is reaction time, not real road safety or crashes, as a way (with its link)
- A way with no link to the study scores 1 mark.
- do not credit "newspapers always lie", or "the headline is too long"
Task 3: a second study and one very slow driver (5 marks) 6 min
In a second study, tired drivers had a 20-minute nap, a cup of coffee, or nothing, before a 10-minute drive in the simulator. The bar chart shows the mean number of hazards (such as a cyclist or a red light) each group missed.
3(a). State the mean number of hazards missed by the coffee group. (7.9.8, Dealing with data: the range and bar charts) (1)
3(b). The aim was to investigate whether a nap or coffee helps tired drivers notice hazards. Write one conclusion from the bar chart that refers back to this aim. (7.9.9, 7.9.10, Dealing with data: reaching conclusions) (2)
3(c). In the first study, one driver in the no-nap group took 1050 ms to brake, far slower than everyone else. Explain how this one driver affects the range of that group. (7.9.5, 7.9.6, Dealing with data: the range and bar charts) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 3
3(a) (1)
- 1 mark for the correct number
- 3 (hazards) (1)
- do not credit any other number; "6" is the group who had nothing
3(b) (2)
- 1 mark for conclusion from the chart
- 1 mark for link back to the aim
- Drivers who had a nap or coffee missed fewer hazards than drivers who had nothing (2 and 3, compared with 6), and the nap group missed the fewest (conclusion) (1)
- So the results support the idea that a nap (and, slightly less, coffee) helps tired drivers notice hazards (link) (1)
- do not credit a list of the three numbers with no pattern, or "coffee is useless" (coffee drivers missed fewer than drivers who had nothing)
3(c) (2)
- 1 mark for how the range is found
- 1 mark for the effect on the range
- The range is the highest time minus the lowest time, so this driver's 1050 ms becomes the highest value (explanation) (1)
- One extreme score makes the range much bigger, so the group looks more spread out than most of its drivers really were (effect) (1)
- allow "the range only uses two scores, so one unusual driver changes it a lot" for the effect
- do not credit "it makes the mean bigger" on its own (the question is about the range)
TOTAL = 15 MARKS