The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 1 Memory and forgetting

Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 1 Memory and forgetting · Homework: extend

Amnesia in real life: a rugby player, a grandmother and a phone

Syllabus 1.1.4Homework: extendAbout 18 minutes14 marks
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

Task 1: a concussion on the rugby pitch (5 marks) 6 min

A rugby player is knocked out in a heavy tackle. When he wakes up in the changing room, the team doctor asks him two questions:

Question A: "Who scored our first try today?" (before he was knocked out)
Question B: "What did I tell you two minutes ago?"

A week later he trains as normal. He cannot remember anything about the match, but he can still pass, kick and tackle perfectly.

1(a). Identify which of the doctor's questions checks for retrograde amnesia and which checks for anterograde amnesia. Give a reason for each. (1.1.4, Forgetting) (2)

Retrograde
Anterograde

1(b). Use the types of memory to explain why he can still pass, kick and tackle, even though he has lost his memories of the match. (1.1.3, with 1.1.4, Types of memory) (3)

Mark scheme: Task 1

1(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for each type linked to its question (× 2)
  • Retrograde: Question A, because it asks about something that happened before the injury (1)
  • Anterograde: Question B, because it asks about new information given after the injury (1)
  • Do not credit the two the wrong way round. A type with no reason scores 0 for that line.

1(b) (3)

  • 1 mark for each relevant point (× 3)
  • Passing, kicking and tackling are skills, so they are stored as procedural memories (how to do tasks) (1)
  • The memories he lost (the match, the tries) are declarative memories of events (1)
  • The two types of memory work separately / procedural memory is often not lost in amnesia, as with Clive Wearing, so losing declarative memories of the match does not remove his skills (1)
  • Allow "his skills were learned through years of repetition and are automatic" as part of the first point.
  • Do not credit "he has practised a lot" with no memory type, or "procedural memory is stronger" with no idea that the types are separate.

Task 2: a grandmother after a stroke (5 marks) 7 min

After a stroke, Rosa, aged 78, cannot remember who visited her that morning or what the nurse told her an hour ago. She still remembers her wedding and her children's names. Every day a physiotherapist teaches her to use a new walking frame. After two weeks she uses it well, but every day she says she has never seen the frame before.

2(a). Identify the type of amnesia Rosa has. Describe one piece of evidence for it from the passage. (1.1.4, Forgetting) (2)

Type
Evidence

2(b). Explain why Rosa gets better at using the walking frame, even though she says she has never seen it before. (1.1.3, with 1.1.4, Types of memory) (3)

Mark scheme: Task 2

2(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for identification
    1 mark for evidence
  • Anterograde amnesia (1)
  • She cannot remember new information after the stroke, for example her visitors that morning or what the nurse said an hour ago (evidence) (1)
  • Allow "she remembers her wedding, so old memories are kept" only if it is added to the evidence about new information.
  • Do not credit retrograde (she still remembers her past), or "she forgets things" with nothing about after the stroke.

2(b) (3)

  • 1 mark for each relevant point (× 3)
  • Using the walking frame is a skill, stored as a procedural memory, which gets stronger with daily repetition (1)
  • Remembering the frame or the lessons is a declarative memory (of events), and her anterograde amnesia stops new declarative memories being stored (1)
  • So her skill improves without her consciously remembering the practice: the two types of memory work separately (1)
  • Do not credit "she is pretending" or "she is getting stronger" (physical strength, not memory), or "she has retrograde amnesia".

Task 3: a phone as a memory (4 marks) 5 min

Rosa's family want to help her live at home again. Her granddaughter sets up a phone for her.

3. Suggest two ways a phone could help someone with anterograde amnesia in daily life. Explain how each one helps. (1.1.4, Forgetting) (4)

Way 1
How it helps
Way 2
How it helps
Mark scheme: Task 3

3 (4)

  • 1 mark for suggestion (× 2)
    1 mark for explanation (× 2)
  • Way 1, for example alarms and reminders for medicines and meals (suggestion) (1)
  • How it helps, linked to anterograde amnesia: she cannot store new information such as today's plan, so the phone stores it and reminds her at the right time (explanation) (1)
  • Way 2, for example a diary or notes app she reads every morning / photos of visitors and carers with their names / video messages from family (suggestion) (1)
  • How it helps: it holds new information she would otherwise forget, such as who visited, so she can check it instead of remembering it (explanation) (1)
  • Allow "step-by-step video instructions" for a new task, with the reason that she can follow them each time without remembering them.
  • Do not credit "photos of her wedding" (she still remembers the past: that is retrograde, which she does not have) or "games to train her memory" with no link to daily life. Max 2 for each way.

TOTAL = 14 MARKS

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.