The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 1 Memory and forgetting

Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 1 Memory and forgetting · Homework: exam technique

Exam technique: how a study supports a theory

Syllabus 1.2.3Homework: exam techniqueAbout 20 minutes13 marks
Back to the lesson

Teach these first

This homework practises one exam skill, using these lessons. Teach them before students start here:

The skill: from results to the theory 2 min

"Explain why the study about ... supports the argument for ..." is usually worth 4 marks, one for each relevant point. The points form a chain:

The chain
Link in the chainWhat you write
1. ResultsWhat was found: the pattern, in order, with numbers if you have them.
2. ConclusionWhat the results show about memory.
3. Link to the theoryWhich idea of the theory this fits, and why.

What the researchers did (the procedure) only sets the scene: it earns little or nothing, because the syllabus asks for the results and conclusion of each named study.

Worked example: Craik and Tulving 4 min

The question: Explain why the study about levels of processing (Craik and Tulving) supports the argument for the levels of processing model. (4)

A full-mark answer, sentence by sentence:

  1. Craik and Tulving found that words processed for their meaning (semantic processing) were recognised most often. (1) Results.
  2. Words processed for their sound (phonemic) were recognised less often, and words processed for their appearance (structural) least of all. (1) Results: the full pattern, in order.
  3. This shows that the deeper the processing when information is encoded, the better it is remembered. (1) Conclusion.
  4. This supports the levels of processing model, which says memory depends on depth of processing: participants did not know there would be a test, so the words were stored as a by-product of processing them. (1) Link to the theory.
  5. They tested 24 students with 60 five-letter words. (no mark)

The last sentence is procedure: true, but it earns no mark.

Task 1: sort the chain (3 marks) 3 min

A teacher repeated a version of the study with her class. Here are four sentences from a student's answer about it.

  • A: "The teacher read out 30 words and asked a question about each one."
  • B: "Words with a meaning question were recognised by 80% of the class, rhyming words by 52% and capital-letter words by 35%."
  • C: "This fits the model's idea that semantic processing is the deepest level and leaves the strongest memory trace."
  • D: "So the deeper the processing, the better the words were remembered."

1. Identify which sentence gives the results, which gives the conclusion, which links to the theory, and which would earn no mark. (1.2.3, Craik and Tulving (1975)) (3)

Results
Conclusion
Link to the theory
No mark
Mark scheme: Task 1

1 (3)

  • 1 mark for each sentence correctly sorted (× 3)
  • All four correct: results B, conclusion D, link to the theory C, no mark A (3)
  • Two or three correct: 2 marks. One correct: 1 mark.
  • Do not credit A as the results: it says what the teacher did (procedure), not what was found.

Task 2: guided practice, the class version (4 marks) 5 min

The class did not know there would be a memory test. Afterwards they picked out the words they had seen from a longer list.

Table 1: the class version of the study
Question asked about each wordLevel of processingMean % of words recognised
"Is it in capital letters?"structural35
"Does it rhyme with ...?"phonemic52
"Does it fit the sentence ...?"semantic80

2. Explain how the results in Table 1 support the levels of processing model. (1.2.3, with 1.2.1–1.2.2, Craik and Tulving (1975)) (4)

Answer frame

  • Results: "Words with ... questions were recognised most (...%), then ..., and ... least (...%)."
  • Conclusion: "This shows that ..."
  • Link: "This supports the levels of processing model, which says ..."
Results
Results (the rest of the pattern)
Conclusion
Link
Mark scheme: Task 2

2 (4)

  • 1 mark for each relevant point (× 4)
  • Results: semantic (meaning) questions gave the highest recognition, 80% (1)
  • Results: then phonemic (rhyme) 52%, and structural (capital letters) the lowest, 35% (1)
  • Conclusion: the deeper the processing, the better the memory (1)
  • Link: the model says memory depends on depth of processing (semantic is deepest), and the class did not know about the test, so storage was a by-product of processing (1)
  • Allow the results with the levels named but no numbers, for the first two points.
  • Do not credit "the semantic group remembered more" with no comparison, "this proves the model", or a description of what the class did.

Task 3: on your own, a language app (6 marks) 6 min

A language-learning app gives 200 users 30 new French words. Half practise with Mode 1, half with Mode 2. None of them are told there will be a test.

Table 2: the language app's results a week later
Practice modeWhat users did with each new wordMean words recalled (out of 30)
Mode 1Typed it three times9
Mode 2Wrote a sentence about their own life using it17

3(a). Identify the level of processing used in each practice mode. (1.2.2, Levels of processing) (2)

Mode 1
Mode 2

3(b). Explain how the results in Table 2 support the levels of processing model. (1.2.3, with 1.2.1, Craik and Tulving (1975)) (4)

Self-check: before you hand in

  • ☐ I gave the results first, as a pattern (which was highest, which lowest), with numbers.
  • ☐ I said what the results show (the conclusion).
  • ☐ I named the idea of the model they support (depth of processing, storage as a by-product).
  • ☐ I did not spend sentences on what the researchers did.
  • ☐ I wrote "supports", not "proves".
Mark scheme: Task 3

3(a) (2)

  • 1 mark for each mode (× 2)
  • Mode 1: structural (shallow) processing: only the look (spelling) of the word (1)
  • Mode 2: semantic (deep) processing: the meaning of the word, linked to the user's own life (1)
  • Allow "phonemic" for Mode 1 only if the student says users would say the word as they type it.
  • Do not credit "Mode 2: phonemic" (writing a sentence is about meaning).

3(b) (4)

  • 1 mark for each relevant point (× 4)
  • Results: users who wrote a sentence with each word recalled more words (a mean of 17 out of 30) (1)
  • than users who typed each word three times (a mean of 9) (1)
  • Conclusion: deeper (semantic) processing led to better memory than shallow (structural) processing, even with the same 30 words (1)
  • Link: this is what the model predicts: memory depends on depth of processing, not on repetition; the users did not know about the test, so storage was a by-product of processing (1)
  • Do not credit "Mode 2 is better because it takes longer" with no depth of processing, or a description of the app with no results.

Common misconceptions and exam errors

  1. Describing the procedure instead of the results. "They used 60 words and three kinds of question" sets the scene. The marks are for what was found and what it shows.
  2. Getting the order wrong. Semantic gave the best memory, then phonemic, then structural.
  3. Stopping at the results. Finish the chain: say what the results show, then link them to the model.
  4. "Recalled" or "recognised"? Craik and Tulving used a recognition test: participants picked out words they had seen. Use "recognised" for their study.
  5. "The study proves the model." One study supports a model; it cannot do more than that.

TOTAL = 13 MARKS

Back to the lesson

Was this page useful?

Goes straight to the two people who make these pages. Please don't include students' names or other personal details.