The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 1 Memory and forgetting
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 1 Memory and forgetting · Homework: extend
Levels of processing at work: groups, the exam hall and two friends
Teach these first
This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- Craik and Tulving (1975) (lesson 18, syllabus 1.2.3)
- Levels of processing: arguments and applications (lesson 19, syllabus 1.2.3–1.2.6)
Task 1: the levels of processing model (3 marks) 4 min
A teacher gives a class the same list of 20 everyday words, such as carrot, blanket and river. The class is split into three groups, and each group does a different task with every word (Table 1.1). No one is told that there will be a memory test afterwards.
| Group | Task for each word |
|---|---|
| A | Decide whether the word is printed in capital letters. |
| B | Decide whether the word rhymes with a word the teacher says. |
| C | Decide whether the word is something you could find in a kitchen. |
1. The next day, the teacher gives the class a surprise test of how many of the words they can remember. Explain, using the levels of processing model, which group is likely to remember the most words. (1.2.1, 1.2.2, Levels of processing) (3)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1 (3)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 3)
- Group C (deciding whether the word is something found in a kitchen) (1)
- This task makes them think about the meaning of each word: semantic processing, the deepest level (1)
- The model says deeper processing leaves a stronger, more durable memory trace, so the words are easier to retrieve (access) in the test (1)
- Allow a comparison with the shallower structural (A) or phonemic (B) tasks as part of the second or third point.
- Do not credit "they tried harder to learn the words": no group knew about the test.
Task 2: an argument against (2 marks) 3 min
Craik and Lockhart's levels of processing model has been tested in research, and it has also been criticised.
2. Explain one argument against the levels of processing model. (1.2.4, Levels of processing: arguments and applications) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 2
2 (2)
- 1 mark for argument
1 mark for explanation - The model cannot explain the limited capacity of memory (1)
- It explains memory only by how deeply information is processed, so it says nothing about how much information can be held at one time (for example, why short-term memory holds only about 7 items) (explanation) (1)
- Limited capacity is the argument against that the syllabus names (1.2.4).
- Allow, if explained: "depth" is hard to measure separately from how well something is remembered (circular).
- Do not credit "the model is wrong" or "it is too simple" with no reason.
Task 3: forgetting in the exam hall (6 marks) 7 min
A student revises biology every evening at a desk in their bedroom, always with the same music playing. In the exam hall, which is silent, they cannot recall some facts that they knew well at home. Back at home that evening, they remember the facts again.
3(a). Outline the encoding specificity principle. (1.2.5, Levels of processing: arguments and applications) (2)
3(b). Explain, using the encoding specificity principle, why the student cannot recall the facts in the exam hall but can recall them again at home. (1.2.5, 1.2.6, Levels of processing: arguments and applications) (2)
3(c). Suggest one way the student could change how they revise to improve their recall in the exam. Explain why it would help. (1.2.6, Levels of processing: arguments and applications) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 3
3(a) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- Memory recall is improved (better) (1)
- when the recall conditions (the context and cues) are the same as the encoding conditions (1)
- The syllabus wording (1.2.5).
- Do not credit "recall only works when ..." (recall is improved, not impossible otherwise).
3(b) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- At encoding the context included the bedroom, the desk and the music; in the silent exam hall these cues are missing (the conditions do not match) (1)
- So the facts are still stored but cannot be retrieved (accessed); at home the cues are present again, so recall improves (1)
- The second point needs the idea that the information was not lost: it is a failure to retrieve it.
- Do not credit "the student was nervous in the exam" with no link to the cues.
3(c) (2)
- 1 mark for suggestion
1 mark for explanation - A suggestion, for example revise in silence at a desk, in conditions more like the exam hall / picture the bedroom and the music at the start of the exam / revise in several different places / explain each fact in their own words (suggestion) (1)
- A matching reason, for example the recall conditions then match the encoding conditions, so the context works as a cue / the facts are no longer tied to one context / deeper (semantic) processing gives a stronger trace that is easier to retrieve (explanation) (1)
- The reason must explain why the suggestion helps, using the encoding specificity principle or the levels of processing model.
- Do not credit "bring the music into the exam": it is not allowed.
Task 4: two friends revise (4 marks) 5 min
Two friends revise for a geography test on volcanoes. Dev reads his notes five times. Priya draws a mind map that links each fact to a volcano she saw in a documentary, then explains it to her younger brother. In the test, Priya remembers more.
4(a). A classmate says: "Priya remembered more only because she spent longer revising." Explain why this is a problem for the levels of processing model. (1.2.3–1.2.4, Levels of processing: arguments and applications) (2)
4(b). Another classmate says: "We know Priya's mind map was deep processing, because she remembered more." Explain the problem with this reasoning. (1.2.3–1.2.4, Levels of processing: arguments and applications) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 4
4(a) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- Deeper tasks, such as drawing a mind map and explaining it, usually take longer than shallow ones such as reading notes (1)
- So Priya's better recall might be caused by the extra time she spent, not by the depth of processing, and the model cannot separate the two (1)
- Do not credit "the classmate is wrong" or "Priya is cleverer" with no link to the model.
4(b) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- The reasoning is circular: it uses the better memory to show the processing was deep, and then uses deep processing to explain the better memory (1)
- Depth needs to be measured on its own, before the memory test, otherwise the model cannot be tested (any result would seem to fit) (1)
- Allow "there is no separate way to measure how deep processing is" for the second point.
- Do not credit "mind maps are always deep" or "she remembered more, so it worked" (these repeat the reasoning).
TOTAL = 15 MARKS