The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 1 Memory and forgetting
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 1 Memory and forgetting · Homework: exam technique
Exam technique: arguments for and against a theory
Teach these first
This homework practises one exam skill, using these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- Levels of processing: arguments and applications (lesson 19, syllabus 1.2.3–1.2.6)
- The multistore model of memory (lesson 1 of 2) (lesson 20, syllabus 1.3.1–1.3.2)
- The multistore model of memory (lesson 2 of 2) (lesson 21, syllabus 1.3.2–1.3.6)
The skill: one argument for, one argument against 2 min
"Explain one argument for and one argument against ..." is usually worth 4 marks, one for each relevant point. Write two points for each side:
| Side | Point 1 | Point 2 |
|---|---|---|
| For | The evidence: what the named study found. | Why it supports the theory. |
| Against | The argument against that the syllabus names. | Why it is a problem for the theory, with an example. |
If you only write about one side, you can get 3 marks at most. When a question then asks you to justify a choice, pick one side and support it with a reason from the scenario.
Worked example: the levels of processing model 4 min
The question: Explain one argument for and one argument against the levels of processing model. (4)
A full-mark answer, sentence by sentence:
- For: Craik and Tulving found that words processed for their meaning were recognised more often than words processed for their sound or appearance. (1) Argument for: the evidence.
- This supports the model's idea that deeper processing leads to better memory. (1) Argument for: why it supports the model.
- Against: the model cannot explain the limited capacity of memory. (1) Argument against: the one the syllabus names.
- It explains memory by how deeply information is processed, but says nothing about how much can be held at one time, such as why we can hold only a few items in mind at once. (1) Argument against: why it is a problem.
- Overall, the model is good. (no mark)
The last sentence earns nothing: it gives no reason. A full answer to only one of the two sides would get 3 marks at most.
Task 1: for, against or neither? (3 marks) 3 min
Decide whether each statement is an argument for the multistore model, an argument against it, or not an argument at all.
- (i) "Murdock found that the first and the last words in a list were recalled better than the words in the middle."
- (ii) "Craik and Tulving found that words processed for meaning were recognised more often, even though participants saw every word in the same way."
- (iii) "The multistore model has three stores: the sensory register, short-term memory and long-term memory."
1. Write "for", "against" or "neither" for each statement, with a short reason. (1.3.4, 1.3.5, The multistore model of memory (lesson 2 of 2)) (3)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1 (3)
- 1 mark for each correct classification (× 3)
- (i) For: it is evidence (Murdock) that short-term and long-term memory are separate stores (primacy from LTM, recency from STM) (1)
- (ii) Against: depth of processing affected memory, which the multistore model cannot explain (1)
- (iii) Neither: it describes the model but gives no evidence or problem (1)
- Allow the word alone (for, against, neither) if it is correct; the reason helps the student check.
- Do not credit (ii) "for" because it mentions a study: the study supports the levels of processing model, not the multistore model.
Task 2: guided practice, the multistore model (4 marks) 5 min
2. Explain one argument for and one argument against the multistore model of memory. (1.3.4, 1.3.5, The multistore model of memory (lesson 2 of 2)) (4)
Answer frame
- For: "Murdock found that ... This supports the multistore model because ..."
- Against: "The multistore model cannot explain ... For example, Craik and Tulving found ..., which the model cannot explain because it says ..."
Mark scheme: Task 2
2 (4)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 4)
Max 3 if only one side is answered - For: Murdock found a serial position effect: the first few words (primacy) and the last few words (recency) of a list were recalled best, the middle words least (evidence) (1)
- Primacy comes from long-term memory (early words were rehearsed and transferred) and recency from short-term memory (the last words are still there), which supports the idea that STM and LTM are separate stores (explanation) (1)
- Against: the multistore model cannot explain depth of processing (1)
- It says information reaches LTM through rehearsal, but Craik and Tulving found that words processed for meaning were remembered better than other words seen in the same way, so how deeply information is processed matters too (explanation) (1)
- Allow "the model is too simple" only if it is explained with depth of processing.
- Do not credit a description of the three stores (not an argument), or "Murdock proved the model".
Task 3: on your own, a capital-cities quiz (6 marks) 6 min
Two friends prepare for a quiz on 20 countries and their capital cities. Sam repeats the list aloud, over and over. Ana makes up a short story for each capital that links it to something she already knows, and does not repeat the list. In the quiz, Ana remembers more capitals than Sam.
3(a). Use the multistore model to explain how Sam's method could help him remember the capitals. (1.3.2, 1.3.6, The multistore model of memory (lesson 2 of 2)) (2)
3(b). Use the argument against the multistore model to explain why Ana's result is a problem for the model. (1.3.5, 1.3.6, The multistore model of memory (lesson 2 of 2)) (2)
3(c). Suggest whether the multistore model or the levels of processing model better explains Ana's result. Justify your answer. (1.3.5, with 1.2.1–1.2.2, The multistore model of memory (lesson 2 of 2)) (2)
Self-check: before you hand in
- ☐ I wrote about BOTH sides when the question asked for one argument for and one against.
- ☐ Each argument has two points: the evidence or the problem, then why it matters.
- ☐ I used the names the syllabus uses: Murdock (for), depth of processing (against).
- ☐ In 3(a) and 3(b) I linked the model to Sam and Ana.
- ☐ In 3(c) I chose one model and gave a reason from the scenario.
Mark scheme: Task 3
3(a) (2)
- 1 mark for explanation
1 mark for link to scenario - The multistore model says repeating information (rehearsal) keeps it in short-term memory and, with enough rehearsal, transfers it to long-term memory (explanation) (1)
- Sam repeats the list over and over, so the capitals may be rehearsed enough to reach long-term memory, where they can be stored for the quiz (link) (1)
- Do not credit "he repeats it so he remembers it" with no stores named.
3(b) (2)
- 1 mark for explanation
1 mark for link to scenario - The model says rehearsal is how information reaches long-term memory, so Sam, who rehearsed more, should remember more (explanation) (1)
- Ana did not repeat the list but processed each capital's meaning (deep, semantic processing) and remembered more: the model cannot explain depth of processing (link) (1)
- Do not credit "the model is wrong" with no link to Ana or to depth of processing.
3(c) (2)
- 1 mark for judgement
1 mark for justification - The levels of processing model (judgement) (1)
- Ana linked each capital to its meaning and to what she knew (semantic, deep processing), which the model says gives a stronger memory trace, while the multistore model would predict that Sam, who rehearsed more, remembers more (justification) (1)
- Allow the multistore model only if the answer argues that Ana's stories were a kind of rehearsal: Max 1.
- Do not credit a model named with no reason linked to Ana.
Common misconceptions and exam errors
- Only one side. The specimen mark schemes give 3 marks at most if only one side is addressed.
- Describing the model instead of arguing about it. "The model has three stores" is a description: it earns nothing in an arguments question.
- A vague argument against. "The model is too simple" will not score on its own. Name depth of processing and explain it with Craik and Tulving's finding.
- Swapping primacy and recency. Primacy: the first words were rehearsed into long-term memory. Recency: the last words are still in short-term memory.
- "Murdock proved the model." One study can support a model, never more than that.
- A judgement with no reason. "Justify" means support your choice with evidence from the scenario.
TOTAL = 13 MARKS