The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 1 Memory and forgetting
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 1 Memory and forgetting · Homework: extend
Testing memory fairly: a language app and a recall quiz
Teach these first
This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- Murdock's study and your own investigation (lesson 2 of 3) (lesson 23, syllabus 1.3.4)
- Murdock's study and your own investigation (lesson 3 of 3) (lesson 24, syllabus 1.3.4)
Task 1: does a picture help? (7 marks) 9 min
A language-learning app wants to know whether a new feature helps users remember Spanish words: a small picture next to each new word. In one week, 400 users get a lesson of 20 new words. Half of them see each word with a picture; the other half see the words alone. The next day, every user takes a test on the same 20 words.
The app always shows the 20 words in the same order. Users can take the test whenever and wherever they like: at home, on the bus or in a café.
1(a). The app always shows the 20 words in the same order. Use the serial position effect to explain why this could make some words look easier to learn than others, and suggest how the app could fix this. (1.3.2, 7.1.21, Murdock's study and your own investigation (lesson 1 of 3)) (3)
1(b). Identify one extraneous variable that comes from letting users take the test wherever they like, and suggest a control for it. (7.1.19–7.1.21, Murdock's study and your own investigation (lesson 2 of 3)) (2)
1(c). Explain why every user should see exactly the same written instructions before the test. (7.8.1, 7.6.4, Murdock's study and your own investigation (lesson 2 of 3)) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1(a) (3)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 3)
- Words at the start and the end of the lesson are recalled better (primacy and recency effects) (1)
- So those words would score well because of their position, not because they are easier to learn (or because of the picture) (1)
- Fix: show the words in a different order to each user (for example a random order, or half the users see the list backwards), so every word is sometimes near the start, middle and end (1)
- Allow "counterbalance the order of the words" for the third mark, if it is clear the order changes between users.
- Do not credit "show fewer words" or "make the words easier" (that does not deal with the order).
1(b) (2)
- 1 mark for extraneous variable
1 mark for control - An extraneous variable, for example noise or distractions on the bus, the time of day, or someone helping the user (1)
- A matching control, for example everyone takes the test in a quiet place at the same time of day, or the test must be done alone, with the app locked to full screen (1)
- Do not credit "the picture" (that is the IV) or "their memory" (that is what is measured).
1(c) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- So that every user is told exactly the same thing: standardised instructions (1)
- So any difference in scores is caused by the picture (the IV), not by different instructions; or so the procedure is consistent and the results reliable (1)
- Do not credit "so it is fair" with no reason.
Task 2: the recall quiz trial (6 marks) 8 min
A head of year wants to know whether a five-minute recall quiz at the start of every lesson helps Year 10 students remember more. She asks Mr Diaz to use the quizzes with his class for a term and compares their end-of-term test scores with another Year 10 class, taught by Ms Reid, that has no quizzes.
Mr Diaz tells his class that the quizzes are compulsory and part of a study. At the end of term he pins every student's test score, with their name, on the classroom wall. Nobody is told afterwards what the study was for.
2(a). Identify two ethical guidelines that Mr Diaz does not follow. For each one, say what he should do instead. (7.7.1, 7.7.2, Murdock's study and your own investigation (lesson 2 of 3)) (4)
2(b). The two classes have different teachers. Explain why this makes it hard to conclude that the quizzes caused any difference in test scores. (7.1.19, 7.9.9, Murdock's study and your own investigation (lesson 3 of 3)) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 2
2(a) (4)
- 1 mark for each guideline (× 2)
1 mark for each matching fix (× 2)
Max 4 - Confidentiality: the scores are shown with names (1)
- Use numbers instead of names, or keep the scores private (fix) (1)
- Right to withdraw: the quizzes are compulsory, so students cannot leave the study (1)
- Tell students they can stop taking part in the study at any time (their quiz results will not be used) (fix) (1)
- Debriefing: nobody is told what the study was for (1)
- At the end, explain the aim and the results to the students (fix) (1)
- Allow consent ("he did not ask whether they wanted to be in the study") with the fix "ask for agreement first".
- Do not credit a guideline named with no link to what Mr Diaz did, or "privacy" for the names on the wall (that is confidentiality).
2(b) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- The teacher is an extraneous variable: Mr Diaz and Ms Reid may teach differently (one may explain better or set more homework) (1)
- So a difference in scores could be caused by the teacher, not by the quizzes, and the conclusion would not be valid (1)
- Allow the classes may differ in other ways (ability, time of day), with the same link to the conclusion.
- Do not credit "it is unfair" with no reason.
TOTAL = 13 MARKS