The Chromozone / Courses / IGCSE Psychology / Topic 1 Memory and forgetting
Cambridge IGCSE Psychology (0266) · Topic 1 Memory and forgetting · Homework: extend
The brain and memory in real life: taxi drivers, Alzheimer's disease and adverts
Teach these first
This homework builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
- The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2) (lesson 26, syllabus 1.5.1–1.5.3)
Task 1: the London taxi drivers (5 marks) 6 min
To get a licence, London taxi drivers must learn the layout of central London. In 2000, Eleanor Maguire and her colleagues scanned the brains of licensed London taxi drivers and compared them with people who did not drive taxis. The rear part of the hippocampus was larger in the taxi drivers, and a front part was smaller. The longer someone had driven a taxi, the larger the rear part was.
1(a). Identify the network of structures in the brain that the hippocampus is part of. (1.5.2, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (1)
1(b). Explain how this study supports localisation of function. (1.5.1, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (2)
1(c). Suggest one reason why this study cannot show that driving a taxi caused the difference in the hippocampus. (1.5.1, 1.5.3, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 1
1(a) (1)
- 1 mark for identification
- The limbic system (1)
1(b) (2)
- 1 mark for each relevant point (× 2)
- A specific part of the brain (the rear hippocampus) differs in people who rely on a specific ability (remembering routes) (1)
- This suggests that this part is responsible for that function, not the whole brain (1)
- Allow "different parts of the brain do different jobs" for the second mark, if linked to the drivers.
1(c) (2)
- 1 mark for reason
1 mark for explanation - Drivers were not put into groups at random (the researchers did not make them become drivers) (1)
- People who already have a larger rear hippocampus may be more likely to become taxi drivers (explanation) (1)
- Allow other reasons, for example the drivers may have differed in another way, such as age or experience of driving in general, with the effect explained.
- Do not credit "the sample is too small" with no reason why that means taxi driving may not be the cause.
Task 2: Mr Perera's memory (6 marks) 7 min
This task is about an illness that may affect someone you know. If you find it upsetting, talk to your teacher.
In Alzheimer's disease, brain cells gradually die, which affects memory and thinking. The hippocampus is one of the first areas affected. Mr Perera, 81, has early Alzheimer's disease. He can tell you in detail about his first day at work in 1962. But he forgets what he has eaten for lunch, and he asks the same question several times in a morning.
2(a). Use the role of the hippocampus to explain why Mr Perera forgets his lunch. (1.5.3, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (2)
2(b). Explain why Mr Perera can still remember his first day at work. (1.5.3, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (2)
2(c). Suggest one way his family could help him in daily life, and explain why it would help. (1.5.3, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 2
2(a) (2)
- 1 mark for explanation
1 mark for link to scenario - The hippocampus consolidates memories from STM to LTM (explanation) (1)
- His is damaged, so the memory of lunch is not consolidated and is not there when he tries to recall it (link) (1)
2(b) (2)
- 1 mark for explanation
1 mark for link to scenario - Older memories are stored in other parts of the brain, so damage to the hippocampus does not remove them (explanation) (1)
- His first day at work was consolidated into LTM long before the damage (link) (1)
2(c) (2)
- 1 mark for suggestion
1 mark for explanation - A way, for example a whiteboard with the day's plan, or phone reminders (suggestion) (1)
- He can use the information without having to form a new long-term memory, which his damaged hippocampus cannot do (explanation) (1)
- Do not credit "tell him to try harder" (he cannot consolidate the memory by trying).
Task 3: two adverts (4 marks) 6 min
Imagine a charity shows two adverts to two groups of people. Advert A gives facts about the charity's work in a calm voice. Advert B tells the emotional story of a lost dog found and brought home to its family. A week later, the people who saw advert B remember much more of it than the people who saw advert A.
3(a). Use the role of the amygdala to explain why people remember advert B better. (1.5.3, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (2)
3(b). Suggest how the results might be different for a person with damage to the amygdala, and explain why. (1.5.3, The brain and memory (lesson 1 of 2)) (2)
Mark scheme: Task 3
3(a) (2)
- 1 mark for explanation
1 mark for link to scenario - The amygdala influences the consolidation of memories that are emotionally arousing (explanation) (1)
- Advert B is emotionally arousing, so it is consolidated more strongly and remembered better than advert A (link) (1)
3(b) (2)
- 1 mark for suggestion
1 mark for explanation - They might remember advert B no better than advert A (suggestion) (1)
- The amygdala no longer strengthens the emotional memory, although ordinary memory still works (explanation) (1)
- Do not credit "they would not remember either advert": amygdala damage does not stop memory in general.
TOTAL = 15 MARKS