The Chromozone / IAL Biology / Unit 4 / Topic 5
Directed study
Directed study: feeding more people from the same land
Practise the energy calculations of productivity and energy transfer on one real question: how do we get the most food from a field, a glasshouse or a pond? 26 marks. A calculator is needed. It takes about 35 minutes and is worth 26 marks. Work through it on your own after the lesson on energy transfer between trophic levels. Type your answers in the boxes, then hand them in at the bottom of the page. The mark schemes open after you hand in: then mark yourself point by point and correct your work in a different colour. The spec point in brackets after a question tells you where to revise. Teachers: this is the page to set as homework.
Teach these first
This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
Part A: retrieval (6 marks) 6 min
Answer from memory first. The spec point is in brackets after each question.
A1. Write the formula for the efficiency of energy transfer between two trophic levels, and explain why the answer can never be more than 100%. (5.10) (2)
A2. On very hot days, the GPP of a crop stays high but its NPP falls. Explain why. (5.9) (2)
A3. Name two factors a grower can change inside a glasshouse to raise the rate of photosynthesis of a crop. (5.8) (2)
Check your answers to part A
A1 (2)
- Efficiency (%) = energy (or biomass) in the higher trophic level ÷ energy (or biomass) in the lower trophic level × 100 (1)
- Energy is lost at every transfer (none is created), so the higher level always has less than the level below (1)
A2 (2)
- NPP = GPP − R (energy lost by respiration) (1)
- Respiration speeds up as the temperature rises, so more of the GPP is used in respiration and less is stored as new biomass (1)
A3 (2)
- light intensity (extra lamps, longer days) (1)
- carbon dioxide concentration (1)
- temperature (heating) (1)
- Max 2
Part B: feed in, food out (5 marks) 7 min
Most of the world's farm animals eat crops that people could eat themselves. Some food scientists say we should farm insects, such as crickets, instead. The table shows how much feed each kind of farm animal needs to produce 1 kg of food that people can eat (not counting bones, skin or other parts we do not eat).
| Food | Feed needed / kg |
|---|---|
| Crickets | 2.1 |
| Chicken | 4.5 |
| Pork | 9.1 |
| Beef | 25.0 |
B1. Calculate the percentage of the feed mass that ends up as edible food for crickets and for beef cattle. (5.10) (2)
B2. Crickets are insects whose body temperature follows the temperature around them; cattle are mammals that keep their body warm all the time. Use this and your knowledge of energy transfer to explain why cattle turn feed into food much less efficiently than crickets. (5.10) (3)
Check your answers to part B
B1 (2)
- Crickets: 1 ÷ 2.1 × 100 = 48% (1)
- Beef cattle: 1 ÷ 25 × 100 = 4% (1)
- ACCEPT 47.6% and 4.0%
B2 (3): max 3
- Cattle use much of the energy in their food for respiration to keep their body temperature high; this energy is lost as heat, not stored as biomass (1)
- Crickets do not use energy to keep warm, so a larger share of the energy they take in becomes new biomass (1)
- Much of the grass that cattle eat (cellulose) is not digested and is lost in faeces (1)
- A smaller share of a cow's body is edible (bones, skin), so less of the biomass made counts as food (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "energy is used up" (it is transferred to the surroundings as heat)
Part C: how many people can one hectare feed? (7 marks) 9 min
A hectare of maize has a net primary productivity (NPP) of 3.0 × 108 kJ per year. Only 35% of the NPP ends up in the grain that is harvested. One person needs about 1.0 × 104 kJ of food energy a day. Show your working for every step and give each answer in standard form or as a whole number.
C1. Calculate the energy in the maize grain from one hectare in a year. (5.9) (1)
C2. Calculate how many people the grain could feed for a whole year if they ate it themselves. Give a whole number. (5.10) (2)
C3. Instead, the grain is fed to chickens. 10% of the energy in the grain ends up in edible chicken meat. Calculate how many people the chicken could feed for a year. (5.10) (2)
C4. Use the idea of trophic levels to explain the difference between your answers to C2 and C3. (5.10) (2)
Check your answers to part C
C1 (1)
- 3.0 × 108 × 0.35 = 1.05 × 108 kJ (1)
- ACCEPT 1.1 × 108 kJ
C2 (2)
- One person needs 1.0 × 104 × 365 = 3.65 × 106 kJ a year (1)
- 1.05 × 108 ÷ 3.65 × 106 = 28.8, so 28 people (1)
- NB round down: 29 people would not all be fed
C3 (2)
- 1.05 × 108 × 0.10 = 1.05 × 107 kJ in the chicken meat (1)
- 1.05 × 107 ÷ 3.65 × 106 = 2.9, so 2 people (1)
- ACCEPT 3 people with the working shown
C4 (2)
- Eating the grain puts people at the second trophic level (primary consumers); eating chicken puts them at the third (1)
- About 90% of the energy is lost at the extra step, mostly as heat from the chickens' respiration (and in faeces), so about ten times fewer people are fed (1)
Part D: more food from a glasshouse (4 marks) 6 min
Glasshouse growers raise the yield of a crop by changing the conditions. This links core practical 10 (limiting factors) to productivity.
| Carbon dioxide / ppm | Natural light: yield / kg m−2 | Extra lamps: yield / kg m−2 |
|---|---|---|
| 400 | 28 | 33 |
| 1000 | 36 | 48 |
D1. Calculate the percentage increase in yield when carbon dioxide is raised from 400 to 1000 ppm in natural light. (5.8) (1)
D2. Adding extra carbon dioxide and extra light together raises the yield more than adding either one alone. Explain why, and explain how this raises the NPP of the crop. (5.8, 5.9) (3)
Check your answers to part D
D1 (1)
- (36 − 28) ÷ 28 × 100 = 28.6% (1)
- ACCEPT 29%
D2 (3): max 3
- When only one factor is raised, the other becomes the limiting factor, so the rate rises only a little (36 or 33 kg) (1)
- Raising both removes both limits, so the rate of photosynthesis rises much more (48 kg) (1)
- More light gives more ATP and reduced NADP; more carbon dioxide means more is fixed by RUBISCO in the Calvin cycle (1)
- A higher rate of photosynthesis raises the GPP; if respiration stays about the same, NPP (GPP − R) rises, so more biomass (fruit) is made (1)
Part E: exam-style question (4 marks) 7 min
A farmer grows shrimps in a pond. The algae in the pond are the producers; the shrimps eat the algae, and a few fish eat the shrimps.
| Trophic level | Energy entering the level | Energy available to the next level |
|---|---|---|
| 1: algae | 48 000 (GPP) | 21 600 (NPP) |
| 2: shrimps | 3 240 | 520 |
| 3: fish | 520 | 62 |
E1. Calculate the NPP of the algae as a percentage of their GPP. (5.9) (1)
E2. Calculate the efficiency of energy transfer from the algae (energy available) to the shrimps. (5.10) (1)
E3. The farmer sells the shrimps and removes the fish from the pond. Explain why this gives a greater yield of food from the pond than farming the fish. (5.10) (2)
Check your answers to part E
E1 (1)
- 21 600 ÷ 48 000 × 100 = 45% (1)
E2 (1)
- 3 240 ÷ 21 600 × 100 = 15% (1)
E3 (2)
- The shrimps are one trophic level lower than the fish (closer to the producers) (1)
- Energy is lost at every transfer, so far more energy is in shrimp biomass (3 240) than reaches the fish (520), and the fish no longer eat the shrimps (1)