The Chromozone / IAL Biology / Unit 4 / Topic 5
Directed study: exam technique
Exam technique: energy calculations
Directed study: exam technique. About 40 minutes, independent study, 25 marks. One skill: a fixed routine for energy calculations, covering efficiency, percentage change, NPP, ratios, rates, unit conversions, rounding and working that earns marks. Type your answers in the boxes, then hand them in at the bottom of the page. Steps 1 and 2 stay open to use; the mark schemes open after you hand in: then mark your work point by point and correct it in a different colour. Teachers: set this after the lesson Energy transfer between trophic levels.
Teach these first
This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:
How this page works
One exam technique, in three steps: learn how to do it, see it done with the marks shown, then do it yourself on this lesson's content.
Step 1: how to do it 7 min
Energy calculations look different, but one routine works for all of them. Write down each step.
- Read the question. Note the word: percentage, ratio, rate or change. Note how to round.
- Choose the numbers. A table can hold many numbers. Underline the two you need and label them.
- Write the formula. Rearrange it first if you need a different quantity.
- Convert units so that all the numbers match, before you calculate.
- Calculate. Keep the full calculator answer, and round only at the end.
- Finish the answer. Add the unit, the sign or the word "increase" or "decrease". Then check that it is sensible.
| You want | Use | Remember |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage efficiency of energy transfer | energy in the higher level ÷ energy in the lower level × 100 | The higher level is the one that eats. The answer is below 100%. |
| Percentage change | (new − original) ÷ original × 100 | Divide by the original. A minus sign means a decrease: write "decrease" too. |
| NPP, GPP or R | NPP = GPP − R, so R = GPP − NPP and GPP = NPP + R | Rearrange first, then put the numbers in. |
| A ratio | Divide every number by the same number, so that one of them becomes 1. For x : 1, divide by the last number. | Keep the order of the question. One number must be 1. A ratio has no unit. |
| A rate | amount ÷ area ÷ time | Productivity is a rate: its unit has energy, area and time. |
| From | To | Do this |
|---|---|---|
| MJ | kJ | × 1000 |
| hectares (ha) | m² | × 10 000 (1 ha = 100 m × 100 m) |
| year | day | amount per year ÷ 365 gives the amount per day |
| day | year | amount per day × 365 gives the amount per year |
Unit steps of 1000 and standard form are explained on the magnification exam-technique page. The same rules apply here.
| What the examiner looks for | Marks | Note |
|---|---|---|
| The two correct numbers taken from the table | 1 | This is often its own mark. A percentage worked out from a wrong pair of numbers scores nothing for the choice. |
| The calculation done and rounded as asked | 1 | For example 31, 30.8 or 30.77 for 30.769...%. Too many decimal places, or a wrongly rounded figure, loses the mark. |
| A correct answer with no working | full marks | But a wrong answer with no working scores 0. Write the steps so that a slip can still earn a mark. |
| A sign, a unit or the word "decrease" | part of the mark when the question asks for it | Productivity is a rate, so its unit has energy, area and time. A change needs "increase" or "decrease", or a sign. |
| The formula copied out on its own | 0 | It scores only when you put numbers into it. |
Common misconceptions and exam errors
These come up again and again in the reports on real exam answers. Each one costs marks.
- Taking the wrong two numbers from a table. One report says students converted the units correctly, then chose the wrong values. The mark schemes give a mark for choosing the right pair, so a table with extra columns is a trap. Label the higher and the lower trophic level before you divide, and use the energy stored in new biomass at each level.
- Giving too many decimal places, or a recurring number. Examiners report answers that are rounded wrongly or left as a recurring value, and the mark schemes accept only certain values. Round as the question says. If it does not say, a percentage needs one or two decimal places at most.
- Working out a different quantity from the one asked. In one report, students found a percentage decrease when the question asked for a rate of decrease. Read the question word first and write it above your working.
- Writing a ratio with no 1 in it. Reports say students divide one number by another, then do not finish the ratio as 1 : something. However you write a ratio, one number must be 1, for example 6.5 : 1 or 1 : 0.15. Divide every number by the one that should be 1, and keep the order of the question.
- Mixing two ways of writing a unit. One report saw a slash and a negative power in the same unit, such as m / year−1. Both mean "per", so together they give the wrong unit. Write kJ m−2 year−1, or kJ per m2 per year, never a mix.
Step 2: a worked example 5 min
A farmer measured the energy flow in a hill pasture. The sheep eat grass.
| Trophic level | Energy stored in new biomass | Energy taken in as food | Energy lost in faeces |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grass (producers) | 18 400 | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| Sheep (primary consumers) | 900 | 7 300 | 2 100 |
This example is for learning. Its 2 marks do not count in your total.
Question: Calculate the percentage efficiency of energy transfer from the grass to the sheep. Use the energy stored in new biomass. Give your answer to 1 decimal place. (2)
Answer 1 0 of 2 marks
Efficiency = 900 ÷ 7 300 × 100 = 12.3%
Why: The student took the energy the sheep eat as the lower level. The question asks about the grass, and the energy stored in new grass biomass is 18 400. So the wrong pair of numbers was chosen and the percentage cannot score. The calculation itself is correct, but a correct method on the wrong numbers earns nothing here.
Answer 2 2 of 2 marks
Higher level (sheep) = 900. Lower level (grass) = 18 400 (1). Efficiency = 900 ÷ 18 400 × 100 = 4.891... = 4.9% (1).
Why: The two numbers are labelled before they are used, and the first mark is for choosing them. The second mark is for the calculation rounded to 1 decimal place, as asked. There is no unit, because a percentage has none. The answer is below 100%, which is sensible, since energy is lost at each transfer.
Check: if your efficiency is above 100%, you divided the wrong way round.
Step 3: your turn 24 min
Use the six steps in every part. Choose your numbers from the tables, label them, and show your working. You need a calculator.
-
Hollin Meadow is a hay meadow in northern England, with an area of 2.5 hectares. The food chain is meadow plants → voles and insects → shrews and frogs → kestrels. Use both tables in parts 1 to 8.
Producers of Hollin Meadow, a hay meadow, each year Energy measure Value Light energy reaching the meadow 4 100 MJ m−2 year−1 Gross primary productivity (GPP) 63 000 kJ m−2 year−1 Energy lost by the plants in respiration (R) 27 000 kJ m−2 year−1 Energy flow in the consumers of Hollin Meadow (kJ m−2 year−1) Consumers Eaten Lost in faeces Lost in respiration New biomass Primary (voles and insects) 11 400 3 900 4 400 3 100 Secondary (shrews and frogs) 2 450 430 1 500 520 Tertiary (kestrels) 410 60 290 60 Calculate the net primary productivity (NPP) of the meadow plants. Use the frame. (2)
FormulaSubstituteAnswer and unit Calculate the GPP as a percentage of the light energy that reaches the meadow. Give your answer to 1 decimal place. (3)
Calculate the percentage efficiency of energy transfer from the meadow plants to the primary consumers. Use the energy stored as new biomass. Give your answer to 1 decimal place. (2)
Calculate the percentage of the energy in the new biomass of the primary consumers that is stored in the new biomass of the kestrels. Give your answer to 2 significant figures. (2)
In a later year, the kestrels stored 45 kJ m−2 year−1 in new biomass. Calculate the percentage change in the energy stored by the kestrels. Write "increase" or "decrease" in your answer. (3)
(a) For the primary consumers, write the energy lost in faeces : the energy lost in respiration : the energy stored in new biomass as a ratio, with the energy stored in new biomass as 1. Give each number to 1 decimal place. (b) Write the ratio of the NPP of the meadow plants to the energy stored in new biomass by the kestrels, in the form x : 1. (a) is 2 marks and (b) is 2 marks. (4)
(a) Calculate the total NPP of the whole meadow in one year. Give your answer in MJ. 1 hectare is 10 000 m². (b) Calculate the energy stored by the kestrels in each square metre in one day. Give your answer to 2 significant figures, with its unit. (a) is 3 marks and (b) is 2 marks. (5)
(a) Calculate the percentage efficiency of energy transfer from the primary consumers to the secondary consumers. Use the energy stored as new biomass. Give your answer to 1 decimal place. (b) Compare your answer with your answer to part 3. Use worked figures from the tables to explain the difference. (a) is 1 mark and (b) is 3 marks. (4)
Mark scheme
1 NPP, step by step (2)
- NPP = GPP − R / 63 000 − 27 000 (1)
- 36 000 kJ m−2 year−1 (1)
- ACCEPT kJ m−2 yr−1
- DO NOT ACCEPT 36 000 kJ or 36 000 with no unit for the second point: NPP is a rate, so the unit needs energy, area and time (our rule, because the frame asks for the unit)
- A correct answer with no working gains full marks
2 Light to GPP (3)
- 4 100 MJ = 4 100 000 kJ (× 1000) (1)
- 63 000 ÷ 4 100 000 × 100 (1)
- 1.5 (%) (1)
- Working in kJ is needed for the first point. Without the conversion, 63 000 ÷ 4 100 × 100 gives 1 537%, which is 1000 times too big and more than 100%: no marks
- DO NOT ACCEPT 1.54 or 1.5366 for the last point: 1 decimal place was asked
- A correct answer of 1.5 with no working gains all 3 marks
3 Efficiency, producers to primary consumers (2)
- 3 100 ÷ 36 000 × 100 (1)
- 8.6 (%) (1)
- ALLOW ecf from the NPP in part 1
- DO NOT ACCEPT 27.2% (3 100 ÷ 11 400): the lower level is the plants, not the energy eaten
- DO NOT ACCEPT 8.61 or 8.611...: 1 decimal place was asked
- A correct answer of 8.6 with no working gains 2 marks
4 Efficiency over two steps (2)
- 60 ÷ 3 100 × 100 (1)
- 1.9 (%) (1)
- The higher level is the kestrels (60) and the lower level is the primary consumers (3 100): the middle level is skipped
- DO NOT ACCEPT 11.5 (60 ÷ 520 × 100): the kestrels from the secondary consumers
- DO NOT ACCEPT 1.94 or 1.935: 2 significant figures were asked
5 Percentage change (3)
- 45 − 60 = −15 (the change) (1)
- −15 ÷ 60 × 100 (divided by the original value) (1)
- 25% decrease / −25% (1)
- ACCEPT 25 with the word "decrease"
- DO NOT ACCEPT 33% (15 ÷ 45): the change is divided by the original value, 60, taken from the table
- Our rule: the question asks for the word, so 25 with no sign or word gains max 2
- A correct answer of 25% decrease with no working gains 3 marks
6 Ratios (4): 2 for (a), 2 for (b)
- (a) 3 900 : 4 400 : 3 100 chosen, in that order / each divided by 3 100 (1)
- (a) 1.3 : 1.4 : 1 (1)
- (b) 36 000 : 60 / 36 000 ÷ 60 (1)
- (b) 600 : 1 (1)
- (a) ACCEPT 1.26 : 1.42 : 1
- (a) DO NOT ACCEPT 39 : 44 : 31 for the second point: one number must be 1
- (b) ALLOW ecf from the NPP in part 1
- (b) DO NOT ACCEPT 1 : 600 (wrong order)
- DO NOT ACCEPT a unit: ratios have no units
7 Whole meadow and one day (5): 3 for (a), 2 for (b)
- (a) 2.5 ha = 25 000 m² (1)
- (a) 36 000 × 25 000 = 900 000 000 kJ (9.0 × 108 kJ) (1)
- (a) 900 000 MJ (9.0 × 105 MJ) (1)
- (b) 60 ÷ 365 (1)
- (b) 0.16 kJ m−2 day−1 (1)
- (a) ALLOW ecf from the NPP in part 1
- (a) A correct answer of 900 000 MJ with no working gains 3 marks
- (a) An answer in kJ with no conversion to MJ: max 2
- (b) DO NOT ACCEPT 0.164 or 0.1644: 2 significant figures were asked
- (b) The unit must have area and time. ACCEPT kJ m−2 d−1
8 Two transfers compared (4): 1 for (a), max 3 for (b)
- (a) 520 ÷ 3 100 × 100 = 16.8 (%) (1)
- (b) the transfer from the plants is about half as efficient (8.6% against 16.8%) (1)
- (b) a smaller share of the plants' energy is eaten: 11 400 of the NPP of 36 000 (32%), against 2 450 of the 3 100 in the primary consumers (79%) (1)
- (b) much of a plant is not eaten, such as roots and tough stems, or it dies and passes to decomposers (1)
- (b) a larger share of plant food is lost in faeces: 3 900 of 11 400 (34%), against 430 of 2 450 (18%) (1)
- (b) because plant cell walls contain cellulose, which is hard to digest (1)
- (a) DO NOT ACCEPT 16.77 or 17: 1 decimal place was asked
- (b) A point from the data needs a worked figure, a percentage or a fraction, not two numbers copied
- (b) DO NOT ACCEPT "the primary consumers lose more energy in respiration": the secondary consumers lose a larger share in respiration (1 500 of 2 450, 61%) than the primary consumers (4 400 of 11 400, 39%)
- (b) DO NOT ACCEPT "energy is used up": it is transferred to the surroundings as heat
- (b) ALLOW ecf from part 3
- Max 3 for (b)
Self-marking checklist 4 min
Before you hand in, check that:
- for each part you wrote down the question word (percentage, ratio, rate or change) and how to round;
- you labelled the two numbers you chose from the tables, and did not use a number from the wrong column or level;
- you converted units before you calculated, and put numbers into every formula you wrote;
- every answer is rounded as asked, and has its unit, sign or the word "increase" or "decrease" where one is needed.
After you hand in, the mark schemes open. Then:
- tick each mark point you earned, including marks for the choice of numbers when your final answer was wrong;
- for each slip in rounding, units or choice of numbers, rewrite the last two lines of your working in a different colour;
- write your total out of 25, and one target, for example: "I will label the higher and lower level before I divide."