The Chromozone / IAL Biology / Unit 4 / Topic 5
Directed study: climate models and their effects on living things
Independent study after the lesson Climate models and the effects of climate change. Sections A to D are on this lesson; Section E looks back at the two lessons before it, evidence for climate change and greenhouse gases and the carbon cycle, and at ecology. The spec point in brackets tells you where to revise. It takes about 40 minutes (27 marks), and you need a calculator. Type your answer in the box under each question, then press Hand in at the bottom of the page. The mark schemes open after you hand in: then give yourself a tick for each point you included. Teachers: this is the page to set as homework.
Teach these first
This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:
Section A: Extrapolation and climate models (5 marks) 8 min
1. A research institute models the rise in temperature in one region using weather station data from 1960 to 2020. By extrapolating this straight-line trend, they predict a local rise of 2.5 °C by 2080.
- (a) State one assumption made when a straight-line trend is extrapolated in climate modelling. (1)
- (b) Explain why relying only on extrapolation makes predictions of climate trends over many decades uncertain. (2)
Check your answer to question 1
A1(a) Assumption (1)
- the past trend will continue at the same rate in the future (1)
- ACCEPT the trend stays the same / no new factors change it
A1(b) Uncertainty (2)
- unexpected events can change emissions: new technology, policy or an economic crash (1)
- small errors grow over decades, so long-range predictions are less reliable (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "the data are wrong"
Section A, question 2
- Explain why climate models give a wide range of predicted results (such as temperature "envelopes") rather than one exact value for the year 2100. (2)
Check your answer to question 2
A2 (2)
- models use different possible futures (emission scenarios) (1)
- different models treat feedbacks, such as melting ice or clouds, differently (1)
Section B: Data analysis (5 marks) 8 min
A long-term study followed the moss campion (Silene acaulis), an alpine flowering plant, on a mountain range in central Europe from 1970 to 2020. Over these 50 years, the lower edge of its range moved 180 m up the mountain, and the upper edge moved 120 m up.
- Calculate the change in the vertical width of the band of mountain where this species lives over the 50 years. (2)
Check your answer to question 1
B1 (2)
- difference between the two shifts: 180 − 120 (1)
- so the band is 60 m narrower (a net change of −60 m) (1)
- NB the correct answer, 60 m, gains both marks
- ALLOW −60 m or 60 m narrower
Section B, question 2
- Use your knowledge of species distribution and climate change to explain why alpine plants face a high risk of "mountaintop extinction" when they are forced to shift their range up the mountain. (3)
Check your answer to question 2
B2 (3)
- warming forces the species to move higher, to cooler places (1)
- at the summit there is nowhere higher or cooler to go (1)
- less space and new competitors, so populations fall and may die out (1)
Section C: Seasonal cycles and timing in a food chain (4 marks) 7 min
In an oak woodland, warmer springs make oak buds open, and winter moth caterpillars hatch, 14 days earlier than the long-term average. Pied flycatchers migrate from Africa to breed in the woodland, and they time their arrival by day length, which does not change.
- (a) Name the term used for a mismatch between the time when a consumer breeds and the time when its food is most plentiful. (1)
- (b) Explain the biological consequences of this mismatch for the breeding success of the pied flycatcher. (3)
Check your answers to Section C
C(a) Term (1)
- mismatch in timing (trophic or phenological mismatch) (1)
- ACCEPT phenological mismatch / trophic mismatch
C(b) Consequences (3)
- caterpillars hatch earlier, but flycatchers arrive on fixed day-length cues (1)
- chicks hatch after the caterpillar peak, so food is scarce (1)
- chicks starve or fledge underweight, so fewer survive and the population falls (1)
Section D: Applying your knowledge: extended writing (5 marks) 10 min
In Jordan, climate change is expected to change rainfall patterns: some projections give 30% less rainfall by 2100. Rising temperatures will also increase the rate of transpiration from crops.
- Your task: write a structured answer (about 120 to 150 words) to advise the agriculture ministry how the changes in rainfall and temperature will affect plant development, crop yields and local food security. (5)
Check your answer to Section D
D Mark scheme (5): one mark for each point
- 30% less rain means less water in the soil (1)
- higher temperatures increase transpiration, so crops suffer water stress (1)
- stomata close, so less CO2 is taken in: lower GPP and lower yields (1)
- warmer conditions speed up pest lifecycles, so more crop damage (1)
- food security is at risk; adapt with drought-resistant crops or efficient irrigation (1)
- ACCEPT any other correct effect on plant development, yield or food supply
Section E: Looking back (8 marks) 7 min
Spaced practice from earlier lessons in this unit: answer from memory first, then check your notes.
- Explain why scientists use several different temperature proxies, such as ice cores, tree rings and pollen in peat, rather than just one. (5.16) (2)
- Give two reasons why the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has risen since about 1800. (5.17) (2)
- Explain how carbon capture and storage (CCS) at a power station reduces the amount of carbon dioxide added to the atmosphere. (5.18) (2)
- Name two abiotic factors that climate change alters, and explain how one of them could change where a plant species grows. (5.12) (2)
Check your answers to Section E
E1 Several proxies (2)
- each proxy has its own limits and errors (1)
- if independent methods agree, the conclusion is more reliable (1)
E2 Rising carbon dioxide (2)
- burning fossil fuels: coal, oil and gas (combustion) (1)
- deforestation: burning forests, and fewer trees to photosynthesise (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "pollution" or "factories" with no detail
E3 Carbon capture and storage (2)
- carbon dioxide is captured where it is made, before it is released (1)
- it is stored deep underground, for example in old gas fields (1)
E4 Abiotic factors (2)
- two of: temperature, rainfall (water in the soil), sea level (1)
- for example: warmer, so it can grow further north or higher up (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT a biotic factor
Your score
Total: 27 marks (Section A 5, Section B 5, Section C 4, Section D 5, Section E 8). Write your score for each section in your notebook, and note one point you missed to revise before the next lesson.