The Chromozone / IAL Biology / Unit 4 / Topic 5
Directed study
Directed study: what colour is the light that feeds a plant?
Real experiments and real uses of light and pigments: Engelmann's bacteria, autumn leaves and LED farms, linked to the light-dependent reactions and the Calvin cycle. 28 marks. It takes about 35 minutes and is worth 28 marks. Work through it on your own after the lesson on pigments, spectra and chromatography. Type your answers in the boxes, then hand them in at the bottom of the page. The mark schemes open after you hand in: then mark yourself point by point and correct your work in a different colour. The spec point in brackets after a question tells you where to revise. Teachers: this is the page to set as homework.
Teach these first
This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
Part A: retrieval (6 marks) 6 min
Answer from memory first. The spec point is in brackets after each question.
A1. An absorption spectrum and an action spectrum often have a similar shape, but they measure different things. State what is plotted on the y-axis of each graph. (5.6) (2)
A2. Name the pigment at the reaction centre of a photosystem, and describe what happens to it when light energy reaches it. (5.6, 5.3) (2)
A3. State where in a chloroplast the photosynthetic pigments are found, and explain why this place suits the light-dependent reactions. (5.5) (2)
Check your answers to part A
A1 (2)
- Absorption spectrum: the amount (percentage) of light absorbed by a pigment, at each wavelength (1)
- Action spectrum: the rate of photosynthesis, at each wavelength (1)
A2 (2)
- Chlorophyll a (1)
- It is excited and releases (loses) a high-energy electron, which passes to an electron carrier (1)
A3 (2)
- In the thylakoid membranes (of the grana) (1)
- Close to the electron carriers and ATP synthase in the same membrane, with a huge membrane area to absorb light (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "in the stroma"
Part B: a real experiment from 1882 (5 marks) 7 min
In 1882 the German scientist Theodor Engelmann wanted to know which colours of light plants use for photosynthesis. He had no oxygen meter. Instead he used living bacteria that swim towards oxygen.
He laid a long filament of a green alga, Cladophora, on a microscope slide in water with the bacteria. A glass prism split white light into a spectrum, so each part of the filament received a different colour. After a few minutes he looked to see where the bacteria had gathered.
B1. Explain why the bacteria gathered above the parts of the filament lit by blue and by red light. (5.6) (3)
B2. Engelmann's results were the first action spectrum, not an absorption spectrum. Explain why. (5.6) (1)
B3. Suggest one reason why counting bacteria gives only a rough measure of the rate of photosynthesis. (5.6, 5.8) (1)
Check your answers to part B
B1 (3)
- Chlorophyll absorbs blue and red light most (and green least) (1)
- So the alga photosynthesised fastest where it was lit by blue and red light (1)
- Photosynthesis (photolysis of water) releases oxygen, and the bacteria swam towards the higher oxygen concentration (1)
B2 (1)
- He measured how well each wavelength drove photosynthesis (the oxygen released), not how much light the pigments absorbed (1)
B3 (1): max 1
- Bacteria also move for other reasons, or move randomly (1)
- Oxygen diffuses away from where it is made, so the edges blur (1)
- He could not count the bacteria exactly: it gives a pattern, not a number (1)
- The bacteria use some of the oxygen in respiration (1)
Part C: why leaves turn yellow in autumn (6 marks) 8 min
In countries with cold winters, many trees lose their leaves in autumn. Before a leaf falls, it turns from green to yellow or orange. A student made a chromatogram of a green leaf and of a yellow leaf from the same tree.
| Spot colour | Green leaf: distance moved / cm | Yellow autumn leaf: distance moved / cm |
|---|---|---|
| Yellow | 8.5 | 8.5 |
| Yellow-brown | 6.4 | 6.4 |
| Blue-green | 5.8 | no spot |
| Green | 4.1 | no spot |
| Pigment | Rf |
|---|---|
| Carotene | 0.95 |
| Xanthophyll | 0.71 |
| Chlorophyll a | 0.65 |
| Chlorophyll b | 0.45 |
C1. Calculate the Rf values of the two spots on the chromatogram of the yellow leaf, and name the two pigments. (5.7) (2)
C2. Name the pigments that are missing from the yellow leaf. (5.7) (1)
C3. A yellow leaf still has some pigments, but it photosynthesises far less than a green leaf. Explain why. (5.6, 5.3) (2)
C4. Chlorophyll molecules contain nitrogen and magnesium. Suggest why a tree breaks down the chlorophyll in its leaves before they fall. (5.6) (1)
Check your answers to part C
C1 (2)
- 8.5 ÷ 9.0 = 0.94: carotene (1)
- 6.4 ÷ 9.0 = 0.71: xanthophyll (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT an answer with a unit
C2 (1)
- Chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b (both needed) (1)
C3 (2)
- There is no chlorophyll a, the pigment at the reaction centre, so few electrons are excited / no light-dependent reactions (1)
- Carotenoids absorb only blue (and some green) light, not red, so much less light energy is absorbed; they can only pass energy on to chlorophyll a (1)
C4 (1)
- To take the nitrogen and magnesium back into the tree (and store them) before the leaf is lost, so it can reuse them next year (1)
Part D: exam-style questions (7 marks) 9 min
Vertical farms grow salad crops indoors on shelves, under LED lights. A grower tested lettuces under five kinds of LED light, all at the same light intensity.
| Light colour | Mean rate of photosynthesis / µmol O2 m−2 s−1 | Mean dry mass per plant / g |
|---|---|---|
| Red (660 nm) | 17 | 8.9 |
| Blue (450 nm) | 15 | 7.6 |
| Green (530 nm) | 6 | 3.0 |
| White | 15 | 7.9 |
| Red and blue mixed | 19 | 10.2 |
D1. Explain the results shown in the table. (5.6, 5.3) (4)
D2. Explain how a higher rate of photosynthesis leads to a greater dry mass of the lettuces. (5.4) (3)
Check your answers to part D
D1 (4): max 4
- Red and blue light give the highest rates (17 and 15) and dry masses (8.9 and 7.6 g) (1)
- because chlorophyll (a and b) absorbs red and blue light most (1)
- Green light gives the lowest rate (6) and dry mass (3.0 g) because most green light is reflected or transmitted, not absorbed (1)
- But not zero: accessory pigments (carotenoids) absorb some light at the edges of the green, and pass the energy on to chlorophyll a (1)
- Red and blue mixed is best (19, 10.2 g): it covers both absorption peaks of chlorophyll (and blue is also absorbed by carotenoids), so more of the light is absorbed (1)
- White light gives less than red at the same intensity because part of it is green light, which is hardly absorbed (1)
- More light absorbed gives more ATP and reduced NADP for the Calvin cycle, so more sugar for growth (1)
- NB quote figures from the table; naming colours alone gets no mark
D2 (3): max 3
- More carbon dioxide is fixed: more GP is reduced to GALP (1)
- GALP is used to make glucose, then sucrose, starch and cellulose (new cell walls) (1)
- GALP is also made into amino acids (with nitrate) and proteins, and into lipids (1)
- These new molecules build new cells, so the dry mass (biomass) rises (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "glucose is carried in the phloem"
Part E: linking the lessons (4 marks) 5 min
This question links the light-dependent reactions (5.3), the Calvin cycle (5.4) and the chloroplast (5.5).
E1. Some weedkillers stop electrons passing from photosystem II to the electron carriers in the thylakoid membrane. Explain why a weed sprayed with this weedkiller soon stops making sugars, even in bright light. (5.3, 5.4) (4)
Check your answers to part E
E1 (4): max 4
- No electrons flow along the carriers, so non-cyclic photophosphorylation stops (1)
- So no reduced NADP is made (NADP is not reduced at photosystem I) (1)
- And much less ATP is made (no proton gradient for ATP synthase) (1)
- Without ATP and reduced NADP, GP cannot be reduced to GALP in the stroma (1)
- And RuBP is not regenerated, so carbon dioxide is not fixed and no sugars (glucose) are made (1)
- DO NOT ACCEPT "NADP" for reduced NADP