Say this Teacher only · not on the projector
Set a 20-minute timer. Before the lesson, print one set of 10 cards per group of four, mix them, and place three zone signs (Fair, Unfair, Unfair but not covered) on three tables or floor spaces. Put students into mixed groups of four. Explain: "Groups carry each card to a zone. For an unfair card, you must also say which protected characteristic it involves."
Round 1 (about 13 minutes): groups read the cards and move them. Walk round and prompt rather than answer: "What would happen if the same thing happened to someone else?", "Is there a fair reason?", "Does the rule treat everyone the same, but have a worse effect on someone?" Remind them to use the case characters' names, not themselves or classmates.
Round 2 (about 7 minutes): reveal answers one card at a time, or have groups walk round and look at one other group's zones, then gather as a class. Take the hard cards: Tom (no reasonable adjustment), Sam (adjustment), Jess (positive action), Ben and Mia (unfair but not covered). Ask: "Why is Ben's treatment wrong even though the Equality Act does not cover it?" (It is still unfair: a good rule is to treat people fairly even when the law does not require it.)
Make the difference clear between treating people the same and treating people fairly. Close with: "Spotting unfairness is a skill. Next time you see something that looks wrong, ask: is there a fair reason, and is a protected characteristic involved?" Thank every group.
Support: give struggling groups the nine characteristics on the board (slide 4) and ask them to start with the cards with names they find easiest. Stretch: ask fast groups to suggest what Tom's club could do to fix the problem (move the room, a ramp or lift).
Watch for
Students may recognise someone in a card. Remind them: the cards are made-up case characters. If a student seems upset, check quietly after the activity.
Card 8 involves sexual orientation, card 3 religion and card 10 race. Keep the language factual. If a student uses the word from card 8 as an insult in the discussion, stop calmly: "We are discussing it because it is a problem. We do not use it that way here."
Disclosures: students sometimes realise what happened to them has a name. Thank them, do not question them in front of the class, and follow the school safeguarding policy.
Answers at a glance
| Card | Zone | Characteristic and why |
|---|
| 1 Tom | Unfair | Disability. A failure to make reasonable adjustments, which the law counts as discrimination: the club must make changes so Tom can take part, such as moving the room or adding a ramp or lift. |
| 2 Mia | Unfair but not covered | Being new is not a protected characteristic. It is still unkind, and a school should deal with it. |
| 3 Amira | Unfair | Religion or belief. Direct discrimination. |
| 4 Sam | Fair | A reasonable adjustment for a disability. It gives Sam an equal chance, so it is not special treatment. |
| 5 Lena | Unfair | Sex. Direct discrimination based on a stereotype. |
| 6 Ben | Unfair but not covered | Football team is not a protected characteristic. It is still unfair. |
| 7 Luis | Fair | An age rating has a protective reason. Age can be a protected characteristic, but there is a fair reason here. |
| 8 Ellis | Unfair | Sexual orientation (he is treated as if he were gay: the law covers how others see someone too). This is prejudice-based bullying. |
| 9 Jess | Fair | Positive action to help girls join in. Everyone else can still use the normal sessions. It involves sex, but it is aimed at fixing a gap. |
| 10 Ravi | Unfair | Race (nationality, ethnic or national origin). Prejudice-based bullying online. |