The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology
Self-study: Micro-Asch research design scaffold
Teach these first
This page builds on this lesson. Teach it before students start here:
Step 1 key words
- Directional (one-tailed) hypothesis
- A prediction that says which way the results will go, for example more errors in one condition than in the other.
- Operationalisation
- Defining a variable in clear, measurable terms, so it can be tested objectively.
- Independent variable (IV) and dependent variable (DV)
- The IV is what you change (here: a unanimous wrong majority, or no group). The DV is what you measure (here: the number of wrong answers that match the group).
Step 1: aim and experimental hypothesis (2 marks) 8 min
Write an operationalised directional (one-tailed) experimental hypothesis for your study. (1.2.4) (2)
Hint: predict how many times participants will conform to the unanimous wrong majority when they judge line lengths, compared with a control condition (people who do the task alone).
Reveal the model answer and mark scheme: Step 1
Step 1: hypothesis (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for a clear direction and one mark for the IV and DV operationalised. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- A clear direction: more matching wrong answers with the majority than alone (1)
- IV and DV both operationalised, for example "wrong answers out of 4 critical trials" (1)
Model answer: "Participants who hear a unanimous wrong majority will give more wrong answers that match the confederates (out of 4 critical trials) than participants who do the task alone, with no confederates."
Step 2 key words
- Target population
- The group of people the sample is taken from, and to whom the findings should apply.
- Opportunity sampling
- Choosing people who are available at the time and willing to take part.
- Random sampling
- Every member of the target population has an equal chance of being chosen.
Step 2: target population and sampling technique (3 marks) 8 min
Your target population is the students in another class at your school. Select a sampling technique (for example opportunity or random sampling), then explain one strength and one weakness of using it for your target class. (1.2.5) (3)
TechniqueStrengthWeakness
Reveal the model answer and mark scheme: Step 2
Step 2: sampling (3)
AO2 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for naming a sampling technique suited to the target class and one mark for each point explaining a strength and a weakness of it. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- A sampling technique named, for example opportunity sampling (1)
- Strength explained, linked to running the study (for example quick, easy) (1)
- Weakness explained, linked to bias or representativeness (1)
Model answer (opportunity sampling): Strength: it is quick and cheap to ask students from the class next door during a free period, with no need for a full class list first. Weakness: they may all share features (same age, same teaching set), so the sample is biased and may not represent the whole school.
Step 3: materials and experimental procedure (3 marks) 10 min
Materials: say what line cards or slides you will make (the standard line and the comparison lines). Procedure: outline, step by step, how a trial will run. On how many trials will the confederates give the wrong answer? How will you tell the confederates what to say without the participant noticing? (1.1.5) (3)
Stretch and challenge: standardised instructions (2 marks) 4 min
Stretch and challenge: explain how you will make sure every participant gets the same standardised instructions, to avoid experimenter bias or demand characteristics. (2)
Reveal the model answer and mark scheme: Step 3
Step 3: materials and procedure (3)
AO2 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each accurate part of the procedure that fits the design. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- Materials: clear stimuli, for example 6 slides of line X with lines A, B and C (1)
- Trial count: for example 6 trials, 4 of them critical (wrong answer) (1)
- Confederates briefed in secret, for example a cue card before they come in (1)
Model answer: Six slides, each showing standard line X next to comparison lines A, B and C. The lengths differ clearly, so the right answer is obvious. Each participant does 6 trials; on 4 critical trials the confederates all give the same planned wrong answer out loud. Before they come in, the confederates get a cue card with their answer for each trial number, so the researcher never has to give them a sign during the test.
Step 3: stretch (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for the method and one mark for its purpose. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- Read the same written script to every participant, word for word (1)
- So the researcher's tone or hints cannot change the answers (standardised) (1)
Step 4 key words
- Extraneous variable
- Any variable other than the IV that could affect the DV if it is not controlled. It can make the results wrong or unclear.
- Standardisation
- Keeping everything the same for every participant, apart from the IV.
Step 4: controlling extraneous variables (4 marks) 10 min
Identify two possible extraneous variables (for example lighting, room noise, where people sit, or participants talking to each other before the test). Explain how you will control each one, so the study is standardised. (4)
Variable 1How I will control itVariable 2How I will control it
Reveal the model answer and mark scheme: Step 4
Step 4: extraneous variables (4)
AO2 (4 marks)
Credit one mark for each extraneous variable identified and one mark for each control for it. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- Variable 1, for example tested participants telling the next ones (1)
- Control 1: keep tested participants apart until everyone is done (1)
- Variable 2, for example where people sit (1)
- Control 2: same seat, the same distance (for example 2 metres) from the screen (1)
Credit any two sensible variables, each with a practical control.
Look for other reasonable marking points.
Step 5 key words: BPS principles
- Informed consent
- Participants are told what the research involves, and agree before they take part.
- Right to withdraw
- Participants can stop at any time, and take their data out, with no penalty.
- Deception
- Misleading participants about the true aim. It must be justified, and kept as small as possible.
- Debriefing
- Telling participants everything about the study afterwards, so they leave feeling as they did before it.
Step 5: ethical considerations (BPS guidelines) (3 marks) 10 min
Using the British Psychological Society (BPS) code of ethics and conduct (2009), explain how you will deal with (1) informed consent and the right to withdraw: how will you brief participants without spoiling the deception? and (2) deception and debriefing: Asch's method depends on misleading people about the line answers, so how will you debrief the students afterwards so that they leave with no distress? (1.2.9) (3)
Consent and right to withdrawDeception and debrief
Reveal the model answer and mark scheme: Step 5
Step 5: ethics (3)
AO2 (3 marks)
Credit one mark for each ethical step that fits the design. Generic answers score 0 marks.
- Consent for a "vision task", with the right to withdraw made clear (1)
- Debrief straight after: the true aim and the confederates revealed (1)
- Reassure them that conforming is normal, and answer their questions (1)
Model answer: Ask for consent to a "visual perception task", and say clearly that taking part is voluntary and that anyone can stop, or remove their data, at any time. Straight after the test, read a standard debrief: explain the real aim (social influence), reveal the confederates, say that going along with a group is completely normal, and answer any questions, so nobody leaves embarrassed.
Anyone under 16 also needs a parent's consent. Ask your teacher before you test another class.
You tried a quick Micro-Asch at the start of the lesson. If your teacher sets it, you can run this full design later in the Micro-Asch practical investigation, after the lesson on evaluating Asch.