The Chromozone / IAL Psychology / Topic A: Social psychology
Directed study: write up your social practical
Teach these first
This page builds on these lessons. Teach them before students start here:
For teachers: marking this page
Teacher note: this sheet is the write-up that groups start at the end of part 2. Each student writes their own report from the group's frames and tables; the numbers may be shared, the sentences should be their own.
Teacher note: the mark schemes list what each part must contain, not a model answer, because every group ran a different study. Check the details against the group's part 1 frames and part 2 tables. The drawn graph in 4(b) is checked by you on paper.
Teacher note: this sheet is 30 marks for the procedure, results and discussion. For the full report (abstract, introduction, references and appendices) use Laura's 40-mark rubric in the teacher area.
How to use this page
This page is the write-up of your own group's questionnaire study, in the order of a real report. When every box is full, you have your practical report.
Each part gives you what goes here, sentence starters and a checklist. Finish the starters with your own details: there is no model answer to copy.
Have ready: your part 1 frames and recording table, your part 2 calculations, graph and themes, and squared paper. Write in the past tense. The full seven-step guide has more detail.
1. Title and aim (1 mark) 2 min
Write the title of your report and the aim of your study. (1.4.1) (1) (about 30 words)
What goes here: A title that says what you compared, and one sentence saying what you set out to find out.
Sentence starters:
- Title: A comparison of ... and ... in their self-reported ...
- The aim of this study was to investigate whether ... and ... differ in ...
It must include:
- both groups (or both kinds of scenario) named
- the score you measured
- the word "whether", not a prediction
Reveal the mark scheme: section 1
1 Title and aim (1)
AO2 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for a title and an aim for the group's own study.
- A title and an aim that name both groups (or kinds of scenario) and the score of your own study, matching your part 1 step 1 (1)
An aim says what you set out to find out. A prediction belongs in the hypothesis.
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
2. Hypotheses (3 marks) 3 min
Write your alternative hypothesis. Say whether it is directional or non-directional, and why. (1.2.4) (2) (about 50 words)
What goes here: Your prediction about the difference, and the reason you chose its form.
Sentence starters:
- Our alternative hypothesis was that there would be a difference in ... (the total score out of ...) between ... and ...
- This hypothesis is [directional / non-directional] because ...
It must include:
- both groups named
- the score, with its top mark
- the direction (or a clear statement that there is none)
- a reason: earlier research for a directional one, or research that points both ways for a non-directional one
Write your null hypothesis. (1.2.4) (1) (about 25 words)
What goes here: The statement that there is no difference, which any difference you found might be due to.
Sentence starters:
- Our null hypothesis was that there would be no difference in ... between ... and ..., and any difference would be due to chance.
It must include:
- no difference between the groups on your score
- the words "due to chance"
Reveal the mark scheme: section 2
2(a) Alternative hypothesis (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for a testable alternative hypothesis and one mark for its form and reason.
- A testable hypothesis that names both groups and the score, with the direction that matches your aim (or none, if non-directional) (1)
- Directional or non-directional stated, with a reason that fits (a directional one needs a reason from earlier research) (1)
It must match your part 1 step 1.
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
2(b) Null hypothesis (1)
AO2 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for a null hypothesis for the group's own study.
- No difference between your two groups on your score, with any difference put down to chance (1)
Reject all other answers.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
3. Method (8 marks) 12 min
Describe your target population, your sampling technique and your sample. (1.2.5) (2) (about 60 words)
What goes here: Who your results should apply to, how you found people, and who took part.
Sentence starters:
- The target population was ... We used ... sampling: we ... (where and how)
- The sample was ... participants: ... in group 1 and ... in group 2, aged ...
It must include:
- the sampling technique named, and what you did
- the number in each group
- who they were (age, school year, anything else relevant)
Describe your questionnaire: the closed questions and the rating scale, the reversed item, and the open question. (1.2.1, 1.2.3) (3) (about 90 words)
What goes here: What a reader would need to make your questionnaire. Put the full questionnaire in your appendix.
Sentence starters:
- The questionnaire had ... closed questions. Each described a scenario and was rated from ... to ... (for example, ...)
- Item ... was reversed: it asked how likely a person was to ..., and was scored ...
- A person's score was the total of ..., from ... to ... The open question was: "..."
It must include:
- the scenarios and the rating scale
- the reversed item and the rule for scoring it
- the open question word for word
- where the group question was placed
Describe your procedure step by step, from the pilot to the debrief. (1.4.1) (1) (about 90 words)
What goes here: A numbered list of what happened, so that someone else could repeat it.
Sentence starters:
- 1. We piloted ... on ... and changed ...
- 2. Each participant was given the brief and ...
- 3. They then ... on their own, in ... minutes.
- Finally, they were debriefed and ...
It must include:
- the steps in order, in the past tense
- the pilot and what it changed
- where and how long they answered, and how their answers were kept
Describe two ethical steps you took, and how each protected participants. (1.2.9) (2) (about 70 words)
What goes here: How you protected the people who took part.
Sentence starters:
- To get informed consent, we ...
- To protect confidentiality, we ...
- After the questionnaire we debriefed them by ... and told them they could withdraw by ...
It must include:
- two different steps, each saying what you did
- consent, the right to withdraw, confidentiality, protection from harm or the debrief
- why each step protected the participants
Reveal the mark scheme: section 3
3(a) Participants and sampling (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for the sampling technique and one mark for the sample.
- The sampling technique named and what your group did (where and how people were found) (1)
- The sample described: the number in each group and who they were (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
3(b) The questionnaire (3)
AO2 (3 marks)
Credit up to three marks for an accurate description of the group's own questionnaire.
- The closed questions as scenarios with the rating scale used (1)
- A reversed item, with how it was scored and how each total was worked out (1)
- The open question word for word (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
3(c) Procedure (1)
AO2 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for an accurate description of the group's own procedure.
- Steps in order, in the past tense, from the pilot to the debrief, with the timings, so that the study could be repeated (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
3(d) Ethics (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for each of two ethical steps, described as something the group did, with how it protected participants.
- One ethical step described as something you did, with how it protected participants (for example consent, the right to withdraw) (1)
- A second, different step described in the same way (for example confidentiality with codes, protection from harm, the debrief) (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
4. Results (8 marks) 12 min
Give a measure of central tendency and a measure of spread for each group. Say why you chose them. (1.2.6) (2) (from your own table)
What goes here: The numbers that summarise each group, taken from your part 2 summary table, and a reason for your choice.
Sentence starters:
- In group 1 the mean was ... and the standard deviation was ... In group 2 the mean was ... and the standard deviation was ...
- I used the [mean / median] because ...
It must include:
- a central figure and a spread figure for both groups
- each group named
- a reason: the mean for evenly spread scores, the median if a few are extreme
Group 1 (name it): mean or medianGroup 1: range or standard deviationGroup 2 (name it): mean or medianGroup 2: range or standard deviationWhy I chose theseDraw a bar chart of your two means on squared paper, and keep it with this sheet. Then write one sentence that reads a figure from it. (1.2.6) (2) (your own graph)
What goes here: A bar chart of the means, drawn by hand, and one sentence saying what it shows.
Sentence starters:
- Figure 1: The mean total score of ... and ...
- The graph shows that ... scored higher, with a mean of about ..., against about ... for ...
It must include:
- Title: says what the graph shows
- Axes: both labelled, the y-axis with the score and its top mark
- Scale: starts at 0, equal steps
- Bars: accurate heights, equal width, a gap between them, each labelled
Describe the difference between your groups, with figures. (1.2.6) (2) (about 70 words)
What goes here: Which group scored higher, by how much, how spread out each group was, and how far they overlap.
Sentence starters:
- ... scored higher (mean ...) than ... (mean ...), a gap of ... points.
- The scores for ... were more spread out (standard deviation ..., against ...), and ... of the ... people in the lower group scored above the lowest person in the higher group.
It must include:
- a figure for each group
- the gap, or a percentage
- the spread or the overlap
- the words "difference", not "proved"
Describe how you analysed the open answers, then give two themes, each with a quote. (1.2.8) (2) (about 90 words)
What goes here: What you did to the words, and what you found.
Sentence starters:
- We copied each answer word for word, read them all and gave each idea a code. We then grouped the codes into ... themes, and a second coder ...
- Theme 1: ... (codes: ...). For example, P... wrote: "..."
- Theme 2: ... (codes: ...). For example, P... wrote: "..."
It must include:
- the steps you took: read, coded, grouped
- two themes, each named
- a quote for each, word for word, with the participant code
Reveal the mark scheme: section 4
4(a) Summary table (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for the figures and one mark for the reason for the measures chosen.
- A central figure and a spread figure for both groups, from your own table, with each group named (1)
- A reason for the measures chosen, such as the mean for evenly spread scores or the median when a few scores are extreme (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
4(b) Graph (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for the graph and one mark for the sentence that reads a figure from it.
- A title, both axes labelled (the y-axis with the score and its top mark), a scale from 0 in equal steps, and accurate bars (your teacher checks this on your drawn graph) (1)
- A written sentence that reads a figure from your graph: which group was higher, and about how much (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
4(c) The difference in words (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for the comparison with figures and one mark for the spread or overlap.
- A figure for each group and the comparison: which scored higher, and the gap or a percentage (1)
- The spread or the overlap described, without claiming that the difference is proved (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
4(d) Thematic analysis (2)
AO2 (2 marks)
Credit one mark for the description of the analysis and one mark for two themes with quotes.
- How the answers were analysed: copied, read, coded and grouped into themes (and checked by a second coder, if you did) (1)
- Two themes named from your own answers, each with a word-for-word quote and the participant code (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
5. Discussion (10 marks) 11 min
Write your conclusion in words. (1.4.1) (2) (about 50 words)
What goes here: What the result means for your hypothesis, without repeating the numbers in a list.
Sentence starters:
- Our results [support / do not support] the alternative hypothesis, because ...
- This is a description of our sample of ..., so ...
It must include:
- a decision about your hypothesis that matches your figures
- which group scored higher, in words
- what the result can and cannot tell us
Link your result to a study or theory from Topic A. (1.1.1 to 1.1.7) (2) (about 60 words)
What goes here: How your result agrees or disagrees with earlier research.
Sentence starters:
- Our result [agrees / disagrees] with ... (year), who found ...
- One explanation is ... Another reason may be that our study used self-report, whereas ... measured what people did
It must include:
- a named study or theory (for example Milgram, Burger, Asch, agency theory or social impact theory)
- what it found or predicts
- a reason for the agreement or the difference
Explain one strength of your questionnaire study. (1.4.1) (2) (about 50 words)
What goes here: One good feature of what you did, and what it did for your findings.
Sentence starters:
- One strength of our study was ... This increased the [internal validity / reliability / generalisability] because ...
It must include:
- a feature of your own study
- validity, reliability or generalisability, and why
Explain one weakness of your questionnaire study. (1.4.1) (2) (about 50 words)
What goes here: One problem with what you did, and what it could have done to your results.
Sentence starters:
- One weakness was ... This could have changed the results because ...
It must include:
- a feature of your own study
- how it could have affected the scores or the themes
Suggest one improvement and say what it would change. (1.4.1) (2) (about 50 words)
What goes here: A change to your study, and its effect. A change is not the same as a weakness.
Sentence starters:
- To improve this, we could ... This would ... because ...
It must include:
- a specific change, not "be more careful"
- its effect on the results, the validity or the generalisability
Reveal the mark scheme: section 5
5(a) Conclusion (2)
AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for a decision about the hypothesis and one mark for what the result can and cannot tell us.
- A decision about your alternative hypothesis that matches your figures, with the higher group named (1)
- What the result can and cannot tell us: a description of your sample, not proof (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
5(b) Link to theory or research (2)
AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for a named study or theory and one mark for using it to explain the result.
- A named study or theory from Topic A, with what it found or predicts (1)
- Used to explain why your result agrees or differs (for example, self-report against real behaviour) (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
5(c) Strength (2)
AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for identifying a strength and one mark for justifying it.
- A strength of your own study (not one that fits any questionnaire) (1)
- Justified: what it did for internal validity, reliability or generalisability (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
5(d) Weakness (2)
AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for identifying a weakness and one mark for justifying it.
- A weakness of your own study (not one that fits any questionnaire) (1)
- Justified: how it could have changed the scores or the themes (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.
5(e) Improvement (2)
AO2 (1 mark), AO3 (1 mark)
Credit one mark for identifying one improvement and one mark for justifying it.
- A specific change to your own study (a change, not only a problem) (1)
- What the change would do to the results, the validity or the generalisability (1)
Generic answers score 0 marks.
Answers must relate to the social practical using a questionnaire to gather quantitative and qualitative data.